Skip to main content

Joe garner

Joe garner

How much would you be prepared to let him go for? A proven goalscorer at our level isn't that easy to come across (as we saw when we thought we were getting one in Beavon). Would need to be touching £750k for me. Given his record in the championship I don't think that would be good business for Wolves (or whoever else is in for him).

Obviously if Garner decides that he wants to try to engineer a move (something I don't think he'd do - or is that me being a bit naive) then the money we could demand would drop.

750k? I'd be annoyed if we didn't get more than that. I'd be thinking of £1 million as a minimum. Much worse players have been sold for far more.
 
750k? I'd be annoyed if we didn't get more than that. I'd be thinking of £1 million as a minimum. Much worse players have been sold for far more.

I hope you're right, but I think the days of those fees for a 26 year old with one outstanding season in the last six may have passed.
 
I hope you're right, but I think the days of those fees for a 26 year old with one outstanding season in the last six may have passed.

Ross McCormack suggests otherwise. Albeit at a higher level, and 3 great and 4 poor seasons in the last seven. But for 11 million? I think Garner could command 1-1.2million quite easily. I think that what would lower his price is that he has only one year left on his contract. 750k.
 
Ross McCormack suggests otherwise. Albeit at a higher level, and 3 great and 4 poor seasons in the last seven. But for 11 million? I think Garner could command 1-1.2million quite easily. I think that what would lower his price is that he has only one year left on his contract. 750k.

11 million is madness.

There are more proven goalscorers that Championship teams can and should go for before Garner, if PNE don't budge on 1million upwards then I wouldn't mind him going. That money can easily be re-invested using Grayson who's track record at PNE with signings is very good compared to previous managers.
 
We're talking about being generally being content if we get 1 million for Garner - proven league one goal scorer. Then in another thread some are realistically thinking we are bidding £1 million plus for May.

If we sold garner we'd be replacing at half the price surely? Plus, maybe, a Premiership loan.
 
11 million is madness.

There are more proven goalscorers that Championship teams can and should go for before Garner, if PNE don't budge on 1million upwards then I wouldn't mind him going. That money can easily be re-invested using Grayson who's track record at PNE with signings is very good compared to previous managers.

£11m is indeed madness. £10.5m is more like it.
 
Maybe the club have said lets see if he recreates the form shown last season, then 2-3 months into the season if he is still as prolific they offer him the bumper deal that he wants with the correct wage structure. Tying Garner down now would be nice but we have no guarantee he will be the same as last season, however his pre-season form looks like he is hungrier than ever.

Not once has he stated he wants to leave and from a reliable source he's happy at Preston, offering him a big contract now can be seen as a risk and we don't have to jump to quick decisions with Garner as we have him for the whole season if we want. Also if he fires us to promotion, we would be in a stronger position financially and will probably be able to ward off potential suitors in the Championship with the backing of Hemmings, something I think he will do if Grayson proves himself with a promotion season.

Money at PNE has to be used properly and thats why Risdale was brought in, we could give Garner the contract now and then he could get injured, its all about risk assessment. We don't want to fall back into our old ways of giving big money contracts to players who haven't earnt them. I'm not for one minute saying Garner hasn't, but maybe he has a little more convincing to do in the eyes of Grayson and Risdale before they put most of there eggs in Garners basket.
 
the other problem that Grayson could have is resentment from other players if Joey Garner , immediately went on higher wages - If he bangs them in this season it wouldn't be so much of a problem as he'll be getting his team mates win bonuses

I read the report re the Liverpool game in The Liverpool Echo they were impressed with him ! - however they mentioned that Liverpool still have a problem with defending set pieces re the Preston goal . The paper also said Liverpool only really caused the Preston centre halves problems when Brendan brought the kids on and speeded up the game .

Reports


 
Last edited:
A player is only worth what someone is willing to pay for them and the only clubs looking at Garner will be those with money to spend , to sell him for anything less than 1.5-2m is madness . But he's going no where so who cares about rumors
 
Back
Top