Skip to main content

Premiership Loans

Premiership Loans

Joined
Jul 5, 2006
Messages
6,659
Is it me or are we battling against clubs who have the benefit of major loan signings from the Premiership.

What annoys me is the number of imports that are ruining the game in this Country - we have no chance of developing a quality England team for the future and what chance does youth have.

The knock on effect being that clubs like Birmingham and Derby can afford to accommodate the loan of surplus or future stars from the Premiership. This also applied to Watford last year with Eagles and Roberts.

I am concerned re the uneven playing field that is being created in the Championship - to me the Premiership is a crap league that is destroying the game in this country.

My view is that imports should be limited to a set number per club - thus ensuring that only quality players will be sourced who will play rather than being loaned to others.

Really annoys me at present - crap Premiership, crap Football Association.

What are you views ?????
 
Sorry elwiss ,brought this same subject 2 wks ago,you must have missed it
try summat else
 
Is it me or are we battling against clubs who have the benefit of major loan signings from the Premiership.

What annoys me is the number of imports that are ruining the game in this Country - we have no chance of developing a quality England team for the future and what chance does youth have.

The knock on effect being that clubs like Birmingham and Derby can afford to accommodate the loan of surplus or future stars from the Premiership. This also applied to Watford last year with Eagles and Roberts.

I am concerned re the uneven playing field that is being created in the Championship - to me the Premiership is a crap league that is destroying the game in this country.

My view is that imports should be limited to a set number per club - thus ensuring that only quality players will be sourced who will play rather than being loaned to others.

Really annoys me at present - crap Premiership, crap Football Association.

What are you views ?????
Couldn't agree more, but would take it further by stopping Prmiership Loans to League clubs. It distorts the league and is not in the spirit of true competition and makes the league just another play thing for Premiership interests. Football league football is more than a training ground for Premiership footballers.
Without the Arsenal players would Birmingham be at the top, would Stoke be the force they are, Leeds are fielding a team with 5 loan players. Who are their supporters watching certainly not their home club.
If we went in this direction with a third of the team loan players, for me, it would rip the soul out of my club. I want to watch PNE not a gang of mercenaries.
 
Couldn't agree more, but would take it further by stopping Prmiership Loans to League clubs. It distorts the league and is not in the spirit of true competition and makes the league just another play thing for Premiership interests. Football league football is more than a training ground for Premiership footballers.
Without the Arsenal players would Birmingham be at the top, would Stoke be the force they are, Leeds are fielding a team with 5 loan players. Who are their supporters watching certainly not their home club.
If we went in this direction with a third of the team loan players, for me, it would rip the soul out of my club. I want to watch PNE not a gang of mercenaries.
Not only that, but fined for trying to field 6 in the team at any one time. The loan system is a joke. If clubs like Birmingham, Derby and the like are promoted of the back of the loan system, how can they be developing for the future and providing a legacy for future fans of their respective clubs?
Indeed, Leeds may well get relegated on the back of this policy and this would just demonstrate the catastrophic effect of relying on paying for overpriced and under-researched players, paying massive wages, gambling on european success and almost losing everything - in the first place.
Can a premiership club really say that the interests of a potentially good player is served by lending them to a bottom of the league club, if they are in with 4 other loanees?
What happened to the maximum number of loans per season?
 
Not only that, but fined for trying to field 6 in the team at any one time. The loan system is a joke. If clubs like Birmingham, Derby and the like are promoted of the back of the loan system, how can they be developing for the future and providing a legacy for future fans of their respective clubs?
Indeed, Leeds may well get relegated on the back of this policy and this would just demonstrate the catastrophic effect of relying on paying for overpriced and under-researched players, paying massive wages, gambling on european success and almost losing everything - in the first place.
Can a premiership club really say that the interests of a potentially good player is served by lending them to a bottom of the league club, if they are in with 4 other loanees?
What happened to the maximum number of loans per season?

The loan system only serves the interest of Premiership clubs. it enables them to carry even bigger squads without the itinerent costs involved, they can sign young promising players with the promise of first team footie at a loan club, starving League clubs of young and potentially valuable talent.
They have tried to get B teams in the League but can't, so they are now doing it by proxy, some teams will become in all but name Arsenal, Chelsea, Man U reserves and do very well at the expense of less well connected clubs.

I do not like the Premiership more people watch League footie every week than Prem and take away the top 4 and there is not much difference in attendances. A case of the tail wagging the dog.
 
The loan system should be scrapped as its nothin more than a cheats charter with a few favour'd clubs being aided by the prem to step up to the prem each year...... nothin more nothing less
 
Loans are good, too many are bad. 3 should be the absolute maximum allowed to play at once.

Birmingham, like they needed the help, have been pretty much sponsored to promotion by Arsenal.
 
Top post Hunter , good points one and all. The way the likes of Birmngham work the loans is an absolute joke, made even more ridiculous when they start lending their own 'fringe' players to lower leagues for experience.

Stoke are a particular example of a completely bogus rise up the table on the back of other clubs players.

If this isn't stopped, and so called 'big clubs' like Birmingham continue to act as development centres for up and comers,the premier league fat cats will be able to continue signing (poaching) any youngster showing any sort of potential without ever intending to play them themselves.
 
Loans should be treated like the NFL draft. The loaning club should register the players they are prepared to lend, and under what terms, with the FA.

Then the team at the bottom of division 2 should have first pick.

Clearly Torquay couldn't afford a young international, but they could take the best player in their price range. Macclesfield can't complain as they get next pick.

United get last pick, and most loaning clubs would insist on an amount of first team football as a condition, so they may not bother. Then we go back to Torquay.

Of course there would be some bending of rules. But I think it's the only way to stop Wenger lending two or three players to his pals in the Championship and having a big say in who goes up.
 
Loans should be treated like the NFL draft. The loaning club should register the players they are prepared to lend, and under what terms, with the FA.

Then the team at the bottom of division 2 should have first pick.

Clearly Torquay couldn't afford a young international, but they could take the best player in their price range. Macclesfield can't complain as they get next pick.

United get last pick, and most loaning clubs would insist on an amount of first team football as a condition, so they may not bother. Then we go back to Torquay.

Of course there would be some bending of rules. But I think it's the only way to stop Wenger lending two or three players to his pals in the Championship and having a big say in who goes up.

Not a bad shout however the bigger clubs would be reluctant to let their young stars join clubs like Torquay or Macclefield. They send them out on loan to improve as players; something they wouldn't do in the football basement. I would like to see a limit on the number of loanees and possibly the length on the loan?
 
The loan system should be scrapped as its nothin more than a cheats charter with a few favour'd clubs being aided by the prem to step up to the prem each year...... nothin more nothing less

EGGSACTLY TROO FOBNT
 
I agree with most of what has been said, that the loan system is an absolute joke. But let's be honest we're just jealous hypocrites are we not?

Who would be complaining if we'd managed to get Bentdner & Lupoli for the season.

Not bloody many!

And whilst looking for good young players from the Prem, we have loaned out plenty of our own this season.

Purely for selfish reasons, I reckon a change in the rules is required as it's only the big clubs with nice grounds/ big crowds / wonderful facilities who seem to do well out of these deals. The B A S T A R D S !!!
 
Back
Top