Skip to main content

We can cut it

We can cut it

With all due respect, name a handful of Championship defenders who are great distributors from the back as well as being defensively solid (not many premier league ones either). While I agree to some extent that he just seems to 'punt it' forward carelessly, I think BW does his main purpose (defending) extremely well - in my opinion better than Clarke & Huntington most of the time, as he has a bit more pace.
Some people get a bit too caught up in players weaknesses rather than their strengths, they focus on the negatives. I thought Bailey Wright was superb on Sunday & was a massive factor in keeping a decent side quiet!

Spot on mate.
 
With all due respect, name a handful of Championship defenders who are great distributors from the back as well as being defensively solid (not many premier league ones either). While I agree to some extent that he just seems to 'punt it' forward carelessly, I think BW does his main purpose (defending) extremely well - in my opinion better than Clarke & Huntington most of the time, as he has a bit more pace.
Some people get a bit too caught up in players weaknesses rather than their strengths, they focus on the negatives. I thought Bailey Wright was superb on Sunday & was a massive factor in keeping a decent side quiet!

I'm not sufficiently familiar with the Championship to name that many centre halves who can pass well, although Tarkowski at Brentford springs to mind. I think it's a fair bet though that there will be quite a few, certainly more than in League 1. I can't fault our 3 CHs defensively but the problem is, none of them are great distributors. You could get away with that in League 1 but at this level, I think you need at least one who can do a bit more than hoof it forward.
 
Not sure what the obsession is with having a ball playing CB. They're all capable of either giving it to a full back or a midfielder or if required going longer towards Garner. You won't see many Prem CB's playing 30 or 40 yard passes, they just give it to one of their midfielders.

We've had enough CB's in recent years thinking they're better than they are and getting us in trouble, SSL in his 2nd spell and Craig Morgan are ones that stand out. I'm quite happy to see Huntington clear the ball properly rather than trying to be clever with it.
 
Not sure what the obsession is with having a ball playing CB. They're all capable of either giving it to a full back or a midfielder or if required going longer towards Garner. You won't see many Prem CB's playing 30 or 40 yard passes, they just give it to one of their midfielders.

We've had enough CB's in recent years thinking they're better than they are and getting us in trouble, SSL in his 2nd spell and Craig Morgan are ones that stand out. I'm quite happy to see Huntington clear the ball properly rather than trying to be clever with it.

Think its complaining for complaining sake Tino.
 
But you said: "99% of his forward passes all game were chips to nobody and lost us the ball. I physically counted each time he lost us the ball, so this is fact, not opinion".

Did you physically count them but forget to write the number down or something?

Exactly right! haha
 
With all due respect, name a handful of Championship defenders who are great distributors from the back as well as being defensively solid (not many premier league ones either). While I agree to some extent that he just seems to 'punt it' forward carelessly, I think BW does his main purpose (defending) extremely well - in my opinion better than Clarke & Huntington most of the time, as he has a bit more pace.
Some people get a bit too caught up in players weaknesses rather than their strengths, they focus on the negatives. I thought Bailey Wright was superb on Sunday & was a massive factor in keeping a decent side quiet!

Yeah, he's not a bad defender. I'm not sure he has that much pace, but I get where you're coming from there.

But surely the manager could get them to do some specific training on their distribution no? Clarke is similar in that degree.. I just think if you're a professional footballer you should be able to pass the ball to one of your team mates. Frustrates me so much when we needlessly give away possession. A general punt up midfield isn't good enough. And I think like some say, in the Championship you expect a bit better and ultimately it piles pressure back on us if we lose the ball so readily.

I'd either train them specifically on distribution, or limit them to short passes.

I also agree that we don't see many ball playing centre backs, but don't you think we should? I'm not sure if not seeing many is a great excuse to be bad at "playing football" in the passing sense..
 
Yeah, he's not a bad defender. I'm not sure he has that much pace, but I get where you're coming from there.

But surely the manager could get them to do some specific training on their distribution no? Clarke is similar in that degree.. I just think if you're a professional footballer you should be able to pass the ball to one of your team mates. Frustrates me so much when we needlessly give away possession. A general punt up midfield isn't good enough. And I think like some say, in the Championship you expect a bit better and ultimately it piles pressure back on us if we lose the ball so readily.

I'd either train them specifically on distribution, or limit them to short passes.

I also agree that we don't see many ball playing centre backs, but don't you think we should? I'm not sure if not seeing many is a great excuse to be bad at "playing football" in the passing sense..

Its all about clearing your lines to avoid the press, with the formation we played on Sunday the options in midfield were limited so sometimes the punt upfield was necessary and it can be well utilised when you have a player like Garner upfront.

Middlesborough were very quick to close our back 3 down when they had the ball, something Karanka must have seen as one of our weaknesses, thats why you wouldn't have seen the back 3 spraying it around like Pirlo.
 
Back
Top