Skip to main content

Humphrey

Humphrey

We've got 5 centre midfielders, we still need someone who can dominate games, but that's a signing to be made in the summer, that sort of player isn't available on loan. Gallagher could play wide, but he's wasted out there, Garner aside, he's our best player, get him in the middle and pick everyone else around him and Garner, if that means there's no room for the likes of Johnson and Brownhill, so be it. Playing three in midfield with Gallagher off the front would be a disaster, no width, everything down the middle and no space for anyone to create anything. Humphrey could play further forward, but if we're going to play a winger with less defensive duties, we might as well get someone in with some quality. Humphrey's quick, but he's braindead at times and he's a terrible footballer, we need quality, not hit and miss with one good ball in five.

Totally agree that a skillful attacking right-sided midfielder is something we lack. But suppose we got such a player and tried play them in a flat four-man midfield then have we got two players who could form a central midfield partnership that might give them the service they would need? I think the answer to that is no. Also where would Gallagher play in such a formation - if on the left then why not on the right with Reid on the left, if upfront then we would only have room for one other player, presumably Garner when fit, but where would that leave Robinson, Ebanks-Blake, Davies, even Beckford if he gets fit again?

We will soon have several quality strikers available so we need to find a way of playing two of them at the same time in addition to Gallagher and that means a three-man midfield behind those other three players or maybe two players sitting in front of the defence with three mobile skillful players in front of them - any three of Gallagher, Johnson, Robinson, Reid and maybe even Garner - behind either Ebanks-Blake or Davies. Yes I did say Garner as one of that trio - I think he would revel in the extra space and be more effective there than as a lone striker upfront. Frankly even Humphrey might be more effective as one of a three behind a robust, disruptive single striker upfront.

Yes either of those formations would mean starting without a conventional winger - but overlapping fullbacks and speedy attackers able to move wide if necessary would still give us width and Reid certainly would give us an option for an attacking winger later on if we wanted. But at the moment we lack drive and pace from central midfield - that is the root cause of everything else and that cannot be cured by sticking a new winger out on one of the flanks. Until we solve that core problem everything else will be just a distraction and simply will not produce the type of change we need.
 
Last edited:
I just think calling them fickle suggests they shouldn't be criticising him.

In a way I agree with you in that he is in a bad patch, but it looks a little more than that IMO. Looks like his head has been turned and he can't be bothered.

Calling them fickle is exactly what it is, calling them fickle.

Humphrey has been one of our better players this season and there are some that are far more deserving of a hard time.
 
Calling them fickle is exactly what it is, calling them fickle.

Humphrey has been one of our better players this season and there are some that are far more deserving of a hard time.

Yes he's not been the only that's been poor recently.

But there's no excuse for pulling out of tackles and basic lack of control.
 
Calling them fickle is exactly what it is, calling them fickle.

Humphrey has been one of our better players this season and there are some that are far more deserving of a hard time.

I disagree.

Whilst there are other players who have not been up to the standard Humphrey has been consistently average.
 
I disagree.

Whilst there are other players who have not been up to the standard Humphrey has been consistently average.

i think JK that suggests some good and some poor performances. The split must be more like 20/80. But SG continues to play him when he is clearly struggling. Why? If a winger is not beating his man, not crossing well, not controlling the ball and not scoring, what is the solution? Ronald, there have been a few poor performers this season, but Humphrey stands out. Not fickle. Some of us are not carried away by one good game or one good cross. We don't all "wax lyrical" when he does something well.
 
All season or in 2015?
He has consistently for 18 months now: shirked tackles, refused to go in for back post headers (jumps and looks away from the ball) and failed to get shots on target. He lacks any composure on the ball, cant use his left foot and has not got one trick, feint or dribble in his locker - he will either run straight into the full back or use his one 'technique' which is to knock the ball 5-10 yards and try to run after it. Other than that, his best tactic is to to face up to the full back and hope they foul him. In terms of his crossing I never really get the impression he is picking someone out for a header, and merely blindly whipping them in. His main attribute is his defensive tracking back which is usually sound and that is why Grayson selects him I assume.

His early season form was better than last season for sure, but that wasn't too much of an achievement. The last few months he has reverted to his 2013-14 form. He is one of the weakest members of the team in terms of genuine ability and should not be an automatic selection. He desperately need some real competition for that right side berth. At 27 years old he should of developed much more than what he delivers. He plays like a raw 19 year old. Its just not good enough.
 
