Skip to main content

Loanees

Loanees

Joined
Oct 4, 2008
Messages
2,563
Location
New Deer
Just a thought, did the fact that we had a fair percentage of players in on loan affect our overall performance.
Perhaps the 'can't be arsed' attitude permeated the team.
 
I would say out of the Loanees Craig Davies didn't care, Gallagher lost his head after bottling the first game and a half and Rudd could not have done much more than he did. I take on board the point but IMO the answer is no, the reason we lost and/ or did not get promotion this season is too many players both on loan and perminant signings did not turn up in the big games.
 
Brentford did ok with all their loan players didn't they? Gallagher wants to be here but is a bit of a one trick pony. Craig Davies is the only loanee this year that shouldn't have bothered.
 
Craig Davies was a massive disappointment. He looked to have the attributes to be superb in League 1, big, strong and with pace. He should (and did in a couple of games) bully defenders. However, in the first leg he was woeful. Gallagher will never be a workhorse and for me did ok especially at the end of the season. He scored in the second leg and got himself in some decent positions. My problem with him is I'm not sure where he can play in a 4-4-2. He is much better in the hole than out on the left wing. However, if he was available again next season I would sign him because he has the quality that can unlock teams in League 1.
Rudd is an outstanding young goalkeeper and we have been lucky to have him for the last season and a half.

I don't think that loanees have had a negative impact on the club. They have all contributed to a decent season and have appeared to get on well with the rest of the squad. In the end, I think we just lost form at the wrong time of the season and that has ultimately cost us.
 
I would say out of the Loanees Craig Davies didn't care, Gallagher lost his head after bottling the first game and a half and Rudd could not have done much more than he did. I take on board the point but IMO the answer is no, the reason we lost and/ or did not get promotion this season is too many players both on loan and perminant signings did not turn up in the big games.

See what you are saying, but think in the we were beaten by the better team in Rotherham and as far back as coventry away and getting stuffed at home by Oldham and that could have been far worse, our side could not cope with teams breaking on us at pace. Evans did his homework well.

Quick centre back needed and a good game reader. Ssl perhaps.
A overhaul of midfield.
A partner for garner.

Rotherham highlighted our weakness in front of the nation, other teams in our league will have been watching. To achieve the same or more points next season, it will all need sorting before the big kick off 2014/2015
 
I'm always surprised that it's so easy for some to detect a can't be arsed attitude. I think it's slightly more complicated that than. It's a pressure game which can also be mentally draining, and I think Davies was found wanting against a good defence who were playing up to the occasion better. Rotherham did a job on us both legs. Plus we had the usual bad luck hitting the posts but to be fair we would have deserved any more than a consolation goal.
 
I think in terms of having a squad able to challenge for automatic promotion next season we are 80% there. However, it is finding the right balance in that remaining 20% that will decide whether or not we go up, as lets face it we're never going to win the play-offs, no matter how many attempts we have.

The loan market is now part and parcel of football, especially in the lower leagues. When it's used well, team win promotion. When it's used badly, teams gets relegated.

Personally, I think the current defenders we have could win us promotion next season. However, we'd either need to re-sign Rudd or hope that Stuckmann can find form again as undisputed number 1.

In midfield Browne and Brownhill could be massive players for us so I'd look to sign a proper left-winger and a holding midfielder, saying goodbye to Welsh and Holmes and keeping Keane and Kilkenny as squad players.

Upfront I'd keep K Davies for his experience and Beavon for his work-rate and would look specifically for a striker to play with Garner. Whether that's someone like Hume (before he went shite) who can link up play or someone like C Davies was supposed to be (who can bully defenders) will obviously depend on who is available within our budget. After all, there's no point the club spending money it doesn't have chasing a promotion that might happen and end up with a situation like we had a couple of years ago when it all goes tits up.
 
I would say out of the Loanees Craig Davies didn't care, Gallagher lost his head after bottling the first game and a half and Rudd could not have done much more than he did. I take on board the point but IMO the answer is no, the reason we lost and/ or did not get promotion this season is too many players both on loan and perminant signings did not turn up in the big games.

Or alternatively, Rotherham were simply better than us. They had players with class as well as 100% ers - and they have signed up and coming, youthful, hungry players discarded by the fat cats in the prem- rather than our Championship also rans.
 
