Skip to main content

Devil's Advocate...

Devil's Advocate...

Maybe the football is awful because of the league we are in and the opposition we face on a weekly basis.

It takes 2 teams to contribute to the football on show.


Oh my god.......... If there's a WUM of the year vote, your getting mine........ or even a tediuos barsteward.
 
Maybe the football is awful because of the league we are in and the opposition we face on a weekly basis.

It takes 2 teams to contribute to the football on show.

On that basis, the standard of football between 2 teams would be the same providing they were in the same division. I'm sure Blackpool played great football vs Bournemouth last month! You and I know that isn't the case, it comes from the manager and how he sets his team up.

We all know how Grayson likes to set his teams up. Other managers have different philosophies, it's part of the game. I don't have a huge problem with the standard of football we play, I'm more concerned with our mentality and the recent results. Although not mutually exclusive, playing free flowing, attractive football and winning consistently is rare to find.

For me, good football is a bonus because I imagine very few of us would come off games having lost but feeling satisfied just because we passed it nicely. I mean when was the last time we played good football? It's not like Grayson has robbed us of the attractive stuff we played under the previous regimes. It's becoming a weapon to criticise the manager. I want us to win, simple really. Few complain about the football we play when we win because it's a results business, it's only during poor runs like the one we are currently experiencing when the football style gets discussed.
 
On that basis, the standard of football between 2 teams would be the same providing they were in the same division. I'm sure Blackpool played great football vs Bournemouth last month! You and I know that isn't the case, it comes from the manager and how he sets his team up.

We all know how Grayson likes to set his teams up. Other managers have different philosophies, it's part of the game. I don't have a huge problem with the standard of football we play, I'm more concerned with our mentality and the recent results. Although not mutually exclusive, playing free flowing, attractive football and winning consistently is rare to find.

For me, good football is a bonus because I imagine very few of us would come off games having lost but feeling satisfied just because we passed it nicely. I mean when was the last time we played good football? It's not like Grayson has robbed us of the attractive stuff we played under the previous regimes. It's becoming a weapon to criticise the manager. I want us to win, simple really. Few complain about the football we play when we win because it's a results business, it's only during poor runs like the one we are currently experiencing when the football style gets discussed.

Very good point.

Norwich, Sheffield Utd and MK Dons are games where I have come off thinking we have played good football.

Completely agree with the style of football being used as a weapon to berate the manager.

The thing with teams in league 1 is they setup to counter us, stifle us and when at home 9/10 they come for the point or to nick a goal rarely do you see teams come to Deepdale and play expansive football because they know we might tear them to shreds. This all contributes to the game on show.
 
Very good point.

Norwich, Sheffield Utd and MK Dons are games where I have come off thinking we have played good football.

Completely agree with the style of football being used as a weapon to berate the manager.

The thing with teams in league 1 is they setup to counter us, stifle us and when at home 9/10 they come for the point or to nick a goal rarely do you see teams come to Deepdale and play expansive football because they know we might tear them to shreds. This all contributes to the game on show.

MK Dons and Swindon are near the top and have teams set up to draw against them yet still play good football and still hit teams for 3/4. We seem incapable of scoring more than one per game.
 
You watch Swindon regularly? Have they been hit with the same injuries as us?

No I don't watch them regularly, but whenever I've watched them either against us or on Sky they've looked a great footballing side.

Yes we have been unlucky with injuries, but Swindon themselves don't have a massive squad like us.

Struggling for cash with a small squad, yet play better football than us, score more than us, concede less than us(look at the stats) and are opening a big gap with ourselves in the league.
 
Very good point.

Norwich, Sheffield Utd and MK Dons are games where I have come off thinking we have played good football.

Completely agree with the style of football being used as a weapon to berate the manager.

The thing with teams in league 1 is they setup to counter us, stifle us and when at home 9/10 they come for the point or to nick a goal rarely do you see teams come to Deepdale and play expansive football because they know we might tear them to shreds. This all contributes to the game on show.

We can play decent stuff, with the budget and squad we have I would expect us to provide a few moments of quality now and then.

As for your last point, it's a decent theory. There certainly are teams that come with no intention of opening up but I'm sure we aren't the only team to experience that at home. I'm sure the likes of Bristol City and Swindon have had their fair share of spoilers at home this season. Ultimately the onus is on us to be inventive and create chances which can win us games, particularly at home. Our home record is good in terms of few defeats but we draw too many games and our safety first approach can bite us on the behind. This is what frustrates supporters, and was evident at Walsall last night.
 
No I don't watch them regularly, but whenever I've watched them either against us or on Sky they've looked a great footballing side.

Yes we have been unlucky with injuries, but Swindon themselves don't have a massive squad like us.

Struggling for cash with a small squad, yet play better football than us, score more than us, concede less than us(look at the stats) and are opening a big gap with ourselves in the league.

What about Swindons connection when it comes to loans with Tottenham we don't have a relationship like that with a Premier League club, might be worth looking into.
 
On that basis, the standard of football between 2 teams would be the same providing they were in the same division. I'm sure Blackpool played great football vs Bournemouth last month! You and I know that isn't the case, it comes from the manager and how he sets his team up.

We all know how Grayson likes to set his teams up. Other managers have different philosophies, it's part of the game. I don't have a huge problem with the standard of football we play, I'm more concerned with our mentality and the recent results. Although not mutually exclusive, playing free flowing, attractive football and winning consistently is rare to find.

For me, good football is a bonus because I imagine very few of us would come off games having lost but feeling satisfied just because we passed it nicely. I mean when was the last time we played good football? It's not like Grayson has robbed us of the attractive stuff we played under the previous regimes. It's becoming a weapon to criticise the manager. I want us to win, simple really. Few complain about the football we play when we win because it's a results business, it's only during poor runs like the one we are currently experiencing when the football style gets discussed.

We have had this discussion before but again here goes.
I want us to win of course but also want us to play good football, this for me means defending when we have to but attacking with intent when we have the ball, playing with good tempo and mixing up the range of passing.
Not sure what pretty passing is but if it means passing to a team mate I think that is probably a good thing.Tired of watching pass/pass/hoof to an imobile target man who then lays it off (if we are lucky) to no one in support.
It is about football philosophy really and mine is that playing well, playing good football will bring more success in the long term, whereas playing poorly, whatever the short term success, will not.
 
We have had this discussion before but again here goes.
I want us to win of course but also want us to play good football, this for me means defending when we have to but attacking with intent when we have the ball, playing with good tempo and mixing up the range of passing.
Not sure what pretty passing is but if it means passing to a team mate I think that is probably a good thing.Tired of watching pass/pass/hoof to an imobile target man who then lays it off (if we are lucky) to no one in support.
It is about football philosophy really and mine is that playing well, playing good football will bring more success in the long term, whereas playing poorly, whatever the short term success, will not.

To play like that do you not think the calibre of players has to be better than the standard in League 1?
 
Back
Top