Lightweight midfield
Just today? He has had a pre season honeymoon and has done very little since.Brownhill certainly looked off the pace today. I would play Keane ahead of him for the next couple of matches and give him a rest let him have a bit of time off and find his touch again.
Keith keane.
A bit wreckless and very unorthodox but as ive said, he will bite the ankles out of each opposing player on the pitch if needs be.
And give away countless unnecessary free kicks and consequently goals and points.
No, let's have players showing skill in the North End team rather than ones showing unskilled violence.
Like who?And give away countless unnecessary free kicks and consequently goals and points.
No, let's have players showing skill in the North End team rather than ones showing unskilled violence.
I feel like I must have been watching a different game. I thought Brown was as lively as ever and Kilkenny was class. I do rate Keane though, and I thought King made some important touches when he moved up the pitch a bit.
Just making a sub appearance would make a difference.And give away countless unnecessary free kicks and consequently goals and points.
No, let's have players showing skill in the North End team rather than ones showing unskilled violence.
- Joined
- Mar 25, 2006
- Messages
- 5,724
Imo this is the route we have to take, financially we cant compete with the other promotion contenders and to want pretty football you need money ie, posh, brizzle and even fleetwood.
We can compete with anyone in this league , all down to Hemmings.
Fewer north end fans on today again it would seem from the figures.
Imo this is the route we have to take, financially we cant compete with the other promotion contenders and to want pretty football you need money ie, posh, brizzle and even fleetwood.
IMHO it's not a choice between "pretty" football as you describe it or having less skilful but tougher (some would say dirty) players like Keane in the team.
In the games so far this season we seem to have created plenty of chances but the problems seem to have been not finishing off enough of those chances and most importantly a less solid looking defence than before. Reports suggest that yesterday our left back Davies effectively cost us the win with an awful performance which gave away the goal for instance. Individual defensive errors by the keeper and centre backs have also directly cost us goals and points too.
Having Keane in midfield would result in a far less effective attacking threat, worse ball retention and far more "costly" free kicks conceded.
Need an attack minded midfielder as Kilkenny sits deep so Welsh or Keane would just cut our attacking play
I stated, as a sub and fully agree that attacking threats would be limited.IMHO it's not a choice between "pretty" football as you describe it or having less skilful but tougher (some would say dirty) players like Keane in the team.
In the games so far this season we seem to have created plenty of chances but the problems seem to have been not finishing off enough of those chances and most importantly a less solid looking defence than before. Reports suggest that yesterday our left back Davies effectively cost us the win with an awful performance which gave away the goal for instance. Individual defensive errors by the keeper and centre backs have also directly cost us goals and points too.
Having Keane in midfield would result in a far less effective attacking threat, worse ball retention and far more "costly" free kicks conceded.
- Joined
- Jul 10, 2004
- Messages
- 3,180
I'd be surprised if Keith Keane is even at the club in another 24 hours tbh
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2004
- Messages
- 13,345
Need an attack minded midfielder as Kilkenny sits deep so Welsh or Keane would just cut our attacking play
Kilkenny wouldn't sit deep if King was in midfield. King, Kilkenny and Browne in midfield for me if we are to play 3 central midfielders.
Kilkenny wouldn't sit deep if King was in midfield. King, Kilkenny and Browne in midfield for me if we are to play 3 central midfielders.
Agree
I'd be surprised if Keith Keane is even at the club in another 24 hours tbh
It is obvious we need to offload several players - Keane, Huntington and Buchanan seem to be SG's prime candidates, though Laird appears to be peripheral as well and Holmes is probably not currently amongst their number only because he is injured. Personally I think Keane's energy and tackling still make him a potentially useful option - if he lacks guile he can have a disruptive effect. In contrast Welsh - though he has been a massive player for us and did more than anyone else to avert relegation the season before last - now seems just a shadow of what he was and an honourable free transfer to a Div 2 club where could still run the show would be in everyone's best interest. Laird's career with us seems to be on a knife edge at the moment - it seems evident that he is never going to get back be being what he was before his injury but if he could get back to being at least substantially comparable then he would still be a useful asset. Otherwise an experienced specialist left-back is another item for the shopping list.
- Joined
- Jul 31, 2011
- Messages
- 29
Even though I admire the three killa/Browne/brown hill in midfield i think we are too lightweight and get pushed off to easy in the championship may be different but in league 1 i think we need more muscle
Completely agree, I know we fairly bossed midfield today and Kilkenny and Browne had good games but at times we need someone with a bit of bite in midfield especially through a long season we need someone to get a grip of the game, close people down and get stuck in. I enjoy watching the midfield three they play well together but away from home especially the same three are a bit to lightweight and nice. I know they are out of our price range in everyway but a players like Karl Henry or Dean Marney type of player not the nicest to watch but do a job in breaking the opposition down to let Kilkenny, Browne and Brownhill (Whoever plays) do there thing. Especially if we start playing with two very attacking wingers in Reid and Humphreys. Oh and No Keane is not good enough to do it chases the ball round headless chicken like sometimes and as King keeps showing in whatever position he plays (He was a error waiting to happen in defence in the first half improved in the second yesterday) hes to slow over the first 5 yards.
- Joined
- Oct 19, 2004
- Messages
- 14,851
Completely agree, I know we fairly bossed midfield today and Kilkenny and Browne had good games but at times we need someone with a bit of bite in midfield especially through a long season we need someone to get a grip of the game, close people down and get stuck in. I enjoy watching the midfield three they play well together but away from home especially the same three are a bit to lightweight and nice. I know they are out of our price range in everyway but a players like Karl Henry or Dean Marney type of player not the nicest to watch but do a job in breaking the opposition down to let Kilkenny, Browne and Brownhill (Whoever plays) do there thing. Especially if we start playing with two very attacking wingers in Reid and Humphreys. Oh and No Keane is not good enough to do it chases the ball round headless chicken like sometimes and as King keeps showing in whatever position he plays (He was a error waiting to happen in defence in the first half improved in the second yesterday) hes to slow over the first 5 yards.
But if we play with 2 out and out wingers, it's fitting a midfield 3 into the system. Maybe Grayson will use Reid and Humphrey as the outer players in a front 3 but for me, that would still leave Garner too isolated. We looked much more of a threat yesterday when Hughill came on to support Garner and we switched to 4-4-2.
Kilkenny wouldn't sit deep if King was in midfield. King, Kilkenny and Browne in midfield for me if we are to play 3 central midfielders.
Kilkenny comes deep to get the ball though so would be wasted further up the pitch