Skip to main content

Buchanan

Buchanan

Keane, Huntington, Wright and Buchanan all had good games. Holmes looked good in spells but faded in the second half. Looked like he was carrying a knock. Other than that, the rest were poor.
 
Keane man of the match for me, I've not enjoyed a player in a preston shirt play like he did for a long time. Solid at full back, changed the game when he went into the midfield, made a lot of meaty challenges and scored a cracking goal to boot. Having said that, Buchs was a very close second simply for his confidence when in possession of the ball.
 
Keane, Huntington, Wright and Buchanan all had good games. Holmes looked good in spells but faded in the second half. Looked like he was carrying a knock. Other than that, the rest were poor.

Wroe was absolutely appalling today. I can't recall him successfully completing a single forward pass, everything went to the back four or the opposition.

Only Mousinho was worse.

Buchanan, Keane and Huntington were the best three out there today in my opinion. Holmes tried hard but was marked out of the game and Monakana deserves a mention for running it out of the defence when everybody else seemed static.

Monakana looked far more determined than he has for months. Last week's criticism clearly had an impact.

Wroe worked really hard but he has lost his early season magic , even when he is playing with Welsh. His footballing brain is still there but too many of his passes are going to the opposition.

The passing generally was poor by most of the players. Dozens did not go forward of the player being passed to and several were suicide passes where our player was not going to win the ball.

I agree that Huntington, Buchanan and Keane were the only starting players to come out of the game with credit. However, all 3 substitutes made a positive impact.
 
Last edited:
Buchs motm for the last few wks he's been outstanding and we are starting to see why the tranmere fans loved this guy, plays for the shirt and gives 110% spoke to welshy at the start off the season and ask how good Buchanan was, and he said he's the best left-back in league 1, that was a big call but he's starting to back it up,
 
Wroe? Good at passing sideways and backwards though.

That sentence could have been written about Paul McKenna in days gone by.

Wroe had a decent game, in percentage terms he doesn't give the ball away often........and some people reckon we should play a passing game, as opposed to a direct long ball approach, anyway.
 
Huntington was MOM for me, he has been outstanding since Grayson took over. Also thought Keane had good game, Buchanan was ok, but thought Wroe was poor, as was Hayhurst.
 
Wroe seems to have split opinions yesterday. FWIW the commentators on BBC radio Solent from the Portsmouth point of view highlighted him as someone who'd had a good battling game and had caused problems. Suppose it depends on whether you rate a performance solely on ball retention by each player or you look at it a a complete midfield performance. It is probably true he's not playing his best at the moment but he's still the best we've got alongside Welsh when fit.
 
Said it time and time again, Wroe needs to push forward more, he's wasted doing the mopping up at the back which is why he seems to play well alongside Welsh, I don't think he was the same trust in Mousinho hence why he played a bit deeper today and we suffered for it.
 
That sentence could have been written about Paul McKenna in days gone by.

Wroe had a decent game, in percentage terms he doesn't give the ball away often........and some people reckon we should play a passing game, as opposed to a direct long ball approach, anyway.

Good point. Fans moan when we go direct but then a midfielder goes backwards or sideways and its a major issue. The full backs and wingers are the most creative players in our team and fast balls in to the strikers are pointless as Cummins and Kings touches are usually a tackle or a header
 
Huntington rarely missed anything in the air again yesterday and was comfortable with the ball at his feet too along with Bailey Wright for the most part.
Can see why he was given the MoM by the sponsors although as has been said already, Keane and Buchanan were worthy candidates and always give 110% for the cause.
I would heve been satisfied with any of these three being nominated, and that's how it turned out.
 
Wroe was there everytime looking for the ball. He probably had to do all of Mooses work as well. That's why he looked knackered late on.

Some of you need to hang your heads in shame, or go to specsavers!!

What a load of tosh.
 
Wroe was there everytime looking for the ball. He probably had to do all of Mooses work as well. That's why he looked knackered late on.

Some of you need to hang your heads in shame, or go to specsavers!!

What a load of tosh.

Yeah I thought Wroe had a good first half even though our wingers and strikers gave him few options.

Both full backs had great games and Wright and Huntington were comfortable.
 
Wroe was very poor yesterday. He is, at best, an average league 1 player. It's a measure of how far we have slumped that many on here consider Wroe to be part of the answer to a future success! As for making comparisons between McKenna and Wroe are you having a laugh - the two are not nearly in the same league.
 
Wroe was very poor yesterday. He is, at best, an average league 1 player. It's a measure of how far we have slumped that many on here consider Wroe to be part of the answer to a future success! As for making comparisons between McKenna and Wroe are you having a laugh - the two are not nearly in the same league.
No they're not, Wroe is in League 1 and McKenna in the conference. Seriously Wroe was badly let down by Moose yesterday, get Welsh back and we'll see him back to his best.
 
Wroe was poor today. I personally think he's very overrated. The fact he looks poor every game, unless played alongside Welsh to me speaks volumes about how good Welsh is.
Buchanan in my opinion was our best player today. He made a few mistakes, but he never shirks away from wanting the ball.

I agree norky, i've no idea what his misplaced pass count would be but i'm sure it would be high and not many had any forward thinking in them either, as someone else has already said maybe alongside Moose he doesn't have the same freedom to get forward than when alongside Welsh?
 
Back
Top