Skip to main content

Attack at Home

Attack at Home

Aye he did, and then what did Welsh do once Banton had skipped past Keane? Stood there not bothering to close him down and let him have a free shot.

So a failed 'tackle' close to the half way line (Keane) or someone standing still and not closing down as the opponent moved towards goal (Welsh)?

Both, in my opinion, of Welsh and Keane, is that neither is good enough in midfield.

I really really fail to see why Welsh gets so much adulation off the PNE faithful.

Is he really all that?

Vastly overrated imo is Welsh.
 
Both, in my opinion, of Welsh and Keane, is that neither is good enough in midfield.

I really really fail to see why Welsh gets so much adulation off the PNE faithful.

Is he really all that?

Vastly overrated imo is Welsh.


How many times have you been told to FACE the pitch JD?
 
Welsh was our best player last season and mostly an excellent player at this level (and maybe higher). He has a good engine, can tackle and leads the team well. This season his has appeared to not be as good but potentially this may be down to Keane playing his role. I think Keane is over rated and an example of better than what you expected so good player (like Jack King - much better than expected but...). Though in fairness Keane has arguably been our best player in a couple of games this season.

Ultimately I don't think Grayson rates Wroe enough and I think having to keep Hume may have meant no funds for a different and attacking midfielder.

Both, in my opinion, of Welsh and Keane, is that neither is good enough in midfield.

I really really fail to see why Welsh gets so much adulation off the PNE faithful.

Is he really all that?

Vastly overrated imo is Welsh.
 
wroe is redundant in the style grayson likes to play. It's wing play and balls into the box. His tactics thus far have been to have two "holding" midfielders to intercept/tackle/collect the ball, then distribute to the wings. Fucking dull, but does a job in this league.
 
He wasn't redundant against Wolves just poor.

wroe is redundant in the style grayson likes to play. It's wing play and balls into the box. His tactics thus far have been to have two "holding" midfielders to intercept/tackle/collect the ball, then distribute to the wings. Fucking dull, but does a job in this league.
 
What's your view on both players, Billy?

I think Welsh was our best player by a mile last season, Keane although very eager was found wanting many times at full back as his tendancy to "jump" into tackles left him flat footed and with a collection of yellow cards few could match.

I think that the effectiveness of Welsh has been compromised by Graysons tactics this season, last season under Grayson Keane didn't feature to much and I cannot for the life of me see what Grayson see's in him as a midfielder, his distribution is poor apart from a sideways pass at best.

I have so far been less than impressed by the quality of our wing play, there has so far been a distinct lack of telling crosses into the box and the only plus is the defensive work done by Holmes, Hayhurst and Humphrey all again could be as a result of the tactics employed with only one striker to find and no supporting midfielder to help.

I would like the middle 4 to be; Holmes, Welsh, Wroe, Hayhurst supporting Davies and Hume/Beavon. In tougher away games King or Laird could be used in the middle if Wroe was left out. Away from home the Welsh/Keane pairing offers little if nothing in a creative sense with Keane just getting in the way at times, he (Keane) is simply not a good enough footballer imho to play this position, if Welsh were to get injured then no doubt Grayson will play Keane in that "holding" position and as could easily be seen on Saturday the team lost its shape when Welsh went off.

I don't get the Keane love in, decent player but just about at the top of his level ability wise, I would rather see him at right back than midfield, but that would mean dropping Clarke (who I thought struggled on Saturday)
 
I think Welsh was our best player by a mile last season, Keane although very eager was found wanting many times at full back as his tendancy to "jump" into tackles left him flat footed and with a collection of yellow cards few could match.

I think that the effectiveness of Welsh has been compromised by Graysons tactics this season, last season under Grayson Keane didn't feature to much and I cannot for the life of me see what Grayson see's in him as a midfielder, his distribution is poor apart from a sideways pass at best.

I have so far been less than impressed by the quality of our wing play, there has so far been a distinct lack of telling crosses into the box and the only plus is the defensive work done by Holmes, Hayhurst and Humphrey all again could be as a result of the tactics employed with only one striker to find and no supporting midfielder to help.

I would like the middle 4 to be; Holmes, Welsh, Wroe, Hayhurst supporting Davies and Hume/Beavon. In tougher away games King or Laird could be used in the middle if Wroe was left out. Away from home the Welsh/Keane pairing offers little if nothing in a creative sense with Keane just getting in the way at times, he (Keane) is simply not a good enough footballer imho to play this position, if Welsh were to get injured then no doubt Grayson will play Keane in that "holding" position and as could easily be seen on Saturday the team lost its shape when Welsh went off.

I don't get the Keane love in, decent player but just about at the top of his level ability wise, I would rather see him at right back than midfield, but that would mean dropping Clarke (who I thought struggled on Saturday)

Agree with most of that. I've said a few times now Grayson has to be brave and pick Keane or Welsh in the middle, and not both, and for me that should be Welsh.

Clarke currently would keep Keane from the RB slot.
 
Back
Top