Skip to main content

Matchday Thread - PNE v Scunthorpe (10/3/12)

Matchday Thread - PNE v Scunthorpe (10/3/12)

gazzaholly

Dreaming hard about promotion...
Staff member
Joined
Jun 7, 2004
Messages
1,793
Location
Preston
mdt-title.png

Preston North End v Scunthorpe United
Saturday 10th March 2012. Kick off 3pm​

Please use this thread to post comments on this match.​

A man-of-the match poll will be posted shortly after the game.​



​

Match Information (From Sky Sports)

Full-backs David Gray
spacer.gif
and Steven Smith
spacer.gif
are set to boost manager Graham Westley's defensive options.
Gray has recovered from a hamstring injury he picked up in the January loss at Yeovil while Smith came back in the defeat at Colchester last weekend following a muscular problem, although he was not passed fit for Tuesday's goaless draw with Chesterfield.
spacer.gif

Westley has shown he is unafraid to give opportunities to youngsters since arriving at Deepdale and 19-year-old centre-back Daniel Devine will be hoping to keep his place after making a first start since October in midweek.
Iain Hume is pushing for a start in attack having made three consecutive substitute appearances after his recovery from a hamstring injury, while fellow striker Neil Mellor
spacer.gif
(knee) is targeting a return to action before the end of the month.
Craig Morgan (foot tendinitis) remains on the sidelines, while Adam Barton (broken leg) is out for the rest of the season.
Scunthorpe will be without suspended midfielders Josh Walker,
spacer.gif
Sam Togwell
spacer.gif
and Michael O'Connor.
The Iron have had a man sent off in each of their last three matches and the latest one, Walker, will sit out a one-game ban after receiving two yellow cards in the midweek win at Oldham.
Togwell will serve the final game of his three-match suspension following his dismissal at Sheffield United
spacer.gif
and fellow midfielder O'Connor, sent off last weekend, is in the middle of his three-game ban.
Manager Alan Knill will be hoping Jimmy Ryan's knee suffers no reaction after the midfielder made his first start in two months at Oldham while Bobby Grant and Garry Thompson
spacer.gif
will be hoping to fill the gaps.
Thompson staked his claim after stepping off the substitutes' bench to score a late winner at Oldham.
Strikers Connor Jennings (foot), Matt Godden (hip) and midfielder Michael Collins (Achilles) remain long-term absentees.
 
Another day, another chance to get the win that might kick-start GW's managerial career here. As far as today is concerned the one thing I hope we do not see is Miller reinstated to central midfield at the expense of Coutts being pushed wide. Frankly I think the only place to play a youngster like Miller at this stage of his career is as a 'wing-half' in support of a more experienced central midfield pairing. If Smith is not fit and Parry continues at left-back then a midfield of Miller, Coutts, Procter, Mayor would be my choice. If Smith is fit and is restored to the left-back slot then Parry can be moved forward but it must be that way round. If Mayor starts - whether on the right or left and I think he can play either position to equal effect - then he has to be involved continuously. Few things would improve the side as much as Mayor being as effective over 90 minutes as he has previously shown himself when coming on as a sub for the last 20 minutes. Hume surely must start - I would rather we got the first 60-70 minutes out of him than the last 20-30. In the eight matches we have played under GW I think there has barely been an hour in total when we have held the lead. If we can get our noses in front today and then hold on to it then maybe we will finally see some of that attacking fluency that GW admits we have not seen so far. It will happen at some point.
 
Another day, another chance to get the win that might kick-start GW's managerial career here. As far as today is concerned the one thing I hope we do not see is Miller reinstated to central midfield at the expense of Coutts being pushed wide. Frankly I think the only place to play a youngster like Miller at this stage of his career is as a 'wing-half' in support of a more experienced central midfield pairing. If Smith is not fit and Parry continues at left-back then a midfield of Miller, Coutts, Procter, Mayor would be my choice. If Smith is fit and is restored to the left-back slot then Parry can be moved forward but it must be that way round. If Mayor starts - whether on the right or left and I think he can play either position to equal effect - then he has to be involved continuously. Few things would improve the side as much as Mayor being as effective over 90 minutes as he has previously shown himself when coming on as a sub for the last 20 minutes. Hume surely must start - I would rather we got the first 60-70 minutes out of him than the last 20-30. In the eight matches we have played under GW I think there has barely been an hour in total when we have held the lead. If we can get our noses in front today and then hold on to it then maybe we will finally see some of that attacking fluency that GW admits we have not seen so far. It will happen at some point.

