Skip to main content

Tonights referee.

Tonights referee.

Garner was right in front of me, he cheated, he knew he wasnt getting the ball and threw himself down. yellow card every day. end of.

He did have a superb game though
 
Can't believe what I'm reading. Yes, there's letting the game flow and not being a whistle-happy jobsworth prick, which would be refreshing, but the referee is tasked with keepng the game under control and I think he failed to do so.

What really pissed me off was how three of their players were allowed to receive treatment on the pitch, while we had yo play on with ten men when Wiseman went down/got sent to the touchline. No consistency.

EDIT: But yes, Garner did dive. He needs to pack it in, it's embarrassing.
 
The ref was excellent tonight. We have become so used to mediocrity that we now accept it as the norm. Far too may cards are brandished for fair challenges nowadays and it was so refreshing to have a ref ewho showed common sense.
What concerns me is the amount of divers we have in our team. Tonight we had Garner as usual plus C. Davies, Gallagher and Laird all guilty of cheating.
 
The ref wasn't the best was he?! He let the game flow, credit to him, but i lost count at how many things he missed. Ok, he wasn't card happy, but there was at least 3 possibly 4 occasions he should have booked players for late tackles.

Garner's dive was embarrassing. The less said the better me thinks!

The one incident that was unbelievable was when one of their players got injured on the touch line,rolled onto the pitch and the game was stopped! Fair enough the guy was subbed straight away, but if he had rolled the other way, when we had the ball, the game would have continued. Going into the second half and Wiseman was clearly struggling, the ref just continued with the game!
 
I thought that the lad who kept the ball in when we'd clearly tried to kick it out so that Wiseman could get treatment was a disgrace. If ever there was a case of ungentlemanly conduct that was it.
 
Ive a feeling that some might not agree with me here.

I thought he was excellent. One of the few Ive seen that allowed the game the game to be played and didnt make it about himself. Yes he made the odd mistake, but that was both ways, but no daft yellows, not stopping the game for petty fouls he just let the players slug it out. first class for me.

Tin Hat on 🙂

Totally agree. Initially I thought his yellow for Garner was outrageous, but after not having had another look at it yet, it seems from reading on here that the Ref was actually correct in dishing it out.

All in all I thought last nights Ref made a refreshing change.
 
Totally agree. Initially I thought his yellow for Garner was outrageous, but after not having had another look at it yet, it seems from reading on here that the Ref was actually correct in dishing it out.

All in all I thought last nights Ref made a refreshing change.

What annoys me is the difference between refs - another referee would have booked three of theirs in the first half. There is little consistency - I don't want robots but on Saturday we might come in with similar challenges and end up with three bookings. That cannot be right.

Incidentally, I do prefer it when they are less card happy and until I see the Garner incident again I still think he was very unlucky!
 
Totally agree with the OP. Made a refreshing change from a whistle every bloody minute!

I mostly agree. He was better than most we've seen - some odd decisions but none that had me spewing like I've found myself reacting to, but Mike Dean was probably the best we've had at Deepdale this season.
 
I agree that Garner tends to simulate but I don't agree he did when he got booked. I sit right in front of where it happened. I think he over stretched or went down with momentum or something but he led on the floor with his hands on his head afterwards frustrated that he missed. He didn't claim for a penalty and usually, he would. I suppose we need to see the video for proof.

I think the ref missed some key bookings and he made a couple of bad decisions both for and against us but overall last night the only things that went against us was seating deep for the last ten minutes.
 
Fatique in the legs deep into a game, or after a particularly long sprint. Straining sinews to get to a ball. Then there's the moment of realisation that you're not going to get it.

I guess that many of us know the feeling as your legs momentarily collapse - with disappointment/exhaustion.

All too often, the above scenario is misinterpreted as simulation.

And to be fair, sometimes it's genuinely difficult/impossible to tell the difference.
 
Back
Top