Skip to main content

Three in attack?

  • Thread starter Thread starter dannypne7
  • Start date Start date

Three in attack?

D

dannypne7

Given that the next two home matches are pretty much do or die as far as our promotion aspirations are concerned, I would like Simpson to go for broke and try starting with three forwards against Plymouth.

I think that this would have the following effects:

1. Force us to play further up the pitch, the lack of which was the primary reason for the equaliser conceded against Coventry City. Alexander and Hill, with the lack of an out-and-out winger in front of them, would naturally push further up onto their men, nullifying their widemen, in areas which have proved our undoing several times this season.

2. Allow us to play Paul McKenna as an out-and-out defensive midfielder - the guy has no attacking capability whatsoever but can play keep ball - him playing slightly deeper would encourage him to play more forward balls. He can also tackle with tenacity in the right areas - this could be crucial if Plymouth play Akos Buzsaky just off their striker(s).

3. With Ormerod to his left and Nugent to his right, Dichio would be played to his strengths - his lay-offs have improved tenfold this season, yet this strength is not being exploited. Agyemang cannot do this, but as an alternative on the bench to Nugent/Ormerod would be useful.

4. Allow us to play both Danny Pugh and Simon Whaley in their most natural positions - neither of them are wingers, and their effectiveness is being seriously limited. Playing more infield, both can get more involved and link with the strikers more easily. You might wonder where crosses into the box for Dichio might be coming from, but these would more likely be provided by Nugent and Ormerod, both of whom could regularly pull out wide.

5. Prepare the team for the arrival of Mellor from the treatment table - he is obviously too good a player to be left out (as are Nugent (if he stays) and Ormerod). It would be a shame to waste these riches, and an eventual frontline of Mellor, Nugent and Ormerod sounds awesome.

So, the way I see it we ought to take the game to Plymouth, decreasing the likelihood of a useless draw and start in the following formation:

Nash

Alexander - Wilson - Chilvers - Hill

McKenna

Whaley - Pugh

Nugent - Dichio - Ormerod

Subs: Lonergan, St Ledger, Sedgwick, Miller, Agyemang.

For the record by the way, I think Keane has loaned us a pup in Miller, who won't be playing much part for us, and I would rest St Ledger, who looks jaded and is making mistakes, and give Wilson his chance.
 
Good post Danny. I absolutely agree that a three pronged attack is our best bet now. I suggested this last season with Dichio in the centre and got absolutely ripped for it, but mind you that was back when Danny wasn't as recognised as he is now.

Best thing about this formation though is that Sedge isn't in it. 🙂
 
Good post Danny. I absolutely agree that a three pronged attack is our best bet now. I suggested this last season with Dichio in the centre and got absolutely ripped for it, but mind you that was back when Danny wasn't as recognised as he is now.

Best thing about this formation though is that Sedge isn't in it. 🙂

Admittedly I couldn't get there today and as such can't comment on Sedgwick's effectiveness, but for the past few matches before that it was like playing with 10 men.
 
I think we need to get back to basics by starting from the back and get back to defending well.

The basis of any good team is a strong back 4.
 
I may be doing him a disservice, but I personally thought Alexander was uncharacteristically poor today, and that was why we lost. It also wasn't helped by Whaley being poor too - in fact, their first two goals were almost identical.
 
Why not play St Ledger at right back and play Alexander in place of Sedgwick in midfield . Alex gets done for speed to often at right back and the opposition soon see the weekness on that side to exploit .
Bring Wilson in St Ledgers place at centre back .Omerod up front with Nugent and Dichio on the bench. What do you think of that ???????
 
I'm not sure that making chances to our defense is what we need at the moment, especially since we now have Matt Hill back.

I think the problem is more that our defense doesn't get enough support from our midfield. This is what I felt after seeing the Palace, Coventry and Luton games live.

Furthermore, the philosophy of Simmo seems to be that "attack is the best defence". If the partnership of Ormerod and Nugent works as well as today's game would suggest, and we get the midfield sorted out, I think our defence will be fine, too.

But as Danny suggests, moving McKenna to a more defensive central-midfield role could well be the right way forward now.


PS. Does anybody else think that it is probably Simon Whaley who needs a rest more than anybody else of our starting line-up regulars? 😕 Whaley is very important to our game, but for a young player he's played a lot of football this season. With the heavy Xmas/ New Year fixture time approaching soon, the time to rest Whaley would be in one of the next two home games.
 
I think Whaley is looking pretty jaded too.

We suddenly look as though we could do with freshening up.

Brett could be a big player for us in the next month or so. He's raring to go. Great turn in th box y'day and a shot that would have flown in a yard either side of Taylor.
 
Back
Top