Skip to main content

New Captain

New Captain

The Welsh cycle at this level tends to go something like:


- Spell out of the team

- Comes back in and has a stormer first game

- Fans demand that he has to play every week

- Looks off the pace and poor technically for the next 3-4 games

- Back to the bench


He's clearly a good character to have around the squad and good for the odd game, but he's not good enough, or fit enough now it seems, to play consistently at this level. Signing another CM is a must for me.

I still maintain that giving him a contract extension has been shown to be a big mistake Grayson made. It isn't the only one either when you consider the Doyle signing (after being shite on loan for a season), Beckford's extension (although who wouldn't have at the time) etc, etc. Easy to say with hindsight though.
 
I still maintain that giving him a contract extension has been shown to be a big mistake Grayson made. It isn't the only one either when you consider the Doyle signing (after being shite on loan for a season), Beckford's extension (although who wouldn't have at the time) etc, etc. Easy to say with hindsight though.

Welsh was in the side when he was offered the extension, and he'll be small-ish wages I would think so can see why it was offered.

Doyle was the main one though yes, and not even trying Pringle wide left.
 
I still maintain that giving him a contract extension has been shown to be a big mistake Grayson made. It isn't the only one either when you consider the Doyle signing (after being shite on loan for a season), Beckford's extension (although who wouldn't have at the time) etc, etc. Easy to say with hindsight though.

You can look at his contract extension as a cost but it's worth thinking about it across the team: it was much better to be able to have kept hold of our best players and eventually get millions for Hughill by offering people playing well contract extensions when we did, rather than waiting and ending up like Barnsley and losing half our team on more-or-less a free.
 
Captain does a lot behind the scenes and all these duties will still be Tom Clarke. Until he returns to fitness it will just be band a player wears on matchday so personally I wouldn't put much thought into it

I understand where you are coming form, but I still believe you need a leader on the pitch as captain. So, for me captain has got to be

(1) a leader
(2) likely to be on the pitch

so, I exclude Gally, Welsh, both keepers, Pearson etc under condition (2)

Looks like Huntington (or Cunningham) to me then.
 
If John Welsh is part of the squad as cover for Pearson, I'll be perfectly happy. Always gonna give 100%, especially in occasional appearances.
 
Welsh was in the side when he was offered the extension, and he'll be small-ish wages I would think so can see why it was offered.

Doyle was the main one though yes, and not even trying Pringle wide left.

I had totally forgotten about Ben Pringle even being here. Says a lot in itself really...

You can look at his contract extension as a cost but it's worth thinking about it across the team: it was much better to be able to have kept hold of our best players and eventually get millions for Hughill by offering people playing well contract extensions when we did, rather than waiting and ending up like Barnsley and losing half our team on more-or-less a free.

I see your point. As I said, with the hindsight of his injuries and lack of playing time, it was a mistake. At the time, I don't think anybody was too disappointed by it.
 
Pearson for me it will be a proud moment for him not only this but it would give him something else to think about if another team came sniffing knowing how valuable to the team he is.
 
I still maintain that giving him a contract extension has been shown to be a big mistake Grayson made. It isn't the only one either when you consider the Doyle signing (after being shite on loan for a season), Beckford's extension (although who wouldn't have at the time) etc, etc. Easy to say with hindsight though.

I doubt he's on massive money so wasn't a very costly "mistake" compared to others you've mentioned, but yeah not ideal that he's not kicked a ball since he signed his extension. I remember his interview about the extension and him saying he'd hoped to be back in a few weeks. It's been 9 months. He can't be relied upon IMHO.
 
I understand where you are coming form, but I still believe you need a leader on the pitch as captain. So, for me captain has got to be

(1) a leader
(2) likely to be on the pitch

so, I exclude Gally, Welsh, both keepers, Pearson etc under condition (2)

Looks like Huntington (or Cunningham) to me then.

Agree

Might be a little early to call, but as it stands Hunts for me.

Pearson might be on the pitch more this time around as well as maybe one of the keepers set in stone just to give some further options. I am still hoping for a couple of signatures who might be in with a shout.
 
Shouldn't the Captain be the first name on the teamsheet and the one that is never dropped due to his consistency?..................... That should narrow it down a bit.
 
Does anyone think Ben Pearson would make a good Captain at the club or would it wind him up to get sent off more than he does? At the moment with Tom injured we don't have the most vocal players and I think it needs addressing. Obviously the Captain channels the managers philosophy through the players so I guess this will be an issue for AN to solve fairly soon.

Sent from my LG-H815 using Tapatalk

If Tom Clarke didn't have his injury, he'd be a Sunderland player today. His absence is like losing 3 players. Perhaps Spurr or Baptiste can step into his formidable boots for half a season at least. If Hunts were an ever present, I'd hand him the arm band. He looks like a good leader and he relates to the fans better than Clarke too.
Give it Gallagher. Senior pro.
 
If Tom Clarke didn't have his injury, he'd be a Sunderland player today. His absence is like losing 3 players. Perhaps Spurr or Baptiste can step into his formidable boots for half a season at least. If Hunts were an ever present, I'd hand him the arm band. He looks like a good leader and he relates to the fans better than Clarke too.
Give it Gallagher. Senior pro.

What makes you think Baptiste will be back?
 
If Tom Clarke didn't have his injury, he'd be a Sunderland player today. His absence is like losing 3 players. Perhaps Spurr or Baptiste can step into his formidable boots for half a season at least. If Hunts were an ever present, I'd hand him the arm band. He looks like a good leader and he relates to the fans better than Clarke too.
Give it Gallagher. Senior pro.

Not sure about that, think Clarke was proud to be PNE captain, seems like a loyal type of player
 
Back
Top