Skip to main content

Is Grayson underachieving with this squad?

Is Grayson underachieving with this squad?

On paper the PNE squad is as good as anything in this division. Today we play an Orient side who have lost there last three games. Perfect time to play them you would think, big 6 pointer. What do we do, play a diamond formation for 60 minutes, no width.....totally useless.

Every time we play a team up there, we seem to disappoint.. Why did it take 60 minutes to change the system, it needed changing after 20 minutes.

How many home games have we had when you get the feeling we have been negative/wrong set up with our line ups. Its so so frustrating being a North end fan.

I agree we have one of the best group of player we have had in years too good really for this level of football, more at home in the championship but the facts are SG has brought in most of this team with the exception of a few...His stats so far make him better than Moyes and Davies! So although it is hard to get out of this league his record so far with us suggests we will if we keep SG obtain promotion. For me he is doing a great job long may he continue.
 
Last edited:
Keane was man of the match at Tranmere last week and it would have been harsh to drop him against Orient. His tackling, passing and running with the ball was exceptional imo. On Saturday he was playing against a different opponent who closed him down much quicker. We can all be wise after the event and SG would probably have started with another formation if he'd have known before what he knows now. Moyes's strength was that he could identify weaknesses quickly and change for the better. SG seems to accept our failings and is slow to react and make the obvious substitutions. Having said that, 4th place is a great place to be, so he must be doing something right.
 
Keane for me has his place in the squad, but he should be used for away games only or brought on in games for late on if Welsh is looking leggy.

It would be interesting to find out how many games we've won at home this season when both Keane and Welsh have started.
 
Keane was man of the match at Tranmere last week and it would have been harsh to drop him against Orient. His tackling, passing and running with the ball was exceptional imo. On Saturday he was playing against a different opponent who closed him down much quicker. We can all be wise after the event and SG would probably have started with another formation if he'd have known before what he knows now. Moyes's strength was that he could identify weaknesses quickly and change for the better. SG seems to accept our failings and is slow to react and make the obvious substitutions. Having said that, 4th place is a great place to be, so he must be doing something right.

A quality that he appears to have lost
 
I don't believe that Grayson is going to make any attempt at catching the top two. The way we set up will continually and steadily pick up enough points to see us comfortably into the playoffs... I think that's his plan..imho
 
Last edited:
I don't believe that Grayson is going to make any attempt at catching the top two. The way we set up will continually and steadily pick up enough points to see us comfortably into the playoffs... I think that's his plan..imho

?? Sounds highly highly unlikely to me.
 
I don't believe that Grayson is going to make any attempt at catching the top two. The way we set up will continually and steadily pick up enough points to see us comfortably into the playoffs... I think that's his plan..imho

We have 16 games to go, plenty of time to catch up. I think SG would prefer automatic than the play-offs. Chasing the top two will be his intent.
 
If we don't catch the top two which it is looking for unlikely by the week, not through any fault of our own its just that Wolves and Brentford have a lot stronger squads than us and are in very good form then the coming fixtures will show us how we will fair against our possible play off opposition.

Walsall - 3/3 Points

Home - Still to play them at Home.

Away - 3-0 can't ask for anything more.

Leyton Orient - 4/6 Points

Home - A bore draw, neither team deserved the 3 points. The occasion may have got to our players, we were not at our best.

Away - Wasn't there but a wonder goal from Garner and a solid defensive performance.

Peterborough - 0/3 Points

Home - Still to play them at home.

Away - Beaten 2-0 because of 2 howlers from Rudd, there form is very inconsistent, they might not make the play offs.

Rotheram - 1/3 Points

Home - Still to play them at home.

Away - Bore Draw

So our form against our play off contenders isn't as bad as it seems.
 
Hope you're both ( regardless/ outreacher ) right and I'm wrong... I could live with that ! But his cautious approach makes me believe what I do.. We'll see ! 🙂

PS...In fairness to Grayson I think that this approach would have ( probably has) on many an occassion gained automatic...... But I can't see it this season, in this division.
 
Last edited:
I think grayson is a very good manager at this level and our points total to date coupled with our turn around last season after his appointment are testimony to this.

