Skip to main content

Keep things in perspective

Keep things in perspective

No point disguising that yesterday was a letdown - we went out with an utterly negative line-up in a match that we needed to win to keep alive the very slim chance we still had of an automatic spot. That three-at-the-back formation with Humphrey and Laird in the wide midfield positions - inevitably because they are the only players we have who can play those roles in that formation to any effect at all - can never do more than attempt to stifle the opposition and then nick one at the other end of the field. It was made worse yesterday by the fact that whatever their other merits none of the three players between those two were really attackers - at the very least Gallagher or Brownhill should have started just behind the front two. But the basic fact is that we have not been good enough to win promotion automatically - too many selections have been on a safety-first basis and, frankly, we have been short all season of at least one other quality wide midfielder. So the play-offs it is. Let's see if we can at least finish third or fourth to get home advantage in the second leg of the semi-finals - that is still a worthwhile target to aim for.
 
Not a wum.genuine question.and this is what i was tring to say,without being insulting.I honestly believe,we will outscore any rivals.Getting a bit tense innit?

Well you haven't outscored us yet and being hard to beat is quite a useful attribute to have in the play-offs.
 
No point disguising that yesterday was a letdown - we went out with an utterly negative line-up in a match that we needed to win to keep alive the very slim chance we still had of an automatic spot. That three-at-the-back formation with Humphrey and Laird in the wide midfield positions - inevitably because they are the only players we have who can play those roles in that formation to any effect at all - can never do more than attempt to stifle the opposition and then nick one at the other end of the field. It was made worse yesterday by the fact that whatever their other merits none of the three players between those two were really attackers - at the very least Gallagher or Brownhill should have started just behind the front two. But the basic fact is that we have not been good enough to win promotion automatically - too many selections have been on a safety-first basis and, frankly, we have been short all season of at least one other quality wide midfielder. So the play-offs it is. Let's see if we can at least finish third or fourth to get home advantage in the second leg of the semi-finals - that is still a worthwhile target to aim for.

Spot on Ernest.
 
I know I am feeling this and I am questioning whether I really want to go and witness a 4th defeat in a play off final !!
Been to every playoff leg we have played and never felt like this reminds me of sheff u playoff semi away crap
Midfield lacks the quality needed against the top sides 27% possession yesterday.
Play Rotherham u in the final and it will be another Wycombe.
 
Midfield lacks the quality needed

The midfield is the key - SG needs to find a formation that can give us the right mix of aggression and creativity in that crucial department. I think we need to go to four at the back hence:

Rudd

Wiseman (or Keane), any two of Clarke, King and Wright, Laird (ideally for his attacking potential) or Buchanan


Upfront it is:

Garner plus Beavon or Davies or Davies (I'm still really not certain what works best but then neither I think is SG)

But that leaves four midfield places and what do we do there? A conventional flat four-man midfield is impossible if we play Gallagher because he always ends up just behind the front two (which is why we really need Laird at left-back because he can get up to exploit the space Gallagher leaves behind). So it seems to me that if play Gallagher in that role (with Brownhill as an alternative) then we have to get what we need by finding a way of perming three out of Welsh, Kilkenny, Holmes and Browne with Brownhill also a candidate to play across the middle. The fact is that even this late in the season we have not really so far found a way of doing so with any consistency.
 
Last edited:
Been to every playoff leg we have played and never felt like this reminds me of sheff u playoff semi away crap
Midfield lacks the quality needed against the top sides 27% possession yesterday.
Play Rotherham u in the final and it will be another Wycombe.

Its a shame, but this is what a lot of fellow nobbers are thinking..

We have had a great season but I fear that we will fall at the final hurdle !
 
Its a shame, but this is what a lot of fellow nobbers are thinking..

We have had a great season but I fear that we will fall at the final hurdle !

Not knocking Grayson love the guy, but hated Brown and Westley for fiddling around with the team formation
Rather stick to a settled formation home and away, and make a point of this is Preston North End try and beat us if your good enough
 
Last edited:
No bite in midfield, too often just hoofing from the back while Brentford had us penned in our own half for 90 minutes, we missed Welsh I thought while Keane was distinctly average, without control in the middle we were exploited
 
Its a shame, but this is what a lot of fellow nobbers are thinking..

We have had a great season but I fear that we will fall at the final hurdle !

I don't really know why though. They haven't beaten us, nor have they outplayed us.

I'm a pessimistic person by nature but I honestly think we've got the beating of Rotherham - it's the other two buggers that'll get us 🙂
 
The midfield is the key - SG needs to find a formation that can give us the right mix of aggression and creativity in that crucial department. I think we need to go to four at the back hence:

Rudd

Wiseman (or Keane), any two of Clarke, King and Wright, Laird (ideally for his attacking potential) or Buchanan


Upfront it is:

Garner plus Beavon or Davies or Davies (I'm still really not certain what works best but then neither I think is SG)

But that leaves four midfield places and what do we do there? A conventional flat four-man midfield is impossible if we play Gallagher because he always ends up just behind the front two (which is why we really need Laird at left-back because he can get up to exploit the space Gallagher leaves behind). So it seems to me that if play Gallagher in that role (with Brownhill as an alternative) then we have to get what we need by finding a way of perming three out of Welsh, Kilkenny, Holmes and Browne with Brownhill also a candidate to play across the middle. The fact is that even this late in the season we have not really so far found a way of doing so with any consistency.

I think we have found that mix today with Welsh and Browne tbh.
 
I think we have found that mix today with Welsh and Browne tbh.

Much as I think he looks a talent, I wouldn't expect him to perform consistently week in-week out, as this rarely happens with young players, and despite his sponsors MOM award, he did give away their second goal.

Let's not "big him up" too much as we've had many false dawns in the past.

Given the right man-management, I think Browne & Brownhill could really excel for us in the next few years, but let's not hail them as the "second coming" after a couple of decent performances.
 
Back
Top