Aside from the long ball debate, it seems that any goal-scoring opportunities are going to be thin on the ground for us in this division. Game playing decisions need to be spot on, such as Hugill's wrong decision to shoot when he could have laid one into the path of Johnson who was through.
This goal scoring issue.
I think Reach is more than capable of beating his man, but he needs support, in the 3 at the back formation he isn't allowed to show his true colours.
That's exactly the problem with wing backs they are shackled and the likes of Reach will be in two minds and by the sounds of our tactics defence will be P1. I am more than happy with this system away as I think it works quite well but home particularly playing sides within a couple of points of us we need to play with another system suited to being the home side. It's what we pay our gate money for is to actually see us regularly threatening and pressurising the away side.
I think Reach is more than capable of beating his man, but he needs support, in the 3 at the back formation he isn't allowed to show his true colours.
Totally agree. I think he is a good left winger / attacking option but it's tactically naive to play him as a wing back in a home game which we should be looking to win. He constantly picked up the ball in our half and the Bolton game was crying out for him to push on as a winger...
Totally agree. I think he is a good left winger / attacking option but it's tactically naive to play him as a wing back in a home game which we should be looking to win. He constantly picked up the ball in our half and the Bolton game was crying out for him to push on as a winger...
Can somebody please pass this Hymm sheet to SG and the coaching staff.
I've been saying exactly this for a few weeks now. Our forward play is predictable and easy to defend against. Any striker would struggle in our side. Our wing play is non-existent. Reach can cross the ball, but doesn't appear capable of beating the defender so rarely manages it. Vermijl regularly got into a crossing position but couldn't get a cross past the first defender. Therefor, our only balls into the box are lofted in by Gallagher, meaning the strikers have to jump, beat the defender, provide the power on the ball and direct it past the goalkeeper. If we could attack with more pace and get a decent cross in, or a through ball, we are giving the strikers much less to do.
Are you for real? REACH is great player i saw him play for Shrewsbury and Bradford against us and he was always a threat. He can cross a ball nearly as good as WALLACE did but if there is nobody anticipating or on the end of it then it looks like a waste.
We need to box clever and play to our strengths and that is on the deck, big centre halves cannot turn as quick big high balls are no good as I have seen that the quality of CH's in this league is much higher then Div 1 and you would expexct that. Just look at WILLIAMSON turns us down goes to Wolves big pressure cooker local derby and gets man of the match, says it all, we can't match the wage bill of some other clubs.
|I don't thinkwe are a million miles away from a home win but this is and was alwasy going to be a long hard slog of a season
- Joined
- Feb 13, 2005
- Messages
- 2,162
Are you for real? REACH is great player i saw him play for Shrewsbury and Bradford against us and he was always a threat. He can cross a ball nearly as good as WALLACE did but if there is nobody anticipating or on the end of it then it looks like a waste.
We need to box clever and play to our strengths and that is on the deck, big centre halves cannot turn as quick big high balls are no good as I have seen that the quality of CH's in this league is much higher then Div 1 and you would expexct that. Just look at WILLIAMSON turns us down goes to Wolves big pressure cooker local derby and gets man of the match, says it all, we can't match the wage bill of some other clubs.
|I don't thinkwe are a million miles away from a home win but this is and was alwasy going to be a long hard slog of a season
At Charlton it was Reach's mazy run through the middle that led to the free kick from which Gally gave us an early lead. In the second half at Brighton Reach went past their defenders with ease creating two great opportunities. Against Bolton, they had done their homework and doubled up on him so he rarely had the space to run at their defence.
This left space on our right which we weren't able to fully exploit in the absence of Humphrey we don't really have a wide right player. Gally drifted over there when we went 442 and I suspect we have to play someone out of position if we want to address that gap, especially in a 442. I guess the alternative might be 433 which pushes more men forward but still leaves us a specialist player short in that right hand position.
But you can only play with what you have, consolidating our strengths in being hard to beat and looking to be more creative in getting balls (and men) into the box when we are attacking. Whatever formation we play, players need to attack that final ball and crowd the defenders.
Thracia
Club Owner, or wingback, depending on your view
- Joined
- Aug 1, 2011
- Messages
- 30,692
Exactly.Aside from the long ball debate, it seems that any goal-scoring opportunities are going to be thin on the ground for us in this division. Game playing decisions need to be spot on, such as Hugill's wrong decision to shoot when he could have laid one into the path of Johnson who was through.
Much harder to create good chances in this league, so we need to make them count.
At the other end, mistakes are much more likely to be punished in this league by the better teams (that's most of them, compared to us), so we have to keep it tight back there too.
Gung-ho attacking tactics in this league, without the necessary quality of squad to pull it off, is not the answer. It's the hardest way to try to win a game, all-out attack, unless you're playing a much weaker team, which we won't be in this league.
Making the most of every chance when it comes along is a better answer. Still difficult though, as there will be very few good chances per match, and even the best players miss.
Are you for real? REACH is great player i saw him play for Shrewsbury and Bradford against us and he was always a threat. He can cross a ball nearly as good as WALLACE did but if there is nobody anticipating or on the end of it then it looks like a waste.
We need to box clever and play to our strengths and that is on the deck, big centre halves cannot turn as quick big high balls are no good as I have seen that the quality of CH's in this league is much higher then Div 1 and you would expexct that. Just look at WILLIAMSON turns us down goes to Wolves big pressure cooker local derby and gets man of the match, says it all, we can't match the wage bill of some other clubs.
|I don't thinkwe are a million miles away from a home win but this is and was alwasy going to be a long hard slog of a season
You are correct about Reach. What I meant, and as Ron and others have said more eloquently, not when he's asked to play as a wing back, or played on the wrong wing. The tactics have stifled our potential attacking threat as a whole.
