Skip to main content

Should we appeal?

Should we appeal?

Should we appeal?

If we win this appeal on the grounds of it not being a handball, then should it not of been a free kick either , then should we still be fined by the FA with 5 bookings etc also?
 
Last edited:
If we win this appeal on the grounds of it not being a handball, then should it not of been a free kick either , then should we still be fined by the FA with 5 bookings etc also?

It wouldn't have been a free kick because it isn't a foul. He won the ball. So we'll only be punished for the 4 bookings I presume.
 
It wouldn't have been a free kick because it isn't a foul. He won the ball. So we'll only be punished for the 4 bookings I presume.

5 Yellows

1 Red.

I don't think we can get fined for 5 Cards, only 6 Cards.

I stand to be corrected of course.
 
JVTegfV.jpg


Also clear from that picture is that Clarke and Hunts are both moving towards the goal while Wood has stopped so even though there's no "last man" rule there is clearly cover in place. Hope the appeal succeeds, even if it won't get us anything back from the Leeds game at least we'll not lose JP to a ban.

First of all, I see that Lairdinho has posted a video on the matchday thread, which he says shows more convincing footage (it won't on my laptop).

I hope so. Because whilst that still photo shows that there's doubt, but no way is it convincing enough to overturn the decision. If the boot was on the other foot, I'd be saying that I think some of the ball was in contact with is upper arm, and the keeper had spread his arms outside the area. (a bit like "umpire's call" - there may be doubt, but officials should be supported unless there is clear evidence it's wrong).

And as much as I'd like to, I can't see how you can say (with enough certainty to overrule the ref) that our defenders would have got back. For sure, they would not have caught up with the ball if it was on target... so a goal was prevented if that was the case.

I think our only hope is that there is some sufficiently high quality video available to show that it definitely his his shoulder.
 
Wish you could appeal yellows. Wasn't Gallagher booked for pulling someone back 10 minutes after he did it?

Thing is, if every team appealed every yellow they felt was contentious, the whole season would grind to a halt in a sea of administrative cases.
 
appeal won

Breaking: Goalkeeper Jordan Pickford's one-match suspension has been overturned with immediate effect. Full details: ow.ly/We0Bo
 
Little point in appealing IMO. Unclear for sure whether it was shoulder/arm. Authorities will not want to undermine ref.
Whether it deprived Leeds of a clear scoring opportunity might be deemed debatable - from my biased eye, we had defenders running back to cover, but an impartial observer might well disagree. There's not enough evidence to say categorically the ref got it wrong.
Think we should just accept that Pickford got it wrong. He has been superb this season but there was no need for him to be out of his area here. Once he made that rash decision, he was in trouble. He jumped up with his arms out. OK, say it did strike his face/shoulder, it would have been a complete fluke. Could just have easily been his arm. Every chance a ref will award against you.

I'll get my coat...
 
Back
Top