Skip to main content

Atmosphere

Atmosphere

I assume this is a joke.

The song may have been popular in the 1920s but so were a lot of other songs to what was a much less sophisticated audience.

To the modern ear the song is dull bordering on shit and really not suitable as an anthem or anything else for that matter.

No joke, and I think your attitude is bordering on shit.

The reason Ive pushed this is because I watched Sir Toms family sing it at his wake. They all sang along. Sir Tom said it was his anthem for PNE and his favourite song. So for you to say its a joke is a bit crass, or ignorant, maybe both.
 
One of the best is Stoke's Delilah in my opinion. Nothing to do with the club at all apart from once, in a quiet bit of game, some bloke started singing it and that's that.

These things will evolve over time and people will sing what they want to. Trying to force something won't work.
As stated earlier, not trying to force anything, just opening peoples eyes to the fact that this song was our anthem and is very special to the club, especially since the recent passing of Sir Tom.
 
Don't worry lads, I have given up due to negativity. Shame for Tom but ho hum eh!

Don't give up with the whole thing just yet. You said you had the idea to ask the band back to Deepdale. Might work.

Although stopping posting about it on here for a while is probably a decent idea.
 
Don't give up with the whole thing just yet. You said you had the idea to ask the band back to Deepdale. Might work.

Although stopping posting about it on here for a while is probably a decent idea.
nah, started getting grief for it so can't be arsed. Should've expected it on here to be honest.
 
nah, started getting grief for it so can't be arsed. Should've expected it on here to be honest.

Fair enough. Bit of a pity. Personally I don't think it is a particularly good anthem, but would have been a great tribute to Sir Tom had it taken off (regardless of the quality of the tune).
 
Fair enough. Bit of a pity. Personally I don't think it is a particularly good anthem, but would have been a great tribute to Sir Tom had it taken off (regardless of the quality of the tune).

It was never about the quality of the tune.
 
No joke, and I think your attitude is bordering on shit.

The reason Ive pushed this is because I watched Sir Toms family sing it at his wake. They all sang along. Sir Tom said it was his anthem for PNE and his favourite song. So for you to say its a joke is a bit crass, or ignorant, maybe both.

Neither crass nor ignorant. (Tautological surely?) Just an opinion on your suggestion for an unsuitable anthem.

I assume you are suggesting I am being insensitive regarding Sir Tom's family. Well surely no more insensitive than the host of others suggesting alternatives?

If you feel that the fact that Sir Tom and his family are fond of this tune means it is exempt from criticism then I feel we must disagree.

By the way, feel free to send more unsolicited "insults" my way as your opinions of me are inconsequential.
 
Neither crass nor ignorant. (Tautological surely?) Just an opinion on your suggestion for an unsuitable anthem.

I assume you are suggesting I am being insensitive regarding Sir Tom's family. Well surely no more insensitive than the host of others suggesting alternatives?

If you feel that the fact that Sir Tom and his family are fond of this tune means it is exempt from criticism then I feel we must disagree.

By the way, feel free to send more unsolicited "insults" my way as your opinions of me are inconsequential.

Your original post started the insults pal. I spent a bit of time on this matter, you flew in calling it a joke, calling it shit. Easy to dish out but can't take an insult back? I never suggested you were insensitive, read into it what you want, you obviously already have.
 
Back
Top