Skip to main content

Transfer Deadline Day Thread

Transfer Deadline Day Thread

People just won't come on if there is little or no ambition from the club and we're left with nothing to play for.

Do you not think there has been ambition shown? There's been significant investment in the team, indeed some use the wage bill last season as something to hit Grayson with seeing as we fluked promotion, and it has come a long way in a short space of time.

More to come of course as we try and establish ourselves in the Championship, but we've been asking for a while to see investment in young players with potential sell on value and that's what we've done, and with Johnstone tried to do in breaking our transfer record.
 
This "people won't come on" argument is totally bogus, it's like the "won't somebody think of the children?" argument people use when they are actually trying to get what they want for themselves right now, and balls to "the children".

Let the "people who won't come on" look after themselves and argue their own case on here - we don't need people on here pretending they speak on their behalf.

Crowds are most affected by the league we're in - being in the Championship rather than League One makes the biggest difference.

Crowds won't be affected significantly whether we finish 18th or 8th within the Championship - at least, not to the extent that a punt on some new player now will reap any guaranteed return, as I'm sure TH and PR have already calculated.
 
I was talking about this window. We've brought in two new players. Anders was a direct loan replacement for Sam, Reach was already here, Robinson was a replacement for Humphrey, Brownhill has gone out on loan to Barnsley. So in effect we've gained Pearson and Grimshaw who will not play for a few weeks. So the net result is +1.

Nothing we have done addresses the need for a centre forward. It's not as though we are even doing okay up front is it? It's a good job DJ is hitting the net or we would be in the doo doo. Garner is one booking away from a suspension and then it's a makeshift side again.
 
I was talking about this window. We've brought in two new players. Anders was a direct loan replacement for Sam, Reach was already here, Robinson was a replacement for Humphrey, Brownhill has gone out on loan to Barnsley. So in effect we've gained Pearson and Grimshaw who will not play for a few weeks. So the net result is +1.

Nothing we have done addresses the need for a centre forward. It's not as though we are even doing okay up front is it? It's a good job DJ is hitting the net or we would be in the doo doo. Garner is one booking away from a suspension and then it's a makeshift side again.

You act like goalscoring centre forwards are readily available and within our price range, SG and TH are not going to sign someone for silly money just to appease the baying mob.

Everyone is after the goal scorers in our league which puts us at a bit of a disadvantage of attracting the player to come here from the start.
 
How does buying a goalscorer equate to appeasing a baying mob? We look lightweight up front with very little pace.

As I've said before, Hugill and Doyle clearly not Championship players and therefore not good enough for PNE.
 
You act like goalscoring centre forwards are readily available and within our price range, SG and TH are not going to sign someone for silly money just to appease the baying mob.

Everyone is after the goal scorers in our league which puts us at a bit of a disadvantage of attracting the player to come here from the start.

Not aware of any baying mobs and I'm not sure we're at a disadvantage because everyone wants a goalscorer - if we have a disadvantage it's a financial one.

I'm not overly bothered that we haven't signed a forward but there are two concerns from my point of view. Hugill needs games, preferably at a lower level and he's probably not going to get them now and I'm also not looking forward to Cardiff if Garner ends up suspended for that game. The lack of Doyle means we'd have just Hugill chasing around - and no, I'm not saying we should have signed someone for that eventuality, it would just be an 'interesting' watch!
 
How does buying a goalscorer equate to appeasing a baying mob? We look lightweight up front with very little pace.

As I've said before, Hugill and Doyle clearly not Championship players and therefore not good enough for PNE.

Because people are calling out for us to sign a goalscorer and I completely agree we look lightweight with very little pace, but maybe the quality of signing we are looking for isn't readily available in January.

January is a funny transfer window usually for teams trying to push for promotion or desperately trying to avoid relegation, as it looks like we will be doing neither for the remainder of the season maybe SG, TH and PR's stance is lets save the money until summer and see how some of our potential targets develop in the coming months.

Patience seems the name of the game now at PNEFC and I think it has worked quite well for us.
 
Crowds are most affected by the league we're in - being in the Championship rather than League One makes the biggest difference.

Price is also a huge factor, and the increase last summer is a reason we hardly get bigger home attendances than we did last season.

I'm looking forward to seeing how the club get on when ambassadors are paying out an extra £100 for the same seat in a few months if the quality of football at Deepdale remains tepid at best.
 
There is the issue in that whilst we might only have 3 out and out strikers, plus Robinson, available, we still have to keep paying Beckford and May- there are limits to how much money we can throw away.
 
We have certainly improved our squad overall compared with the end of last last season.

In - Lindegaard, Cunningham, Vermijl, Grimshaw, Pearson, Kirkland, Robinson, Reach, May, Doyle, + Beckford and Gallagher who were on loan

Out - Stuckmann, Jones, James, Wiseman, Laird, King, Buchanan, Davies. K, Ebanks- Blake, Reid,
 
I do accept that the squad is better then last season but it had to be we are in a Division higher and desperately need to stay here.

I like SG and back him he is a good manager but this window with the striking options has been hugely disappointing.

I would have had a punt at Alex Revell at Cardiff who has signed for MK Dons.

we were probably in for Bradshaw but Walsall probably wanted silly money and I agree with the club don't spend silly money on an unproven striker. Well in the Championship.

Nick Powell - would have been good but we cannot compete with Hull City and the influence of mike Phelan.

So that leaves us with an option to seek a premiership youngster like Callum ROBINSON and I am sure Man City have loads at their place plus other big clubs.

I have nothing against Callum ROBINSON and he looked sharp last week but I would have preferred us signing someone else, an out and out goal scorer.

I hope this inactivity does not bite us on the bottom.
 
Not signing a striker was frustrating but not disastrous. Nothing would be more like this team now than to go out and get several goals tonight.
 
We can at least all celebrate the fact that Rod Fanni is finally getting a chance to play in England and could well be on show when Charlton come to Deepdale on Feb 23.
 
Back
Top