Skip to main content

offside and a dive

offside and a dive

John, do you think that if this had happened outside of the area and a slide tackle had come in he would have gone down or stayed on his feet and ran on goal with the ball'. To me if no contact was made, which there wasn't, if Rooney could have stayed on his feet, which he could, if Stuckmann had intended to bring Rooney down, which he didn't he intended to get the ball, then yes it would have been a penalty bug to me Rooney cheated.


If Rooney had stayed on his feet Stuckers would have brought him down. He jumped to avoid getting clattered. Penalty either way.

There was no need for Stuckers to chase him as he was running away from goal.

If this had happened to Garner, no one would have complained or said he dived.
 
Davies was lucky. He's made a career of stamping elbowing and going through the back of players. Last night when he wasn't being a dirty sod, he was throwing himself on the floor and Dowd gave him most of those 50/50 decisions. Rooneys not impairing anybody's vision, stuckman was slow to react, as he was indecisive with the cross for the second. I also don't think it was a push on Clarke, he was just stronger, its a contact sport, if you blow up every to.e somebody is touched then the game would never get going or finish. If this makes me an apologist then so be it.

Not the way I saw it at all, quite the opposite.

Dowd was penalising Bailey Wright all night against Falcao when in my view he was clearly winning the ball.
 
Here is what should have happened. The linesman should have raised his flag for offside, as he was in no position to determine whether or not Rooney was interfering with Stuckmann's sight line.

Then the ref (I use that word loosely) would have been able to think about the decision, maybe even consult the linesman, and then determine if Rooney was indeed a)in an offside position (which we all know he was) and b) interfering with play.

The linesman had no right to leave both decisions to Dowd, and by not raising his flag, in effect he did not communicate with the referee that Rooney was in an offside position.

I knew we would be in trouble as soon as I saw Dowd was the referee, and true to form he put in yet another un-professional performance. TV replays clearly showed no contact between Stuckmann and Rooney.

Dowd is clueless, the linesman incompetent, we are out of the cup but made some dosh so it is what it is.

Absolutely.

The offside law (law 11) states that it's an offence if the player is in an offside position , which Rooney was, and gaining an advantage, again which Rooney clearly was by distracting our keeper and causing a delay in his reaction to the shot.

Had North End scored a goal exactly like that it would have been ruled out for offside. No question about that at all.

Had Davies put both hands in the back of his opponent in the six yard box, got himself a clear header and scored just as Fellaini did then he would have been penalised and the goal ruled out.

The powers at Manchester United exerted enough pressure on Dowd and the other officials to ensure that the key decisions went their way. And as per usual the officials obliged.

Was good to see the North End players giving it their best shot and scaring the crap out of Utd but sad to see the dubious ways in which Utd achieved the win. Sad to see a player with such talent as Rooney cheat in the way he did against a third division team to get the penalty and sad to hear the England manager condoning Rooney's dive. Disgraceful that is.

If Garner had dived so blatantly I would have been very, very embarrassed.
 
But he did jump didn't he that was his decision, therefore a dive, no penalty and a booking for Rooney.

If Ashley Young had done it then, with his history of diving, everybody would have accepted it as the dive it clearly was. It's only because Rooney is the golden boy of English football that some people don't want to admit it.

I can't wait to hear Hodgson next complain when an opponent of England does the exact same thing.

Pathetic that a player as good as Rooney resorts to that against a League One team and pathetic that people defend it especially the England manager.

Money and cheating, ruining the game.
 
I never said he didn't dive, I said the net outcome was the same so it becomes irrelevant.


Its totally relevant you say the intent was there yet Rooney lept very early and after coming down well clear of the advancing keeper left a leg in so far beyond the challenge it was funny then went down like a sack of spuds about six feet from him on the second stride . Had the linesman been up with play it would have been a booking for simulation .

If we are going to start booking people for sliding in then thats the end of slide tackles as we know it .

Was it a penalty ? no it wasn't , was he offside for the other goal and interfering with play ? without a doubt , was his conversation with man of the match Dowd ( with three assists ) dubious you bet your ass it was .
 
Absolutely.

The offside law (law 11) states that it's an offence if the player is in an offside position , which Rooney was, and gaining an advantage, again which Rooney clearly was by distracting our keeper and causing a delay in his reaction to the shot.

Had North End scored a goal exactly like that it would have been ruled out for offside. No question about that at all.

Had Davies put both hands in the back of his opponent in the six yard box, got himself a clear header and scored just as Fellaini did then he would have been penalised and the goal ruled out.

The powers at Manchester United exerted enough pressure on Dowd and the other officials to ensure that the key decisions went their way. And as per usual the officials obliged.

Was good to see the North End players giving it their best shot and scaring the crap out of Utd but sad to see the dubious ways in which Utd achieved the win. Sad to see a player with such talent as Rooney cheat in the way he did against a third division team to get the penalty and sad to hear the England manager condoning Rooney's dive. Disgraceful that is.

This..

The last time I watched Utd at Deepdale they got a dodgy decision that saved them from defeat (anyone else remember?). I don't mind if they don't come back to Deepdale for another 40yrs.

Can I say for the record.. the PREMIER LEAGUE has ruined English football.

Pathetic that a player as good as Rooney resorts to that against a League One team and pathetic that people defend it especially the England manager.

Money and cheating, ruining the game.

Next time I suggest they just give us a few million and we let them go through without all the charade of playing a game.

Do those on here defending the ref really believe we would have got those decisions ?
 
Last edited:
I am sure that if these decisions had gone the other way and we had scored with a player in an off side position, as close to the goal, goalie and ball as Rooney was, and one of our players went down for a penalty without DeGear touching him, all f their players would have been around the ef like a rash. Our players, and I am very proud of them for this, whilst not liking the decision did not crowd the ref, etc. we were the sportsmen and didn't feel the need to cheat. Man Utd were not convinced of their own skills to beat usp alone and felt they had to cheat to still be in with a chance of winning something this year. I hope Arsepnal stuff them!
 
Back
Top