One football rule change for next season is a amendment to the offside rule, where you only have to be interfereing or make a movement of some kind towards the ball to be classed as being offside. ? So as a example Rooney standing in front of Stuckie for Utd 3rd goal v PNE last season it wasn't ruled offside, due to him not touching the ball although his foot movement wrong footed TS well next season it will be classed as being offside. If a player is standing in a GK line of vision or blocks a GK change of direction easy?
New Offside Rule?
One football rule change for next season is a amendment to the offside rule, where you only have to be interfereing or make a movement of some kind towards the ball to be classed as being offside. ? So as a example Rooney standing in front of Stuckie for Utd 3rd goal v PNE last season it wasn't ruled offside, due to him not touching the ball although his foot movement wrong footed TS well next season it will be classed as being offside. If a player is standing in a GK line of vision or blocks a GK change of direction easy?
So it's an offence to be interfering with balls? Common sense I'd have thought.
NORTHENDRTOPS
French scout
One football rule change for next season is a amendment to the offside rule, where you only have to be interfereing or make a movement of some kind towards the ball to be classed as being offside. ? So as a example Rooney standing in front of Stuckie for Utd 3rd goal v PNE last season it wasn't ruled offside, due to him not touching the ball although his foot movement wrong footed TS well next season it will be classed as being offside. If a player is standing in a GK line of vision or blocks a GK change of direction easy?
common sense prevails, imo all 3 of those goals were suspect, but I would say that
What about our first goal against Swindon at Wembley?
Was Super Tommy Clarke not deceiving their 'keeper?
Was Super Tommy Clarke not deceiving their 'keeper?
I thought interference was already classified as offside, but Rooney was deemed to not be interfering (incorrectly).
Who knows? Confusing, this rules lark.
Who knows? Confusing, this rules lark.
What about our first goal against Swindon at Wembley?
Was Super Tommy Clarke not deceiving their 'keeper?
Everyone was onside when ball was played so no
- Joined
- Apr 8, 2012
- Messages
- 6,513
What about our first goal against Swindon at Wembley?
Was Super Tommy Clarke not deceiving their 'keeper?
No. It's only bad when something goes against you. That's also in the rules of football.
NORTHENDRTOPS
French scout
Everyone was onside when ball was played so no[/QUO
He's probably right so let's go back and do it again Yaaaaay another day out !!!!!!!!!!
Everyone was onside when ball was played so no
When Beckford took his touch, Clarke is cleary a couple of feet off-side, right between Beckford and the Goalie. This new rule says to me that there is a strong chance that this goal would've been ruled out.
When Beckford took his touch, Clarke is cleary a couple of feet off-side, right between Beckford and the Goalie. This new rule says to me that there is a strong chance that this goal would've been ruled out.
It absolutely should have been ruled out. Beats me how under the "old" rule it wasn't classed as offside. Or the linesman didn't see him.
It absolutely should have been ruled out. Beats me how under the "old" rule it wasn't classed as offside. Or the linesman didn't see him.
...but should probably have been a penalty as well for their defender trying to haul Beckford down.
It absolutely should have been ruled out. Beats me how under the "old" rule it wasn't classed as offside. Or the linesman didn't see him.
Well we played that game under the old rules so it wasn't and we won 4 - 0 so its obvious I'm right thread closed
...but should probably have been a penalty as well for their defender trying to haul Beckford down.
Ok so it should have been decided on a coin flip.
- Joined
- Jul 21, 2010
- Messages
- 39,377
It absolutely should have been ruled out. Beats me how under the "old" rule it wasn't classed as offside. Or the linesman didn't see him.
Interesting. I hadn't seen that this rule change was coming in (thanks for the heads-up Keith). It takes us back to nearer the offside interpretation that I played under (but still more in the attacking team's favour now).
But even back then, I suspect that Beckford's goal would have stood. Technically, you could say Clarke was offside, but I just don't think they were given in situations of close-combat like that, with the ball whizzing past him unwittingly into the net.
Whilst they are rule changing - can they stop the wrestling matches that break out at every corner kick.
Or award penalties.
Or award penalties.
Interesting. I hadn't seen that this rule change was coming in (thanks for the heads-up Keith). It takes us back to nearer the offside interpretation that I played under (but still more in the attacking team's favour now).
But even back then, I suspect that Beckford's goal would have stood. Technically, you could say Clarke was offside, but I just don't think they were given in situations of close-combat like that, with the ball whizzing past him unwittingly into the net.
I don't see how the keeper wasn't impeded. Clarke ran across right as Beckford contacted the ball if I remember correctly.