Skip to main content

Promotion mentality

Promotion mentality

Yes I would definitely have kept him, one of my favourite players.

At the end of last season, with a front two of SB and Garner, we actually started scoring a few goals and spanking sides. (Carlise for 6 and Shrewsbury for 5 if memory serves?) Then in the play-offs, Grayson, in his wisdom, inexplicably dropped Beavon for Kevin"goals on legs"Davies, and the rest is history.

My opinion on Grayson went down a lot after that play-off debacle , and wasn't enhanced by his summer transfer dealings.

I would much rather see a ball into the feet of Beavon, who was more than capable of holding the ball up, and who very rarely gave the ball away, and maybe even a handful of goals, than 90 minutes of hoof up to "Super Massive Big Head" and no goals at all ever.

Clearly I must be mad as a box of frogs for having such a crazy opinion!?

Your opinion is just as good as anyone's
It's just that I beg do differ, but then I thought that Parkin was and is a dollop

Great opinions aren't they ?

As for Grayson - well I've pinned my colours to the mast, I'm a fan
He doesn't get it right all the time and is conservative in his decisions yet you have to look at where we are now in comparison to managers past.
We are a division three team at the moment and sadly we have a division three budget to match our league position so based on that I feel his purchases on the whole haven't been to bad. The likes of Davies I assure you would not offer the options that Grayson does.
Keep the faith my friend, we need the continuity of a manager for now and I see no better for the money than our current incumbent
 
Just my prediction, like I say because they are strong in the cups and play-offs can be likened to cup football.

I think their play-off record is almost as bad as ours, but I think they will triumph this time for reasons given above. Plus they will be strengthening their team, and let's not forget their remarkable second half of the season last season rising from the relegation zone to 7th I think? Our cautious, safety first approach and trying to grind out results will only take you so far, and has never been successful before in winning promotion.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think we've been in the top 2 spots all season, and nothing suggests to me, with the way we are playing, that we are suddenly going to get on a roll and start smashing teams and leapfrog the teams above us?

Be honest, do you think any of our strikers(not including the unavailable Garner, who SG has all but written off for the season) would get in any of the top 3's sides? I would think not, judging by the fact we are the lowest goalscorers in the top 4 by some margin. And it's the strength of your forwards that generally win the prizes.

If we actually manage to bring in some quality this TW, I might just change my opinion, but I don't think, on the whole, Grayson has been a great success in the transfer market, so I won't hold my breath. Also, it's ineveitable the top 3 will strengthen too.

Yesterday was Sheff United's first win since November in the league, I'm not too concerned about them. They were a poor side and whilst that doesn't say much for us yesterday, we know we can play better and that we can compete with all sides in this division as demonstrated by our league position.

Not sure whether we have been in the top 2, although we were 1st mid way through the Barnsley game I think. The point is, we are close to the top 2 and it is quite irrelevant where we have been/are in the league table. What matters is where we are in May and with only 3 points to make up, we have a VERY GOOD chance of hitting the automatic places. Who's to say we can't go on a run? You mention Sheff Utd last season, it can be any team.

The loss of Garner has been a huge blow. No question. But the expectation to pluck a forward from somewhere and expect them to start banging them in is unrealistic. Very few teams have more than 1 striker that can fire 20+ goals in a season for them, have we ever? I don't think many sides would be as successful if you took their leading scorer out, therefore we have done well to be so close to the best in the division.

Garner is the best striker in the division and his ability to create something from nothing allows us to provide him with average service yet still score goals. If someone can find a striker with his ability, within our budget to walk into our side and hit the ground running then feel free to contact the powers that be. Until then we have to play with 2 up top and do what we can. Our options are good and we have strikers with a wealth of experience at a higher level to this. Their and the teams lack of goals stems from the piss poor service to them (at least it was yesterday) meaning we struggle to create and put teams away. I don't think not scoring freely is necessarily a problem, defensively we are one of the best and this has won us many points. To quote Gary Neville; "clean sheets win titles". We can improve though, no doubt.

We need to loosen the shackles I think and allow our players to be more creative. Humphrey and Gallagher were marked out of the game yesterday meaning we often just looked to hit the front 2 with aimless punts. We lack creativity and drive in the middle which I believe restricts our ability to score. I think priority should be a top quality centre midfield player, with decent service to the forwards, we would score more. It's a big month, but if we get it right (and I back them to) we can get promoted.
 
Your opinion is just as good as anyone's
It's just that I beg do differ, but then I thought that Parkin was and is a dollop

Great opinions aren't they ?

