Skip to main content

Premiership Players ???

Premiership Players ???

Lonergan and Nash are both quality 'keepers.
Mawene could, and both St. Ledger and Wilson have the potential to be good enough
Davidson could if he were less injury prone, however...
Whaley and Nugent both certainly have the potential.
Ormerod would be a useful squad player, but not a starter.
Paddy might be a decent bench option.
McKenna... I'm honestly not sure.
Stock- Technically good enough, but I'm not sure if he's good enough in other areas. Kinda like Jason Koumas a few years back.
Not sure about Nowland
Mellor is still an unknown.

I doubt any of the others could make the jump long-term.
 
Nash and Mawene are the only two who could hack it right now (If Youl was fit)

Nugent and Whaley will almost certainly be good enough in the future.

McKenna, Davidson, St. Ledger, Dichio, Mellor, Ormerod, Miller and Pugh would all probably be okay if we got promoted but they would have a lot to prove if they were to be considered genuine Premiership players.

Lonergan has been injured/not playing for so long I don't think any of us are in a position to comment on his ability or potential right now. Before his injury I would have put him in the Nuge/Whaley bracket but now...who know?

Nowland might be okay too but I have a feeling that it would have been a bridge too far even before his injury.

The rest, I feel, have no chance.

Alexander might be okay too, but certainly not as a full-back.
 
Both goalkeepers NOW, both central defenders in 2008/9 (still bit raw), no full backs (sorry Graham, speed is vital at that level), McKenna (probably enjoy more space at Premiership level) but only Pugh of the other midfielders could even make the squad, Nuge (on potential 7 flashes) Ormerod (on current form )- ie. 4 or 5 would make any other squad BUT as a collective, we are more skillful than Sheff Utd of a year ago, comparable with Watford and a long way short of Reading of last season, even if we can pass the ball and swarm in their style, but not for 75 mins per game.
Outcome- current squad plus left back plus bossy ball winner in front of defence, and we're up !!!!!
 
Very hard to judge. I thought Claude Davis would be a very good Premiership player but from what I've seen (albeit MoD highlights), he looks out of his depth. And yet there are players at Reading and Sheff Utd who are doing ok and yet looked nothing out of the ordinary in the Championship.
 
Lonergan and Nash are both quality 'keepers.
Mawene could, and both St. Ledger and Wilson have the potential to be good enough
Davidson could if he were less injury prone, however...
Whaley and Nugent both certainly have the potential.
Ormerod would be a useful squad player, but not a starter.
Paddy might be a decent bench option.
McKenna... I'm honestly not sure.
Stock- Technically good enough, but I'm not sure if he's good enough in other areas. Kinda like Jason Koumas a few years back.
Not sure about Nowland
Mellor is still an unknown.

I doubt any of the others could make the jump long-term.

WITH YOU 100% with the addition of CHILVERS.
 
True, but the likes of Stubbs or others at least have the positional play and experience to make up for it. Mr. Chilvers isn't quite good enough for that level in my opinion.
 
Fair enough- but who would have thought chris morgan would have gained alan hansen's approval (and not for being a hard barsteward)
 
Back
Top