I am Dichio's biggest fan, ask anyone, but to suggest he starts ahead of Nugent is quite simply absurd.
I do believe that sometimes you do not necessarily play your best 11 players, but your best "team." Nugent, along with Nash would always be two names who would make both the best 11 players team and the best "team."
Its like Mourinho said the other day, he has his "untouchables" and Nugent is ours. Football management is not just about picking a team and getting results, well it is actually, but its also about managing players and keeping them happy. Maybe dropping Nugent down to the bench after some petulant behaviour/suspension/injury wouldn't do him any harm, but when he has run a international centre half ragged for 70 minutes, been unlucky with a few chances then to drop the lad would be criminal. What would it do to his confidence? What would he start thinking of Simpson?
Some people have no idea.