Matchday Thread PNE v Ipswich - 03/02/24 - KO:3PM - Championship

[JOE TOTALE]

I used to ref quite a few rugby games back in the day and in truth relied on a lot of guess work during rucks and mauls, I feel Saturdays officials were following my playbook.

All decisions of the laws are applied in the opinion of the referee, he/she has the final decision to make.

As for guessing, if you dont/cannot see it you don't give it. it will come back and give you grief,

I have learnt that in my early days of officiating Mr S!

 

[Doyler]

Please can we stop this ridiculous light show when people start to get bored in the second half? It’s tinpot as fuck

 

[noelpne]

Ron seems to be as safe from a ban as Ryan is from the sack. Are we also having to wait until our next financial year before the moron gets banned?

😂 But who are you talking about 😂?

 

[noelpne]

All decisions of the laws are applied in the opinion of the referee, he/she has the final decision to make.

That's the prob. with the Premier League's VAR - it makes those Premier Refs. less likely to get a decision "spot-on" as they're aware that the VAR people would overule him in all likelihood .

 

[noelpne]

Same question to you also as if you’re right then the law needs changing IMO.

Comparing the opportunity denial to Mads verses the Leeds penalty because of the ball-to-arm of Ledson..... that's two laws need revising.
( I know it's nothing to do with denying LUFC a goal-scoring-opportunity & I'm not comparing the 2 incidents) It's just that both were wrong decisions.

 

[noelpne]

Seeing people say he was the worst ref all season, they must not have seen the Wednesday game

Keeping the gender thing well-away ( & it's totally irrelevant, imo ) from this - that Woman Referee we had a few games back had a very poor show.

 

[JOE TOTALE]

That's the prob. with the Premier League's VAR - it makes those Premier Refs. less likely to get a decision "spot-on" as they're aware that the VAR people would overule him in all likelihood .

Quite right Noel, overrule or give assistance on a split second decision that may be corrected from an original one.It can work both ways.
Yet the same faces in the premier league management and on the ex pro/hosts on the punditry 'game' shows(Sky etc) were crying out for review of decisions by tv.video means.
None ,as far as I know have had any officiating experience bar their own 5 a side training sessions in their day..
Dont get me wrong , I get frustrated with decisions against us but after second re think more often than not I try to see how that decision was calculated. Not always mind!
Tough job, in the middle , lines and even fourth official duties on occasion!
For what my opinions worth , leave it to the officials on the field.
After all we got away with it Saturday for the well finished own goal, the next match it could go against us, that's football throughout its time.

 

[TheWarehouse]

Keeping the gender thing well-away ( & it's totally irrelevant, imo ) from this - that Woman Referee we had a few games back had a very poor show.

That’s who I was talking about, dreadful

 

[Bobbage]

I’ve gone and looked into it and it would have been an IDFK with no booking to the keeper.

Oh good. I saw your post earlier... 😉

Red card for denying a clear goal scoring opportunity when he’s not allowed to touch it with his hands.

Incorrect.

Go on then, what would the correct decision been if he’d blown for an infringement against the keeper for handling the goal from a back pass whilst at the same time denying a clear goal coring opportunity?

An indirect free-kick for handball in the area from a back pass.

I’ve said that several times, any card for the keeper?

No

Is that your interpretation or is that you knowing the law 100%.

You can find out here

 

[milkyken]

Please can we stop this ridiculous light show when people start to get bored in the second half? It’s tinpot as fuck

Add in to that the Blackpool chants and the latest “it’s all gone quiet over there” which seems to have had a reappearance from the 1980’s!!

We do look and sound pretty shit at times but im also wondering because of the anti Lowe vibes , it is also affecting the atmosphere. 3-0 up and you could hear a pin drop ….

 

[Doyler]

Add in to that the Blackpool chants and the latest “it’s all gone quiet over there” which seems to have had a reappearance from the 1980’s!!

We do look and sound pretty shit at times but im also wondering because of the anti Lowe vibes , it is also affecting the atmosphere. 3-0 up and you could hear a pin drop ….

Yeah. I mean I’m anti-Lowe and I’m still not weird enough to switch my phone torch on like.

 

[Ando60]

Please can we stop this ridiculous light show when people start to get bored in the second half? It’s tinpot as fuck

What does it mean Doyler….

I noticed it again on Saturday when there was about 15 mins left.

 

[Sid Snot]

I’d consider it a privilege to deliver them personally Sid. 👍😃

You will be most welcome here anytime 👍

 

[Bobbage]

What does it mean Doyler….

I noticed it again on Saturday when there was about 15 mins left.

"Oh Benny Woodburn, you are the light of my life..."

 

[Regardless]

To reiterate what others have said, once we had been made aware action was swiftly taken against the user in question. Please reconsider your decision as we don't want you to feel that we'd ever have condoned such language

Very pleased to see @Keeper1 liked this... and posted later 👍

I’ve gone and looked into it and it would have been an IDFK with no booking to the keeper.

Your incorrect about never being booked for handling the ball in his area though.
A keeper can be booked for handling the ball in his area if they handle after a dead ball kick which doesn’t leave the area, that can be a red if it prevents a clear goalscoring opportunity.

I wasn't aware of the vastly different sanctions against the keeper if they handle a backless in those two different circumstances. It makes no sense to me. They are essentially identical offences.

 

[Flaxby White]

Add in to that the Blackpool chants and the latest “it’s all gone quiet over there” which seems to have had a reappearance from the 1980’s!!

We do look and sound pretty shit at times but im also wondering because of the anti Lowe vibes , it is also affecting the atmosphere. 3-0 up and you could hear a pin drop ….

Agree, Anyone up for the return of
I hear the sound of distant bums or
go home you bums, go home you bums go home

 

[Jack Daniels]

Only just read this thread, a full month behind.

Stuff suddenly makes sense.

Ron, you silly sausage. Too late for you now.

You makes your bed...