Exactly.
Much harder to create good chances in this league, so we need to make them count.
At the other end, mistakes are much more likely to be punished in this league by the better teams (that's most of them, compared to us), so we have to keep it tight back there too.
Gung-ho attacking tactics in this league, without the necessary quality of squad to pull it off, is not the answer. It's the hardest way to try to win a game, all-out attack, unless you're playing a much weaker team, which we won't be in this league.
Making the most of every chance when it comes along is a better answer. Still difficult though, as there will be very few good chances per match, and even the best players miss.
Excellently put and the Graysons Negativity brigade need to start realising this.
- Joined
- Jun 28, 2004
- Messages
- 6,057
For fucks sake.
What was your excuse for the shite, defensive anti football we played in League One then, sitting back at home to the likes of Gillingham?
"Oh it's a tough league... blah blah..."
Get a grip. Whatever league Grayson is in, he'd play a negative, shite brand of football involving utility players and twatting it up to an ugly grafter.
Lots of teams passed us off the park last season with pathetic, comparative resources.
What was your excuse for the shite, defensive anti football we played in League One then, sitting back at home to the likes of Gillingham?
"Oh it's a tough league... blah blah..."
Get a grip. Whatever league Grayson is in, he'd play a negative, shite brand of football involving utility players and twatting it up to an ugly grafter.
Lots of teams passed us off the park last season with pathetic, comparative resources.
Exactly.
Much harder to create good chances in this league, so we need to make them count.
At the other end, mistakes are much more likely to be punished in this league by the better teams (that's most of them, compared to us), so we have to keep it tight back there too.
Gung-ho attacking tactics in this league, without the necessary quality of squad to pull it off, is not the answer. It's the hardest way to try to win a game, all-out attack, unless you're playing a much weaker team, which we won't be in this league.
Making the most of every chance when it comes along is a better answer. Still difficult though, as there will be very few good chances per match, and even the best players miss.
Not sure I've read anyone suggest we play gung-ho tactics. That would be ridiculous.
- Joined
- Aug 23, 2015
- Messages
- 4,634
Excellently put and the Graysons Negativity brigade need to start realising this.
Against the likes of Middlesbrough, Ipswich and Derby, then yes, the reserved and defensive approach is perfectly understandable - if we were to try and relentlessly attack those sides we'd get hammered.
However, against the likes Bolton, Cardiff, Wolves, Bristol City etc, who are the poorer sides in the division and there for the taking (Bolton were especially shit) the request for us as the home team to play on the front foot and exploit the opposition is not being overly demanding.
Thracia
Club Owner, or wingback, depending on your view
- Joined
- Aug 1, 2011
- Messages
- 30,692
I saw a couple of comments (maybe not on this thread) saying our wing backs should just bomb forwards with the ball and bugger their defensive duties because hey, "they can't attack us, we've got the ball" - it's that kind of attitude I'm talking about, the ones who make out its piss-easy this Championship football lark, all you need is grass, a ball and a Shankly cliche, etc.Not sure I've read anyone suggest we play gung-ho tactics. That would be ridiculous.
I saw a couple of comments (maybe not on this thread) saying our wing backs should just bomb forwards with the ball and bugger their defensive duties because hey, "they can't attack us, we've got the ball" - it's that kind of attitude I'm talking about, the ones who make out its piss-easy this Championship football lark, all you need is grass, a ball and a Shankly cliche, etc.
Fair enough. But we certainly can't nil-nil our way to safety either. There has to be a balance. At the moment it's fair to say this needs addressing.
I saw a couple of comments (maybe not on this thread) saying our wing backs should just bomb forwards with the ball and bugger their defensive duties because hey, "they can't attack us, we've got the ball" - it's that kind of attitude I'm talking about, the ones who make out its piss-easy this Championship football lark, all you need is grass, a ball and a Shankly cliche, etc.
I was one that suggested that fullbacks should go forward I'm not suggesting all the time, it's about balance. But when the likes of Reach and stood there with 2/3 in front of them with no real options in front of them the attack breaks down.
It's about balance, as a fullback goes forward the other wouldn't.. A CM would stay back etc.
sadly I agree with a lot of this! It's been the same ever since he arrived!!For fucks sake.
What was your excuse for the shite, defensive anti football we played in League One then, sitting back at home to the likes of Gillingham?
"Oh it's a tough league... blah blah..."
Get a grip. Whatever league Grayson is in, he'd play a negative, shite brand of football involving utility players and twatting it up to an ugly grafter.
Lots of teams passed us off the park last season with pathetic, comparative resources.
Fair enough. But we certainly can't nil-nil our way to safety either. There has to be a balance. At the moment it's fair to say this needs addressing.
I was trying to work this one out earlier on in the week and I think you're probably right. Though it's close.
- Joined
- Jul 1, 2004
- Messages
- 7,312
If you were there tonight you would have seen our forwards having to go out to the right wing because no one was there. It is an area that has needed addressing for a couple of seasons but we have failed to get anyone decent in. Infact I believe Grayson doesn't like wingplay at all and wants everything through the middle and the the long ball. The forwards must be sooo frustrated as nothing of any quality comes into the box.