I think in terms of having a squad able to challenge for automatic promotion next season we are 80% there. However, it is finding the right balance in that remaining 20% that will decide whether or not we go up, as lets face it we're never going to win the play-offs, no matter how many attempts we have.

The loan market is now part and parcel of football, especially in the lower leagues. When it's used well, team win promotion. When it's used badly, teams gets relegated.

Personally, I think the current defenders we have could win us promotion next season. However, we'd either need to re-sign Rudd or hope that Stuckmann can find form again as undisputed number 1.

In midfield Browne and Brownhill could be massive players for us so I'd look to sign a proper left-winger and a holding midfielder, saying goodbye to Welsh and Holmes and keeping Keane and Kilkenny as squad players.

Upfront I'd keep K Davies for his experience and Beavon for his work-rate and would look specifically for a striker to play with Garner. Whether that's someone like Hume (before he went shite) who can link up play or someone like C Davies was supposed to be (who can bully defenders) will obviously depend on who is available within our budget. After all, there's no point the club spending money it doesn't have chasing a promotion that might happen and end up with a situation like we had a couple of years ago when it all goes tits up.

You have obviously seen Stuckman play a lot more than I have to say he has lost his form.
It wasn't that long ago he was POTY.
 
Gallagher is one of our key players and we would struggle to replace his quality, he's not everyone's cup of tea sometimes but even when he's not playing particularly well he can still pop up with a match winning cross or pass.

Rudd, is a no brainer, if we can get him then get it done. I think it's unlikely though.

Craig Davies can do one, we can do better.
 
Gallagher is one of our key players and we would struggle to replace his quality, he's not everyone's cup of tea sometimes but even when he's not playing particularly well he can still pop up with a match winning cross or pass.

Rudd, is a no brainer, if we can get him then get it done. I think it's unlikely though.

Craig Davies can do one, we can do better.

Agreed, I think we will get Rudd back on loan if not permanent, it would be seen as a very good investment if we were to sign him permanently with a clause in of a wage rise if we get to the Championship, he has stated he enjoys it hear and I believe he has bought a house. At Norwich he will be number 2 to Ruddy maybe number 3 if Bunn stays as well, he could sign for a lower league Championship team or a League 1 team that next year could be challenging at the top end of the division again. I would rather have the opportunity to play for a team challenging for automatic promotion or the play offs than a team in limbo in the Championship. I think we have more appeal than some of the clubs in the division above us. Plus it will be very good for his development, 1 being another year in League 1 and 2 under the coaching influence of Alan Kelly.

Craig Davies, I personally wouldn't sign him again because he did seem to have an attitude problem but he does have skill pace and power and on his day is a world beater. The problem for me was his service whilst he played for us, Welsh and Kilkenny's service has been very poor indicated in how many assists they have had this season, people can't expect our strikers to create something out of nothing and he actually did that on 3 occasions against Carlisle, Notts County and Rotherham.

Gallagher no brainer, since he has come in he has been our 2nd most influential player going forward, he looks like he doesn't give a shit when it comes to winning the ball, but is dangerous from set pieces and in a season that only started in November for him he has become our second highest goal scorer and one of the top assisters.
 
He has already gone back to Bolton, so no need to worry about him !!
.....can't read anything into that as Rudd will have returned to Norwich and Gally to Leicester.
If Davies could perform to the standard of his debut I'd defo have him back. Strangely his form collapsed after that.
 
Bolton loaned us Craig Davies and never looked back-jumped up the table.
Bristol City were bottom of league, loaned us Kilkenny-climbed the table.
Leicester City loaned us Gally-won the league and got promoted.
Are they better than what we had? Have they improved us?
Main question-can they get us promoted and can they hack it in the Championship?
 
Bolton loaned us Craig Davies and never looked back-jumped up the table.
Bristol City were bottom of league, loaned us Kilkenny-climbed the table.
Leicester City loaned us Gally-won the league and got promoted.

How many games had they played at those clubs this season before joining us? It's not as though they'd been playing every week in a losing side, joined us and suddenly their parent club started winning every week.
 
How many games had they played at those clubs this season before joining us? It's not as though they'd been playing every week in a losing side, joined us and suddenly their parent club started winning every week.

+1.

Gallagher and Kilkenny are decent players. Craig Davies went off the boil real quick; abysmal first half against Rotherham, in fact he was invisible.
 
Back
Top