Skip to main content

Players throwing games

Players throwing games

Joined
Aug 12, 2006
Messages
6,888
Now that we know there was an orchestrated player rebellion to lose at home 1:5 to I think it was Mansfield under Beck do any of you think a player who had an allegiance with another manager would deliberately throw a game ?
 
Now that we know there was an orchestrated player rebellion to lose at home 1:5 to I think it was Mansfield under Beck do any of you think a player who had an allegiance with another manager would deliberately throw a game ?

do you mean nash against derby , because while i believe this is unthinkable ive been around football long enough to never say never about anything , if ive read you wrong then im sorry ,
 
without joining in with all this Nash crap (based on him applauding our own fans!)

Yes, I do.

I also think a player would throw a game for not liking a manager, or betting on a match or having his mistress saying he will get a BJ if he did.

Which player would do that....fook knows. Thats one for the psycologists.
 
Now that we know there was an orchestrated player rebellion to lose at home 1:5 to I think it was Mansfield under Beck do any of you think a player who had an allegiance with another manager would deliberately throw a game ?
Do you mean, "The Barry Siddall Incident?"
First I've heard of that game being thrown. Where do you "know" this from?
 
We must be getting very close to libel here - perhaps this thread should be deleted -we can all think what we want but we should be careful about what we publish in the public domain,m'learned friends might have a field day
But I am interested in the Mansfield story - if anyone could put some flesh on the bones
 
We must be getting very close to libel here - perhaps this thread should be deleted -we can all think what we want but we should be careful about what we publish in the public domain,m'learned friends might have a field day
But I am interested in the Mansfield story - if anyone could put some flesh on the bones

i was at that mansfield game and the way in which we lost that day was remarkable inept wasnt the word. north end played like a bunch of strangers and had no fight in them at all , we stood on the pavillion shaking our heads in the end and im sure that mansfield were down there with us although my memory isnt what it was , but the end of that game feeling will stay with me forever as ive seen us hammerd before but never have i seen a team roll over so easily in all my time as a north end fan. but did they throw the game i couldnt say but what i do know is the standard of play that day was pittyfull.
 
yes i remember this game. if memory serves mansfield had already been relegated. we went 1-0 up then i think it was norbury who missed a pen to make it 2-0. went on to loose 1-5 and be relegated on the last day a bolton. how different things might have been if we had won that game cos the 3 points would have seen us safe that year.
 
I`m not having any conspiracy theory about Nash, he nearly kept out the penalty remember?

I'm with you Shaky, its a ludicrous claim albeit no names mentioned!

Okram, wise words but no names have been mentioned just questioned by others.
 
Ironically, that relegation was the best thing to happen for us. For those that don't remember that far back, the mood of the fans has already turned when half-way through an awful losing game against Swansea the Town End suddenly decided to start cheering no matter how crap we were. After we went down we were winning lots of matches and the atmosphere just built and built the next season, finishing with losing at Wembley and then promotion the year after. If we hadn't gone down, and we had been a bottom end team in a higher division again, would the Town End magic still have happened?
 
Ironically, that relegation was the best thing to happen for us. For those that don't remember that far back, the mood of the fans has already turned when half-way through an awful losing game against Swansea the Town End suddenly decided to start cheering no matter how crap we were. After we went down we were winning lots of matches and the atmosphere just built and built the next season, finishing with losing at Wembley and then promotion the year after. If we hadn't gone down, and we had been a bottom end team in a higher division again, would the Town End magic still have happened?


How can relegation be a good thing? Beck took us down like the fool he was.
 
Do you mean, "The Barry Siddall Incident?"
First I've heard of that game being thrown. Where do you "know" this from?

You're thinking of a different game !!

That slap head played once against port vale ( thank god ) !!!!!

He did still let 5 in though 😎
 
When Gary Peters was in charge I had a long conversation with a certain gentleman, who had agreed to meet me and a friend in the Black Bull in Preston to give me an interview for a publication I was helping with.

Although the Mansfield game wasn't mentioned specifically, the gentleman (who had close relationships with Chapman, Peters and Beck (as close as it was possible to get to Beck because of his unpredictable and at times aloof character) told me that when Beck took over and started implementing his 'methods', the players at Preston despised him but wanted to stay at the club. Hence, a clique of players formed who agreed that the way forward was to get Beck the sack by losing games. If anyone wants to PM me I'll tell them the name of the person (not rocket science), as long as they promise not to post it on here.

Referring to Norbur's penalty miss in the Mansfield game as a form of match-rigging is inaccurate: Norbury was a Beck signing and was Beck through and through. It's also wrong to single out the Mansfield game in particular - the players lost lots of games before this one.

As for deleting the thread because of legal worries - Okram, you nerd.
 
Back
Top