Skip to main content

Team Changes needed for Saturday?

Team Changes needed for Saturday?

If we play three at the back then that has to mean Clarke, Huntington and Wright with either Humphrey or Wiseman as right-sided wing-back and Laird in that role on the left. That would then inevitably mean Welsh and Johnson in central midfield, Gallagher in front of them and Garner plus one other upfront. How many times does it need to to be said that Garner is wasted as a lone striker.

If we play four at the back then that has to mean Wiseman at right-back and either Laird or Woods at left-back which in turn means that one out of Clarke, Huntington and Wright has to go to the bench however harsh that might seem. How many times does it need to be said Clarke is not a fullback. With Garner and one other upfront and Welsh and Johnson in central midfield then the wide positions are filled by any two of Gallagher, Robinson, Humphrey and Reid or just maybe Laird.

Those are the options and SG has to make decisions accordingly.
 
Ernest said:
How many times does it need to be said Clarke is not a fullback.
People keep saying this but to be honest he has probably played more games at full back in his career than at centre half. He also played many games in central midfield at Huddersfield.

Grayson probably likes having him at rightback as it means we can switch from 352 to 442 at will, with no substitutions needed. And it means we have an extra 6ft2 player when defending / attacking freekicks.

And lest we forget... Wiseman is an accident waiting to happen with his underhit backpasses and poor decision making.
 
Humphrey to be dropped as he has no end up product. go 4-4-2 to give garner a partner upfront.

Johnstone, Wiseman, Clarke, Huntington, Laird, Reid, Welsh, Johnson, Gallagher, Garner, Davies.

Beckford, SEB, Robinson, Killa, Wright, Stuckmann.
 
People keep saying this but to be honest he has probably played more games at full back in his career than at centre half. He also played many games in central midfield at Huddersfield.

Grayson probably likes having him at rightback as it means we can switch from 352 to 442 at will, with no substitutions needed. And it means we have an extra 6ft2 player when defending / attacking freekicks.

And lest we forget... Wiseman is an accident waiting to happen with his underhit backpasses and poor decision making.

Switching between a back four and a back three is just asking for trouble though, and overcomplicating things players who are committed to the cause but at the end of the day just League 1 players. Grayson's obsession with tinkering will cause more problems than it solves at this level.
 
Switching between a back four and a back three is just asking for trouble though, and overcomplicating things players who are committed to the cause but at the end of the day just League 1 players. Grayson's obsession with tinkering will cause more problems than it solves at this level.
Some would argue the 22 managers below us in the table should maybe tinker more often. People keep screaming for 442 but we have consistently played 451 for the majority of the season. I dont see that changing as it suits the midfielders at our disposal. Equally 352 suits us too. The one formation which our squad struggles with is 442 because it means gallagher is playing left wing - where he is wasted IMHO - and we get over run in midfield by teams adopting a five man midfield and are left punting balls up to SKD.
 
To be honest I would sign a right sided midfielder on loan asap. Not a winger. Just a decent footballer who can tuck in or offer us an outball on the flank. Someone who can actually trap and cross a ball would be nice on that side. I think having no competition for that position is a real weakness.

Yes - someone like Sedgwick or Ainsworth. As I've pointed out many times - and got a lot of flak for - that is a persistent lack. Humphrey tracks back and tries hard but he has no invention and can really only be dangerous as an attacker when the rest of the team is up for it and particularly when the central midfield can provide some momentum and creativity. He can be good in a good team. But when that isn't the case then he becomes a blunt instrument because he cannot compensate by providing any creativity of his own. We are still a quality midfielder short of where we want to be in terms of resources for the run-in and SG needs to recognise that fact and act on it.
 
Yes - someone like Sedgwick or Ainsworth. As I've pointed out many times - and got a lot of flak for - that is a persistent lack. Humphrey tracks back and tries hard but he has no invention and can really only be dangerous as an attacker when the rest of the team is up for it and particularly when the central midfield can provide some momentum and creativity. He can be good in a good team. But when that isn't the case then he becomes a blunt instrument because he cannot compensate by providing any creativity of his own. We are still a quality midfielder short of where we want to be in terms of resources for the run-in and SG needs to recognise that fact and act on it.


Your obsessed with Humphrey and its painful to read , saying he has no invention is utter crap he just has no consistency and needs to work on his end product . I hope for all our sakes he leaves in summer then we won't have to put up with your obsession every day saying the same things over and over and over and over
 
SG got it all wrong last night.

2 massive centre halves and one who had garner in his pocket at Walsall earlier in the season in Andy BUTLER.

last night was a game for Kevin DAVIES to start, Garner was never going to do anything against this lad and was lucky not to be sent off because his frustration just grew and grew.

Doncaster played the better football for sure but we were off 5straightw ins and the law of averages says we would drop a point here and there.

MK dons is now a massive game, they have their captain and left back out of the team and so we have to take advantage. Play REID on Saturday.

DAVIES and BECKFORD to start up front, lets do something different and make them change, we are like England cricket too predictable.

A win there and win the game in hand and it could be certain promotion.
 
Your obsessed with Humphrey and its painful to read , saying he has no invention is utter crap he just has no consistency and needs to work on his end product . I hope for all our sakes he leaves in summer then we won't have to put up with your obsession every day saying the same things over and over and over and over

No obsessed at all - though you seem to be with constantly refusing to recognise the obvious. We aren't particularly strong on the other flank either - the options being the slow but determined Laird, the tricky but lightweight Reid, the skillfull but arguably out-of-position Robinson. But at least we do have options there which we don't on the right. Ironically this Saturday looks like an ideal opportunity to use Humphrey as a 'wing-back' in that three-at-the-back formation - the one position in which in away games at least he has been a consistent success, a success I have always acknowledged.
 
Back
Top