Skip to main content

PNE's strongest line-up?

PNE's strongest line-up?

pnd54 said:
After all the new signings and emergency loans, whats PNE's strongest formation and lineup?
Click to expand...

I would say:

----------------------LONERGAN---------------------

JONES--------MAWENE------ST LEDGER-----DAVIDSON

PARRY--------JAMES--------COUTTS--------WALLACE

---------------WELBECK------PARKIN-----------------
 
I don't rate Jones highly enough to play him with someone who's not defensively capable. I thought Jones was the worst player on the pitch for us last night, and he's not lived up to his reputation.

So from that I'd go with:
Lonergan
Hart Mawene St Ledger Davidson
Parry/Treacy/Sedgwick James Coutts Wallace
Parkin Welbeck​

I've been saying since Welbeck's arrival that Parkin is the ideal partner for him and us. Last night went some way to proving me right. I've not seen Treacy or Parry enough to give them a fair assessment.
 
lilywhiter10 said:
I don't rate Jones highly enough to play him with someone who's not defensively capable. I thought Jones was the worst player on the pitch for us last night, and he's not lived up to his reputation.

So from that I'd go with:
Lonergan
Hart Mawene St Ledger Davidson
Parry/Treacy/Sedgwick James Coutts Wallace
Parkin Welbeck​

I've been saying since Welbeck's arrival that Parkin is the ideal partner for him and us. Last night went some way to proving me right. I've not seen Treacy or Parry enough to give them a fair assessment.
Click to expand...
Hart is a terrible right back and not fit to lace jones boots in that position.......jones does make a terrible midfielder though...for me
Lonnergan
jones youl sledge davidson
parry chaplow (when motivated and fit) coutts wallace
Welbeck Parkin

subs james mellor collins treacy henderson Brown Nolan
 
flipper said:
Hart is a terrible right back and not fit to lace jones boots in that position.......jones does make a terrible midfielder though...for me
Lonnergan
jones youl sledge davidson
parry chaplow (when motivated and fit) coutts wallace
Welbeck Parkin

subs james mellor collins treacy henderson Brown Nolan
Click to expand...


Chaplow when motivated and fit is about once a month if we're lucky. James beats him hands down. I used to be a fan of Chappers but this season i've been hugely disappointed with him, a real let down just like Carter.
 
In fairness to Chaplow, hes been spot on defensively. However, I agree poor overall especially in attack
 
Last edited:
flipper said:
Hart is a terrible right back and not fit to lace jones boots in that position.......jones does make a terrible midfielder though...for me
Lonnergan
jones youl sledge davidson
parry chaplow (when motivated and fit) coutts wallace
Welbeck Parkin

subs james mellor collins treacy henderson Brown Nolan
Click to expand...

Hart is an excellent footballer. You are talking out of your ring surely????😱
 
Hart is an excellent defender, but is completely clueless when it comes to attacking. Slow to react, no vision, one dimensional, predictable, horrible passing, worse crossing, bad movement and poor communication.

Me and a mate were saying, as soon as he crosses the half way line, it's as if he has all his talent sucked out of him, ala Space Jam.
 
pnd54 said:
In fairness to Chaplow, hes been spot on defensively. However, I agree poor overall especially in attack
Click to expand...

Must watch a different game to you then. I always thought he never closed a man down and backed out of winnable tackles. Allowing forwards to have space and attack our defenders to score long range goals. Teams have been using it to great effect Vs us because nobody closes down their players.
 
Anyway I think:

Lonergan
Jones Youl Ledge Davidson
Parry James Coutts Wallace
Welbeck Parkin

subs Henderson Collins Nolan Miller Sedgwick Proctor Mellor
 
----------------------LONERGAN---------------------

JONES--------NOLAN------ST LEDGER-----DAVIDSON

SEGGERS--------JAMES--------COUTTS--------WALLACE

---------------WELBECK------PARKIN-----------------

Subs: Henderson, Mawene, Hart, Chaplow, Parry, Mellor, Brown.
 
dandinho said:
----------------------LONERGAN---------------------

JONES--------NOLAN------ST LEDGER-----DAVIDSON

SEGGERS--------JAMES--------COUTTS--------WALLACE

---------------WELBECK------PARKIN-----------------

Subs: Henderson, Mawene, Hart, Chaplow, Parry, Mellor, Brown.
Click to expand...

Anybody who picks Nolan obviously has not got a clue!!
 
boeoz said:
Hart is an excellent defender, but is completely clueless when it comes to attacking. Slow to react, no vision, one dimensional, predictable, horrible passing, worse crossing, bad movement and poor communication.

Me and a mate were saying, as soon as he crosses the half way line, it's as if he has all his talent sucked out of him, ala Space Jam.
Click to expand...
in all honesty, I think hes an awful defender, with his "attacking" play being what hes better at.

Funny isnt it.
 
----------------------LONERGAN---------------------

JONES--------MAWENE------ST LEDGER-----DAVIDSON

SEDGWICK--------JAMES--------COUTTS--------WALLACE

---------------WELBECK------PARKIN-----------------

Subs: Henderson, Nolan, Hart, Treacy, Parry, Mellor, Brown.
 
My starting XI:

----------------------LONERGAN---------------------

--JONES--------MAWENE------ST LEDGER-----NOLAN---

WELBECK-------CHAPLOW--------COUTTS------WALLACE

---------------MELLOR------PARKIN-----------------
 
nickfish90 said:
I would say:

----------------------LONERGAN---------------------

JONES--------MAWENE------ST LEDGER-----DAVIDSON

PARRY--------JAMES--------COUTTS--------WALLACE

---------------WELBECK------PARKIN-----------------
Click to expand...

bang on the money for me. although swapping Mawene for Collins went through my mind. Collins looks resonably sturdy next to StLedger.
 
Back
Top