Skip to main content

Robinson

Robinson

There isnt a PNE player that is more committed and puts in more effort than Callum. He chases everything and it stifles the opposition trying to play out and they end up going long to Wright and Clarke who win it almost all the time. My favourite player at the moment. I wish he could have been around when Finney was alive, he would have loved him.
 
Cal Robinson is an exciting player who is improving. I always have a massive issue with critics who magnify certain minor errors more than necessary. This is traditionally the domain of the fans who love a tryer and a workhorse for their muddy shorts and hoofing out of play determination, yet find the skilful player who is brave enough to try something creative, irritating.
The equivalent of going to the races and complaining because there are no donkeys on the race card.
As far as I'm concerned they all put in 100%. This is not why Robinson is exciting. He excites because he has skill, pace, an eye for goal and tactically targets the danger areas around the goal and penalty area.
 
Last edited:
Starting to think it could have been a lucky break that Adam Reach went elsewhere for all that money, Robinson could end up being worth as much if not more
 
Adam Reach at £5m or Robinson on a free? I'll admit that I was very sceptical signing him on a perm but he's been sensational this season. Looks to be settled now he's no longer a loanee.


Loved reach but not at 5 million. We basically got McGeady as a like for like and Aiden is the better player. What were Sheffield Wed thinking?
 
We don't miss Reach as much as I thought we would, Robinson has stepped up to the mark and McGeady looks very good.

There's no doubting that Reach is a quality young winger though who will eventually play in the Prem.
 
I don't think we miss Reach in the slightest, our midfield is far better this season from right to left.

Reach was good for his versatility, defensive qualities and ability to carry the ball but he offered little in terms of attacking threat.

I think Robinson offers much more of a threat down the left hand side than him, plus we have McGeady down the other side (when fit).
 
I don't think we miss Reach in the slightest, our midfield is far better this season from right to left.

Reach was good for his versatility, defensive qualities and ability to carry the ball but he offered little in terms of attacking threat.

I think Robinson offers much more of a threat down the left hand side than him, plus we have McGeady down the other side (when fit).

Agreed. He was a decent player but nothing else really and I was amazed that Sheff Wed paid £5m for him to then play him at LB for most of the season so far. Robinson certainly offers more goal threat as well, and has improved on his tracking back recently.
 
Good to see the lad progressing. Disagree with the OP about bulking up. Iniesta, Silva, Giggs, lots of players who are less than "bulky".
 
Agreed. He was a decent player but nothing else really and I was amazed that Sheff Wed paid £5m for him to then play him at LB for most of the season so far. Robinson certainly offers more goal threat as well, and has improved on his tracking back recently.

It was only because Daniel Pudil was injured and Urby Emanuelson was gaining fitness. He's been back on the left wing in recent games and even played up top on Wednesday. The Sheff Wed fans are impressed by all accounts. Yeah £5m is too much but aren't most players overpriced these days? That's the state of the market.

As I said I don't think we miss him, but I don't agree with this he wasn't that good etc. view now he's left. He was very good and definitely our biggest attacking threat whilst here, plus he's still only 23.
 
As I said I don't think we miss him, but I don't agree with this he wasn't that good etc. view now he's left. He was very good and definitely our biggest attacking threat whilst here, plus he's still only 23.

He wasn't that good though really, certainly wouldn't have him in the same bracket as the likes of Eddie Lewis and Ross Wallace when they played for us, nowhere near in fact.

Even Keith Treacy, before it went to pot for him was a much more productive player for us.

I'm confident that before the end of the season, Callum Robinson will have scored and set up a lot more than Reach managed.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
He wasn't that good though really, certainly wouldn't have him in the same bracket as the likes of Eddie Lewis and Ross Wallace when they played for us, nowhere near in fact.

Even Keith Treacy, before it when to pot for him was a much more productive player for us.

I'm confident that before the end of the season, Callum Robinson will have scored and set up a lot more than Reach managed.

If he wasn't that good, many of the tops teams in the division wouldn't have been chasing him.

And FWIW I'm very impressed with Robinson so far (he looks like the player we had in his first loan spell) and think he can reach double figures in goals this season.
 
If he wasn't that good, many of the tops teams in the division wouldn't have been chasing him.

And FWIW I'm very impressed with Robinson so far (he looks like the player we had in his first loan spell) and think he can reach double figures in goals this season.

If he was that good, Boro would have kept him.
 
Not really, we all know he's not Premiership standard. But in terms of the Championship I think he's excellent in multiple positions.

We'll disagree, I think he's good-to-middling in multiple positions and we've replaced him with ease.

As a left winger, he was pretty unproductive.

That's not to say I disliked him, he did a good job for us but I don't think he's a top end player.
 
He wasn't that good though really, certainly wouldn't have him in the same bracket as the likes of Eddie Lewis and Ross Wallace when they played for us, nowhere near in fact.

Even Keith Treacy, before it went to pot for him was a much more productive player for us.

I'm confident that before the end of the season, Callum Robinson will have scored and set up a lot more than Reach managed.

Exactly my thoughts. Wallace, Treacy and Lewis could win us a tight game from absolutely nothing, I never felt like Reach was going to do that. Good solid player but about 5 times over priced.
 
It was only because Daniel Pudil was injured and Urby Emanuelson was gaining fitness. He's been back on the left wing in recent games and even played up top on Wednesday. The Sheff Wed fans are impressed by all accounts. Yeah £5m is too much but aren't most players overpriced these days? That's the state of the market.

As I said I don't think we miss him, but I don't agree with this he wasn't that good etc. view now he's left. He was very good and definitely our biggest attacking threat whilst here, plus he's still only 23.

DJ was our biggest attacking threat. Why do people think when we say a player isn't that good it's only because he left. We are saying he wasn't that good because he actually wasn't that good. I have seen Mcgeady and robinson this season and both offered more then Reach did in his time here. I'm not saying i didn't like him - he did a job and had a few quality games like Leeds at home, wolves away, but he had no pace and we look so much better with robinson and mcgeady in the team.
 
There isnt a PNE player that is more committed and puts in more effort than Callum. He chases everything and it stifles the opposition trying to play out and they end up going long to Wright and Clarke who win it almost all the time. My favourite player at the moment. I wish he could have been around when Finney was alive, he would have loved him.

Agreed - one thing I noticed on Wednesday was that in the 82nd minuted robinson was still chasing a lost cause and still presurrising the defenders. His fitness levels must be extreme.
 
Back
Top