Skip to main content

No Striker Needed

No Striker Needed

Doyle wasn't brilliant yesterday, but when he's asked to play against 6ft 4 and a 6ft 3 centre backs as a target man, it's not going to go down well. Grayson did him no favours.

Doyle is a supporting striker who needs to be played alongside someone else with some disruptive presence - Beckford, Hugill, Makienok of our other strikers not Robinson. Whether he would then deliver remains to be seen but playing him as a lone striker at this level - irrespective of whether he might have managed it a division lower - is an exercise in utter futility. There is nothing wrong with trying things out but when they obviously do not work then you have to stop and if SG persists with trying to play Doyle that way then it might be evidence that he has genuinely lost the plot.
 
Doyle wasn't brilliant yesterday, but when he's asked to play against 6ft 4 and a 6ft 3 centre backs as a target man, it's not going to go down well. Grayson did him no favours.

First bit of sense made on this thread. With Garner going we have to change the way we play as the personnel we have can't handle long high balls pumped to them. Grayson did Doyle no favours at all, it was only when Hugill came on that thinks improved and I don't think he's the answer.
 
There was clearly money available otherwise we wouldn't have signed Marnick. Maybe it was a straight choice in buying a full back or a striker & SG chose the former. Who knows?

Either way not signing a replacement for Garner will come back to bite him IMO.

We clearly needed money to strengthen the defence and renew contracts. We could not afford to replace Garner and I guess the powers that be felt we were well stocked with strikers with May to come back. Though Doyle is no superstar I think he will net a few if played up alongside Hugill or Makienok supported by Robinson and McGeady.
 
Doyle wasn't brilliant yesterday, but when he's asked to play against 6ft 4 and a 6ft 3 centre backs as a target man, it's not going to go down well. Grayson did him no favours.

Doyle is nowehere near good enough for this league irrespective of that.
 
We clearly needed money to strengthen the defence and renew contracts. We could not afford to replace Garner and I guess the powers that be felt we were well stocked with strikers with May to come back. Though Doyle is no superstar I think he will net a few if played up alongside Hugill or Makienok supported by Robinson and McGeady.

He will be lucky to hit double figures.
 
I'm guessing the guy who started this thread has at least 2 braincells or has amnesia. We have strickers that can finish and we saw that with Beckford in league one, yes he didn't score many last season but he was injured for most of it and now hes injured again. We also have May who guess what is injured and Doyle well personally he holds the ball up well but needs another strike partner. Hugill played well yesterday and gave it his all and Makeionok well he hardly ever plays and we cant really base a judgment on him.
 
Doyle is a supporting striker who needs to be played alongside someone else with some disruptive presence - Beckford, Hugill, Makienok of our other strikers not Robinson. Whether he would then deliver remains to be seen but playing him as a lone striker at this level - irrespective of whether he might have managed it a division lower - is an exercise in utter futility. There is nothing wrong with trying things out but when they obviously do not work then you have to stop and if SG persists with trying to play Doyle that way then it might be evidence that he has genuinely lost the plot.

From the little we have seen of him so far, disruptive presence does not come to mind !
 
I didn't mind us signing Doyle, a 3 year contract is too long, but I wasn't opposed to us signing him.

However, Doyle should have been signed as a 4th choice striker - not the focal point of our attack. He should be a squad player who comes off the bench in the later stages of games which is when he is most effective - to be fair he poached some important goals last year from inside the box towards the end of games. But to task him with leading our attack as a loan striker from the start is suicide.
 
Back
Top