As for Grayson - well I've pinned my colours to the mast, I'm a fan
He doesn't get it right all the time and is conservative in his decisions yet you have to look at where we are now in comparison to managers past.
We are a division three team at the moment and sadly we have a division three budget to match our league position so based on that I feel his purchases on the whole haven't been to bad. The likes of Davies I assure you would not offer the options that Grayson does.
Keep the faith my friend, we need the continuity of a manager for now and I see no better for the money than our current incumbent

I'm not advocating sacking Grayson, and I am not privvy to what his budget actually is, and who in the division has a higher budget. But he needs to up his game!

What I would say, seemingly for the 800th time is that his summer dealings could have been a lot better, and he went for quantity over quality, signing players we didn't need, and it is a ridiculous situation when we have about 10 players sat in the stand each matchday!

How can anyone think this is a good thing, when we are struggling to get rid of the deadwood to make way for players that would actually improve us!? This should have been done in the summer.

SMBH chose to come here over a clutch of Championship clubs, so I'd assume he's not on peanuts. In my eyes, and with the benefit of hindsight, that money could have been better spent. He doen't contribute to the "goals for" column, and when he plays we are very one-dimensional and we just hoof it up to him. I appreciate he is good at holding the ball up and he brings others into the game, but plenty of other players, within our budget, can do this also, and they might even score a goal once a blue moon!

Clubs with a much smaller budget, such as Oldham and Walsall, play a much more appealing brand of football, so I don't see this as an excuse, and I'd be looking to take their better players off their hands, not has-beens with big reputations and presumably wage packets.

Can I shock you? I actually like Mr Grayson, but that doesn't mean I have to agree with everything he does, and to me he's got plenty of the big decisions wrong and is starting to remind me, a hell of a lot, like the much-maligned all-round nice guy Alan Irvine.

I see him as the ultimate "safe pair of hands" and should we get lucky and actually get promoted, then I don't think we'd get relegated as he would grind out results, and we have never looked out of place against championship opposition. But it will never be exciting and get the stands packed to the rafters, and I would wager he probably has the words "Steady Eddie" tattooed on his arse.

PS What do you mean by "The likes of Davies I assure you would not offer the options that Grayson does."
Sorry, don't understand that comment.
 
SMBH?

What? Guessing it's something to do with SKD?

Please explain what this means Neal. Thanks.
 
R
I'm not advocating sacking Grayson, and I am not privvy to what his budget actually is, and who in the division has a higher budget. But he needs to up his game!

What I would say, seemingly for the 800th time is that his summer dealings could have been a lot better, and he went for quantity over quality, signing players we didn't need, and it is a ridiculous situation when we have about 10 players sat in the stand each matchday!

How can anyone think this is a good thing, when we are struggling to get rid of the deadwood to make way for players that would actually improve us!? This should have been done in the summer.

SMBH chose to come here over a clutch of Championship clubs, so I'd assume he's not on peanuts. In my eyes, and with the benefit of hindsight, that money could have been better spent. He doen't contribute to the "goals for" column, and when he plays we are very one-dimensional and we just hoof it up to him. I appreciate he is good at holding the ball up and he brings others into the game, but plenty of other players, within our budget, can do this also, and they might even score a goal once a blue moon!

Clubs with a much smaller budget, such as Oldham and Walsall, play a much more appealing brand of football, so I don't see this as an excuse, and I'd be looking to take their better players off their hands, not has-beens with big reputations and presumably wage packets.

Can I shock you? I actually like Mr Grayson, but that doesn't mean I have to agree with everything he does, and to me he's got plenty of the big decisions wrong and is starting to remind me, a hell of a lot, like the much-maligned all-round nice guy Alan Irvine.

I see him as the ultimate "safe pair of hands" and should we get lucky and actually get promoted, then I don't think we'd get relegated as he would grind out results, and we have never looked out of place against championship opposition. But it will never be exciting and get the stands packed to the rafters, and I would wager he probably has the words "Steady Eddie" tattooed on his arse.

PS What do you mean by "The likes of Davies I assure you would not offer the options that Grayson does."
Sorry, don't understand that comment.

I mean that given the same budget and resources I firmly believe that Grayson is a better manager than Davies
 
Super Massive Big Head, this is what I will be calling him from now on, until he scores, for future reference.

Thanks.

Danny Dichio was called "50p Head" (unrelated to 6pence) until he finally scored. 6pence is still waiting to score on the football field.

SKD will bang an important goal in this season. My bet v either Bristol or Swindon in April. Another 3 month wait then!
 
Danny Dichio was called "50p Head" (unrelated to 6pence) until he finally scored. 6pence is still waiting to score on the football field.

SKD will bang an important goal in this season. My bet v either Bristol or Swindon in April. Another 3 month wait then!

Which is not acceptable. Time for the landscape gardener/brickie or whatever he is! Long live the King!
 
Not playing Beavon for 3 months cost us promotion last season.

Selling him after he cost us a fortune was illogical.

Judging him on his goals alone, here or elsewhere is also shortsited.
 
Back
Top