Skip to main content

impotence

impotence

comment moved

Good post.

I would argue, however, that Cunningham and Reach are good players with a bit about them - Reach has looked a far more competent winger than Humphrey ever has (he knows what he's doing in other words) and Cunningham looks a more competent defender than Laird and Buchanan did, even in League One. He also offers a bit, going forward as he is competent with the ball at his feet. (overuse of the word 'competent' I know but it seems an apt description of the majority of our squad)

We actually have some decent players; Gallagher, Garner, Browne, Reach, Johnson etc who I genuinely think would have provided better performances and a better points return if they were allowed to express themselves and take a few risks. The players are good enough (some of them anyway). Let them play.

It's the management, tactics ( or lack of ) and system that's holding us back.
 
Good post.

I would argue, however, that Cunningham and Reach are good players with a bit about them - Reach has looked a far more competent winger than Humphrey ever has (he knows what he's doing in other words) and Cunningham looks a more competent defender than Laird and Buchanan did, even in League One. He also offers a bit, going forward as he is competent with the ball at his feet. (overuse of the word 'competent' I know but it seems an apt description of the majority of our squad)

We actually have some decent players; Gallagher, Garner, Browne, Reach, Johnson etc who I genuinely think would have provided better performances and a better points return if they were allowed to express themselves and take a few risks. The players are good enough (some of them anyway). Let them play.

It's the management, tactics ( or lack of ) and system that's holding us back.

Acknowledged.
Garner? For me, a question mark that is growing by the week.
 
Acknowledged.
Garner? For me, a question mark that is growing by the week.

Obviously Garner's inability to score this season is worrying, but I think the service to him has been poor to say the least. For example tonight, all he had for supply was hopeful punts forwards in his general direction. To ask him to make something out of nothing like that, especially against the monstrously efficient centre half Wheater (ex-England) is asking a lot.
 
Obviously Garner's inability to score this season is worrying, but I think the service to him has been poor to say the least. For example tonight, all he had for supply was hopeful punts forwards in his general direction. To ask him to make something out of nothing like that, especially against the monstrously efficient centre half Wheater (ex-England) is asking a lot.

I agree completely, Doc, but I'll add that I notice Garner has this strange habit of running away from the ball looking down at the turf, while the ball is in play. All well and good blaming the supply, but I'm not convinced he is too interested in assisting others to score.
 
Garner and Doyle didn't look interested at all tonight,didn't chase or harass the defenders although the service upto the forwards was poor.
 
I agree completely, Doc, but I'll add that I notice Garner has this strange habit of running away from the ball looking down at the turf, while the ball is in play. All well and good blaming the supply, but I'm not convinced he is too interested in assisting others to score.

Garner must be frustrated, with himself more than anyone, understandably so really following two such prolific goal scoring seasons. I've just watched the montage of Garners 24 goals from 2013/14 and most of them (approximately 15) were reactionary, almost instinctive strikes, taken in 1/2 touches. There as also a surprising number of headed goals, but you have to say that the north end players who supplied the crosses (back then it was Holmes/Gallagher) have loads of time and space and there is little resistance all round to the goal going in. There isn't that much time and opportunity in the Championship.

Obviously the standard of defending in the Championship is miles better, and I think anyone would find it hard to go from scoring a shed load with relative ease against poor opposition, to step it up so much in the space of a few months, in a poor team. Garner, like the rest of the team, just needs to persist with doing what he is good at and not get carried away.
 
Back
Top