Skip to main content

2014 - 2015 Scapegoat?

2014 - 2015 Scapegoat?

Joined
Jan 21, 2014
Messages
595
Location
Euxton
If Humphrey is to leave which player will become this seasons scapegoat? 😕 I see a few have already started turning on Wiseman, is he the one?

Not sure I recall a season where one player hasnt been singled out (often unfairly may I add!!) Rankine, Sedgwick, Alexander all received the treatment at some stage. I wouldnt mind all 3 of them in their prime playing for us now!!
 
If Humphrey is to leave which player will become this seasons scapegoat? 😕 I see a few have already started turning on Wiseman, is he the one?

Not sure I recall a season where one player hasnt been singled out (often unfairly may I add!!) Rankine, Sedgwick, Alexander all received the treatment at some stage. I wouldnt mind all 3 of them in their prime playing for us now!!

Ask Billymac
 
Sedgwick even in his prime was one of the worse signings I have seen at deepdale. He was only good enough to collect track suit tops at best or carry water bottles.
Wiseman cost us goals last season the most important being at Rotherham with a needless foul that led to their equaliser and gave them the momentum to go on and win the game. For me he should have been moved on.
 
1. Grayson
2. Ridsdale
3. Hemmings
4. Kevin Davies

my sweepstake selections
 
Sedgwick even in his prime was one of the worse signings I have seen at deepdale. He was only good enough to collect track suit tops at best or carry water bottles.
Wiseman cost us goals last season the most important being at Rotherham with a needless foul that led to their equaliser and gave them the momentum to go on and win the game. For me he should have been moved on.

WOW. You seem to hold a grudge against Wiseman and believe that it was his fault that we couldn't beat Rotherham over 2 legs. Do you honestly believe that? You do know he didn't play at all in the first leg at home, where we were also completely out-played. What about the disgraceful performance by all the other players, both in the home leg and the away leg? We had more than 180 minutes to beat them and used 19 different players!

If you're going to criticize Wiseman then you should also criticize the manager (more so really) for playing him when he was clearly not match fit. But I suggest you just let it go and the same goes for anyone else who's holding a grudge against Wiseman for the same reasons.
 
Last edited:
Wiseman cost us goals last season the most important being at Rotherham with a needless foul that led to their equaliser and gave them the momentum to go on and win the game. For me he should have been moved on.

Come off it, the main culprits for that goal were the CB's who gave Thomas a free run (was it fans favourite and Premier League bound Wright or Jack 'Beckenbauer' King?) or indeed Rudd who had jelly hands and not someone who gave away a free kick (and it was barely that) 40 yards from goal on the left hand side.

In answer to the OP though it will Jones, with the usual odd one thrown in at Ridsdale, Hemmings and Kevin Davies.
 
Sedgwick even in his prime was one of the worse signings I have seen at deepdale. He was only good enough to collect track suit tops at best or carry water bottles.

Missed this bit the first time, one of the reasons that Alexander was the best RB we've had in the last 30 years was because he had Sedgwick in front of him.
 
It's often the ones that come through the ranks, so, if not Jamie Proctor or Danny Mayor, probably Bailey Wright, who will undoubtedly, according to our village idiots, suddenly become 'too big for his boots'
 
I think the new goal keeper has a hard act to follow. Humphrey started getting more positive Fanbase towards the end of the season. Think it helps that he comes across as a decent guy and tries hard.
I'm not keen on how Beavon seems to be the player to pick on.
 
2014 - 2015 Scapegoat?

Definately the Keeper.


And as for Sedgewick in his prime..... I'd have him back like a shot.
 
How small minded to single 1 player out even when others are doing no better but you persist anyway , I'm with you Libs for what its worth , if he starts a bit rocky hes finished . Such is the mentality of the football fan
 
2014 - 2015 Scapegoat?

Definately the Keeper.


And as for Sedgewick in his prime..... I'd have him back like a shot.
+1

Unfortunately our fans won't give Jones a second chance.

Sedgwick was a stalwart of some of our best teams. It's difficult to make that many appearances for the Club if you're as crap as some would have you believe.
 
“It's too easy to criticize a man when he's out of favour, and to make him shoulder the blame for everybody else's mistakes.” ― Leo Tolstoy

Sums up my thoughts on looking for scapegoats perfectly.
 
Sedgwick even in his prime was one of the worse signings I have seen at deepdale. He was only good enough to collect track suit tops at best or carry water bottles.
Wiseman cost us goals last season the most important being at Rotherham with a needless foul that led to their equaliser and gave them the momentum to go on and win the game. For me he should have been moved on.

I gave up reading this tosh when you described Sedgwick as one of the worst players you've ever seen at Deepdale. Clearly you can't have been watching that long as I could name dozens worse than him. IMHO Sedgwick was an integral part of the good seasons in the championship.
 
Back
Top