He has signed a large number of players and we have been a work in progress. We started off with a back 3/5 with Huntington as a nailed on starter now he can't make the bench some games as we play a back four and king is seen as cover for wright and Clarke. We have moved to a midfield 4 from a three and with Kilkenny have adapted to being a passing team that keeps possession. We have tried with up to 6 forwards to find the right pairing or something that yields goals but apart from Garner it hasn't yet clicked.

When grayson arrived he inherited a first division team with a second division back up squad. He has shipped out players who most agree are not of the standard required and added quality. Kilkenny Gallagher Davies x 2 Clarke and the re-signed Rudd are all very good players at this level.

Brentford and orient already had a good first division team and brentford have also added quality to their squad where as orient have been consistent in selection.

Orient had a decent season last year and their success is down to a good first team that picks itself. They do have a squad but very few of them have played more than a handful of times. They have 9 players who have featured in 27 or more league games nearly all from the start. Yesterday 8 of them started one was injured and one of the other starters was their top scorer mooney who has 15 goals from 21 starts and 3 as sub. The other starter was an on loan keeper. There first choice keeper started 21 games before a back injury.

Wolves have players who two years ago were in the premier league and jacket has done a good job turning them around and they have been favourites to win the league and remain so.

Whilst we have dropped a number of home points drawing games at home our overall points tally is good and if our home and away form were swapped around I suspect most of those who are worried about our current position would be happier.

I hope Grayson gets us up this year but the gap to the top two is likely to be unachievable more due to the continued performances of the top two not our own lack of points in the run in. The play offs are a lottery and our record is poor.

If we do not make it via the playoffs then next season we will be a real force in this league.

Grayson has done and continues to a good job and is not underachieving.

I expect him to continue to be backed by our owner and hope to see our crowds improve as Grayson continues his work here.


Bang on the money fella 🙂
 
Keane for me has his place in the squad, but he should be used for away games only or brought on in games for late on if Welsh is looking leggy.

It would be interesting to find out how many games we've won at home this season when both Keane and Welsh have started.


That's exactly how I see it too.

For me Welsh has improved a lot by having Kilkenny alongside him and is a good ball winner and a lot of the time a decent passer. He can keep the play going. Keane is predominantly a hard tackling ball winner but pretty poor when we have possession. His passing is awful much of the time and he rarely shows for the ball.

I wouldn't have both Keane and Welsh in the starting line up at home.
 
I think grayson is a very good manager at this level and our points total to date coupled with our turn around last season after his appointment are testimony to this.

He has signed a large number of players and we have been a work in progress. We started off with a back 3/5 with Huntington as a nailed on starter now he can't make the bench some games as we play a back four and king is seen as cover for wright and Clarke. We have moved to a midfield 4 from a three and with Kilkenny have adapted to being a passing team that keeps possession. We have tried with up to 6 forwards to find the right pairing or something that yields goals but apart from Garner it hasn't yet clicked.

When grayson arrived he inherited a first division team with a second division back up squad. He has shipped out players who most agree are not of the standard required and added quality. Kilkenny Gallagher Davies x 2 Clarke and the re-signed Rudd are all very good players at this level.

Brentford and orient already had a good first division team and brentford have also added quality to their squad where as orient have been consistent in selection.

Orient had a decent season last year and their success is down to a good first team that picks itself. They do have a squad but very few of them have played more than a handful of times. They have 9 players who have featured in 27 or more league games nearly all from the start. Yesterday 8 of them started one was injured and one of the other starters was their top scorer mooney who has 15 goals from 21 starts and 3 as sub. The other starter was an on loan keeper. There first choice keeper started 21 games before a back injury.

Wolves have players who two years ago were in the premier league and jacket has done a good job turning them around and they have been favourites to win the league and remain so.

Whilst we have dropped a number of home points drawing games at home our overall points tally is good and if our home and away form were swapped around I suspect most of those who are worried about our current position would be happier.

I hope Grayson gets us up this year but the gap to the top two is likely to be unachievable more due to the continued performances of the top two not our own lack of points in the run in. The play offs are a lottery and our record is poor.

If we do not make it via the playoffs then next season we will be a real force in this league.

Grayson has done and continues to a good job and is not underachieving.

I expect him to continue to be backed by our owner and hope to see our crowds improve as Grayson continues his work here.

agree Brentford , Wolves and Orient are far better teams …4th is a very fair position …Grayson is steady Eddie with a quite a good record
 
Back
Top