Ernest, I'm forever hearing your appeal for a wing-half.

Personally, I'm a big fan of the position. It's no coincidence as far as I'm concerned that we got relegated the season Sedgwick left (and no I'm not saying thats the sole reason). However, in League 1, I think teams who set out with two wingers who will run for 90 minutes and two solid central midfielders are rewarded (and promoted) in this division.

If we are to get back to the Championship, I'll happily champion the position, but for now, the last thing our impatient fans want is defensive football.
 
stf - fair enough. But we only really have one winger in any case - Mayor. We do, however, have a very good, pacy attacking right-back in Gray and if Mayor was on the left then I would ideally want to see Gray giving us attacking width on the opposite flank by getting up in wide positions. But do you really think that a youngster like Miller could be used as one of just two central midfielders with all the responsibility for winning the ball? If not where would you play him to give him any experience? The reality is that a two-man central midfield can be overwhelmed by any fairly humdrum opposiiton that packs its central midfield and if that happens then your wingers are just left high and dry. Remember the last time we got out of this division we had no wingers at all. Instead we had a sort of three-man midfield of Gregan flanked to his left by McKenna and to his right by Rankine with Cartwright - who by that time had already ceased to be the flying winger he was in his youth - doubling up with Rankine as another hassling, ball-winning midfielder. So effectively we had a midfield of four ball-winners with all our attacking width coming from the fullbacks - Alexander on the right and Edwards on the left. This sort of all-out attacking 4.4.2 that is really an old-fsahioned 4.2.4 is a tactic to be used if you are chasing a game or are maybe 3-0 up against ten men with 20 minutes to go. As a basic strategy in the modern game which is basically a midfield battle it doesn't work. But the real thing is coming up. Let's see what GW picks and how we get on.
 
Last edited:
stf - fair enough. But we only really have one winger in any case - Mayor. We do, however, have a very good, pacy attacking right-back in Gray and if Mayor was on the left then I would ideally want to see Gray giving us attacking width on the opposite flank by getting up in wide positions. But do you really think that a youngster like Miller could be used as one of just two central midfielders with all the responsibility for winning the ball? If not where would you play him to give him any experience? The reality is that a two-man central midfield can be overwhelmed by any fairly humdrum opposiiton that packs its central midfield and if that happens then your wingers are just left high and dry. Remember the last time we got out of this division we had no wingers at all. Instead we had a sort of three-man midfield of Gregan flanked to his left by McKenna and to his right by Rankine with Cartwright - who by that time had already ceased to be the flying winger he was in his youth - doubling up with Rankine as another hassling, ball-winning midfielder. So effectively we had a midfield of four ball-winners with all our attacking width coming from the fullbacks - Alexander on the right and Edwards on the left. This sort of all-out attackign 4.4.2 that is really an old-fsahioned 4.2.4 is a tactic to be used if you are chasing a game or are maybe 3-0 up against ten men with 20 minutes to go. As a basic strategy in the modern game which is basically a midfield battle it doesn't work. But the real thing is coming up. Let's see what GW picks and how we get on.

Re Miller, I'd send him out on loan to a League 2 or Conference Team. Let him build his confidence up elsewhere. However, he is big and strong enough to cope with the demands in League 1, I just think he'd be better off learning his full team responsibilities elsewhere.

The Cartwright Rankine Gregan McKenna midfield was tough, battling and extremely narrow. It worked, and I don't doubt it would work again. But, and its a big but, if it didn't work, Westley would be slated for 'negative' 'boring' 'midfield bypassing' football.
 
Westley picking the team at random 5 minutes before kick off, he is doing this so the opposition can't make a game plan 😉
 
PNE: Stuckmann, Hunt, Devine, Robertson, Parry, Procter, Coutts, Mayor, Holroyd, Cummins, Hume. Subs: Arestidou, Miller, Proctor, Devine, Nicholson.
 
I presume it should be Murphy and not Devine amongst the subs since Devine is starting - but I now gather it is Wright. But that is an attacking line-up that could slip into gear if we can get ahead. About time Holroyd got himself a goal.
 
Hi from Holland everyone, just listening to Player and their playing the GW interview, tell ya what, even though i'll give GW until October next season i'm getting sick of "when i was at Stevenage..."
 
Back
Top