Skip to main content

Joe Garner

Joe Garner

Was waiting for my mate after the game & got into a conversation with a Donny fan about JG & it was interesting to see other fans viewpoint of him.

Much of what he used to describe him was unrepeatable but safe to say he wasn't best keen.

Wasn't his best game last night offensively but he did make a couple of great headers defensively.
 
How many times have I said it - Garner needs a robust partner. He is wasted in that lone striker role. I said it even when we seemed to be winning with him in that role. Perhaps now it will be obvious. Play him upfront alongside Davies or Ebanks-Blake or maybe even Beckford. Given that Gallagher will still play and that we need a central midfield partnership of two other players then out of tonight's starting line-up one or other of Robinson and Humphrey needs to give way. These are the decisions SG is paid to make and which frankly he sometimes shies away from.

I think it's about 231 times including today, ernest............but I do agree with you 🙂
 
He was dogshit tonight, but to be fair when he's living off hopeful 60 yard punts, 2 wide men who failed to put a cross in all night and a midfield who didn't get within 30 yards of him for over an hour then it isn't surprising he was dogshit.

Agree with this, but I'm not too sure what should be done to change things - we are 2nd in the league after all.

However, I am worried that that SG has come out and said that we didn't play enough longer passes up to Garner (and beyond their defenders) to allow us to get further up the field. I can see what he is getting at, but their centre halves were gobbling up any long balls, and we had no-one near Garner to give them something else to worry about.

Hopefully, last night was just a blip. Fingers crossed. For what it is worth - I can't see us playing 2 up front on Sat (as some people are calling for one here).
 
He was dogshit tonight, but to be fair when he's living off hopeful 60 yard punts, 2 wide men who failed to put a cross in all night and a midfield who didn't get within 30 yards of him for over an hour then it isn't surprising he was dogshit.

100% this.

Very harsh to slate Garner on that performance given the lack of support in all departments.

Bigger picture needs to be looked at here.
 
Has he really had a decent game since coming back from injury? Even against Chesterfield, he was poor, despite scoring 2 (let's face it 1 was a tap in) and Davies' outshone him. He also was one of the only players to go missing in the Man Utd game I thought. Just looks a shadow of his former self at the minute. Maybe we rushed him back too early, and a rest may do him good. We need him firing on all cylinders in the run in, and we can't be relying on our midfield to do the work for him.
 
How many times have I said it - Garner needs a robust partner. He is wasted in that lone striker role. I said it even when we seemed to be winning with him in that role. Perhaps now it will be obvious. Play him upfront alongside Davies or Ebanks-Blake or maybe even Beckford. Given that Gallagher will still play and that we need a central midfield partnership of two other players then out of tonight's starting line-up one or other of Robinson and Humphrey needs to give way. These are the decisions SG is paid to make and which frankly he sometimes shies away from.
No point writing what I think as you've done it for me!
 
He was dogshit tonight, but to be fair when he's living off hopeful 60 yard punts, 2 wide men who failed to put a cross in all night and a midfield who didn't get within 30 yards of him for over an hour then it isn't surprising he was dogshit.

You contradict yourself

You describe him as dogshit (classy of you) and then go on to say he was provided with no service from midfield or the wings.

Surely you can only question Garner's performance if he gets the service and cocks it up?

The diving is another issue of which he is an appalling example
 
He is playing in the hardest position in the team ie on his own up top. He can't just boot it up front or put it in the stands like a defender can. His job is to get some control over the ball and either pass it out wide or back to a colleague or take it on himself. He does this whilst being marked by 2 defenders- the only player to have 2 opponents on the pitch. If we play 2 up front, then we would lose a winger and some width or a central midfielder. This is the choice our management team have to make, and judging by our position in the league, are doing a pretty good job of it. His theatrical falling does influence refs and sometimes we do suffer from his reputation, but I'd rather he was playing for us than some other team as he has a passion and a hunger for scoring goals.
 
Back
Top