Skip to main content

David Buchanan

David Buchanan

Joined
Aug 11, 2008
Messages
1,596
I have personally been very impressed with Buchs' battling performances at the back recently. He's been one of the most consistent performers in the team over the last few weeks and always puts his all in which is great to see, never shirks out of a tackle.

Now the issue, Lairds return. We all know that it would be silly to have a man of Lairds quality on the bench when fully fit. Along with his defensive qualities, he scores goals and whips in a fantastic ball from a set piece. So, could we play both? I know playing one of them on the wing has been mentioned, but could Buchs do a job at right back? I know Connolly hasn't done anything to warrant being dropped but who knows if he will be here next year. Buchs could become our first choice right back allowing Keano to cement his place in the middle of the park. So, could Buchs do a job at right back? I think he could.
 
I have personally been very impressed with Buchs' battling performances at the back recently. He's been one of the most consistent performers in the team over the last few weeks and always puts his all in which is great to see, never shirks out of a tackle.

Now the issue, Lairds return. We all know that it would be silly to have a man of Lairds quality on the bench when fully fit. Along with his defensive qualities, he scores goals and whips in a fantastic ball from a set piece. So, could we play both? I know playing one of them on the wing has been mentioned, but could Buchs do a job at right back? I know Connolly hasn't done anything to warrant being dropped but who knows if he will be here next year. Buchs could become our first choice right back allowing Keano to cement his place in the middle of the park. So, could Buchs do a job at right back? I think he could.

It is a dilemma, but a good one to have. I think Laird will be the starting LB next season, Buchs will either switch to the right or become a back-up player which I don't really think is fair to a player of Buchs quality.
 
It's not usually a massive issue being 1 footed but Buchanan is the most 1 footed player I have seen in a very long time, and the norm of knocking balls down the line and into the RW would not happen as easily.
 
I have personally been very impressed with Buchs' battling performances at the back recently. He's been one of the most consistent performers in the team over the last few weeks and always puts his all in which is great to see, never shirks out of a tackle.

Now the issue, Lairds return. We all know that it would be silly to have a man of Lairds quality on the bench when fully fit. Along with his defensive qualities, he scores goals and whips in a fantastic ball from a set piece. So, could we play both? I know playing one of them on the wing has been mentioned, but could Buchs do a job at right back? I know Connolly hasn't done anything to warrant being dropped but who knows if he will be here next year. Buchs could become our first choice right back allowing Keano to cement his place in the middle of the park. So, could Buchs do a job at right back? I think he could.

Agree 100% Buchs has been outstanding since westley I'm not suprise tho you dont win north west league 1 player of the year for being a tube, as for him playing right back couldnt see,
 
Perhaps someone should mention his cock ups this season that have cost us goals and points? He has improved since the egomaniac was potted as has pretty much all of the squad. However a few of his errors this season leading to the opposition scoring have been school boy at best.

As for playing Buchanan at right back, give it a rest! He is all left peg. Square pegs in square holes and round pegs in round holes Simon please. The opposite (imho) has contributed to our decline over the last 6 years or so. With a superb left back / left midfielder in Laird, a decent left back / left midfielder in Buchanan and Holmes and Hayhurst all vying for a place on our left hand side it will be interesting to see what Grayson thinks is his best option.

The new found competition for starting places at left back and left midfield is a welcome change to the previous squads that saw anyone semi capable of using their left foot shoehorned in at left back or on the left of midfield irrespective of fitness and form at times.
 
Will be good to have the competition at left back also knowing that we have two players both capable of doing the job.

Laird is quality, Buchs is decent back up.

Just a shame despite bringing them both in that Westley took a dislike to Buchs and played tried everyone else there instead of playing him.
 
Will be good to have the competition at left back also knowing that we have two players both capable of doing the job.

Laird is quality, Buchs is decent back up.

Just a shame despite bringing them both in that Westley took a dislike to Buchs and played tried everyone else there instead of playing him.

I agree that Buchanan is far too one-footed to play right back. Once Laird returns, his future will probably be competing for a place at left midfield or perhaps centre midfield. He wasn't very successful at left midfield under Westley though.

I don't think he would have signed for PNE if he had known Laird was going to sign. When Buchanan did sign though, I don't think even GW and PR expected Laird to sign as Laird had received offers from championship clubs.
 
maybe with Laird's goal scoring ability he could play on the left side of midfield, if not its good to have strong competition which hopefully will spur them on in training and when they're playing to prove they deserve to be 1st choice at left back.
 
I agree that Buchanan is far too one-footed to play right back. Once Laird returns, his future will probably be competing for a place at left midfield or perhaps centre midfield. He wasn't very successful at left midfield under Westley though.I don't think he would have signed for PNE if he had known Laird was going to sign. When Buchanan did sign though, I don't think even GW and PR expected Laird to sign as Laird had received offers from championship clubs.


Was anyone a success under Westley???

I think that Laird and Buchanan could form a very good left sided partnership, with either able to play in defense or in a more advanced role (as was seen at Bournemouth earlier this season), they would also offer something different to Hayhurst or Holmes and give the chance for one of these (Holmes or Hayhurst) to play wide right.
 
Buchanan has been excellent since Westley's departure, and he's as good a left back as Laird, but Laird is far better at set pieces and also scores more goals, and that is a big advantage.

We may not have missed Laird's defending qualities, but we sure as hell, have missed his set pieces. We've hardly scored from a set piece since he got injured.
 
Can't see either player being happy with the subs bench and wouldn't be surprised to see one of them leave.
 
Some interesting points, with most saying Buchs wouldn't suit a right back role. Maybe Buchs could come into it more away from home. Go with two out and out attacking wingers in the home games, whereas away have Buchs playing infront of Laird giving us a bit more stability when defending.
 
Can't see either player being happy with the subs bench and wouldn't be surprised to see one of them leave.

Can't see any off them being happy sitting on the bench when both could walk on to other teams, so maybe ur right that 1 will leave,
 
Back
Top