Last edited:
Calling them fickle is exactly what it is, calling them fickle.

Humphrey has been one of our better players this season and there are some that are far more deserving of a hard time.

I also don't agree. People call it as it is. When he has a good game, which he hasn't for some time, it is right that people say so, but when he is in a long run of poor performances then say it as you see it. There is nothing fickle in that. As JK says ,he hasn't had that many good games and yesterday he was all over the place and didn't really seem interested.
 
I also don't agree. People call it as it is. When he has a good game, which he hasn't for some time, it is right that people say so, but when he is in a long run of poor performances then say it as you see it. There is nothing fickle in that. As JK says ,he hasn't had that many good games and yesterday he was all over the place and didn't really seem interested.

As the saying goes, you're only as good as your last game and for Humphrey, his last game has been poor, time and time again in the past few weeks.
 
Since he has been here.

You can count the number of games he has played well on one hand and he has played a lot!

I disagree with that.

He showed some initial promise when he signed but then was a let down. I think he really got going in the first half of this season and was a big threat for us.

He has five assists (only behind Davies and Gallagher) and 4 goals (behind Garner, Gallagher and Huntington), which is a bigger contribution than other regulars such as Kilkenny and Brownhill etc.
 
A month back there was panic on here that he maybe leaving as he hadnt signed a new contract yet and now he has replaced Jones as enemy no1 ffs. Could it be he has just lost his form and confidence right now. Played very well and was a key player in the first half of the season.

Agreed and he was quite incredible at the start wasn't he? If we go up this season I'd rather focus on how many points he's contibuted to the team rather berate him when he's out of form.

I really am sick of the sweeping statement, long term memory loss Pne onliners we get on here these days.
 
Agreed and he was quite incredible at the start wasn't he? If we go up this season I'd rather focus on how many points he's contibuted to the team rather berate him when he's out of form.

I really am sick of the sweeping statement, long term memory loss Pne onliners we get on here these days.

Do you mean the 'say it as we see it' club? 😉
 
Agreed and he was quite incredible at the start wasn't he? If we go up this season I'd rather focus on how many points he's contibuted to the team rather berate him when he's out of form.

I really am sick of the sweeping statement, long term memory loss Pne onliners we get on here these days.

He's been poor for a good while now.

Before you have a go, I actually like CH.

There's nothing wrong with players dipping in and out of form or even losing confidence, it happens.

Yesterday however he just looked like he couldn't be arsed and towards the end of the game he seemed to be wandering around feeling sorry for himself.

At one point Johnstone collected the ball and raced to the edge of the box, screaming at Humphrey to get moving.

He just stood there with his hands in the air, about 25 yards away, when there was acres for him to run into behind.

We can't keep him in the side because he had a good first half of the season.
 
Do you mean the 'say it as we see it' club? 😉

More like 'Bandwagon Jumpers and Shunters Social Club'. My point is simply that Chris was awesome at the start of the season and was clearly our best player of the first few months so the daft, over the top comments about him are well wide of the mark.

He was shit yesterday but he clearly isn't shit
 
He's been poor for a good while now.

Before you have a go, I actually like CH.

There's nothing wrong with players dipping in and out of form or even losing confidence, it happens.

Yesterday however he just looked like he couldn't be arsed and towards the end of the game he seemed to be wandering around feeling sorry for himself.

At one point Johnstone collected the ball and raced to the edge of the box, screaming at Humphrey to get moving.

He just stood there with his hands in the air, about 25 yards away, when there was acres for him to run into behind.

We can't keep him in the side because he had a good first half of the season.

Agreed, I think he should be dropped too. I'm just saying, comments about about him being a shit/soft/lazy winger aren't true when you consider his blistering start to the season. He's a good player at this level in terrible form
 
Agreed, I think he should be dropped too. I'm just saying, comments about about him being a shit/soft/lazy winger aren't true when you consider his blistering start to the season. He's a good player at this level in terrible form

Ironically if Humphrey is benched for Tuesday then it will be for a match in which his defensive efforts would very likely prove very useful. If SG is going to change the team on a match-by-match tactical basis then starting Humphrey in away games but using him as an impact sub against tiring defences at our place might not be a bad ploy. But if it is not obvious by now that playing Humphrey flat and wide of the central midfield and then just rolling the ball to his feet and expecting him to beat a fullback is an exercise in futility then it never will be - he has never done that with any consistency and he never will.
 
Back
Top