Skip to main content

3-5-2 return?

3-5-2 return?

Joined
Nov 9, 2010
Messages
8,286
Location
York
We've seen the 3-5-2 return recently when we have been struggling. And now we have two quality strikers who are both sure to start.

I'm thinking we will revert to last years' system with Humph and Laird doing the wing back thing.

What do we reckon? Anybody care?
 
We've seen the 3-5-2 return recently when we have been struggling. And now we have two quality strikers who are both sure to start.

I'm thinking we will revert to last years' system with Humph and Laird doing the wing back thing.

What do we reckon? Anybody care?

Our defence was solid using this formation prior to the January transfer window.

I'd be happy to see us revert back to it on Saturday.
 
We've seen the 3-5-2 return recently when we have been struggling. And now we have two quality strikers who are both sure to start.

I'm thinking we will revert to last years' system with Humph and Laird doing the wing back thing.

What do we reckon? Anybody care?

Quite likely for Saturday as I think Bristol City play that way.
 
Yes I think so.
Bristol are wary overall of our new strike force.
I see Thor hasn't infiltrated their site (yet)
 
I think we'll play it Saturday, think it'd be good if we play Wiseman, Huntington and Clarke as after Saturday I wouldn't trust King and Huntington playing together, King especially looked out of his depth.
 
Think we should have five in midfield, as when we have lost games it stems from our midfield being over run. You can see it coming a mile away and just know the other team will score soon. So yes pack the midfield and make it defensive, but who should play there? Well what SG gets paid to get right.
 
The 3-5-2 system requires three centrebacks and at the moment we are pretty short in that department. I have doubts on whether Wiseman is good enough to play as a centre half (even in that formation), whereas as an attack-minded righ back he should do fine as a right wing-back.
 
The 3-5-2 system requires three centrebacks and at the moment we are pretty short in that department. I have doubts on whether Wiseman is good enough to play as a centre half (even in that formation), whereas as an attack-minded righ back he should do fine as a right wing-back.

Wiseman is probably a better right-sided wing-back than is Buchanan on the left though has he ever looked really effective there as opposed to at right-back? I am not certain he has. The problem with the wing-back system is that though we have two players who can perform the defensive side of that role adequately - Humphrey and Laird - we don't have players who can really combine both the attacking and defensive side of things. Humphrey, as I've explained before, is too far back and Laird too far forward but they are probably the best we have got - though Browne and Hayhurst might also bring some youth and energy to the role.
 
Wiseman is probably a better right-sided wing-back than is Buchanan on the left though has he ever looked really effective there as opposed to at right-back? I am not certain he has. The problem with the wing-back system is that though we have two players who can perform the defensive side of that role adequately - Humphrey and Laird - we don't have players who can really combine both the attacking and defensive side of things. Humphrey, as I've explained before, is too far back and Laird too far forward but they are probably the best we have got - though Browne and Hayhurst might also bring some youth and energy to the role.

Good points. At the end of the day, I think very very few footballers are so good at wing-backs, it is such a challenging position to play at. Gareth Bale can play there, but he is a monster, one of the best footballers in the world.

To me, one of the "best prototype wing-backs" was John Arne Riise for Liverpool in the late 90's. He was always a bit of a defensive liability, but with all that strength and energy was a real force on that left flank. The 3-5-2 system that Liverpool used during those years suited Riise very well, even though he was good at 4-4-2, too.

If PNE play some sort of 3-5-2 tomorrow, I think it will be a stop-gap game plan to nullify Bristol City, not a long term solution. We don't have abundance of quality centre halves, which 3-5-2 requires, and we don't have designated wing-backs either, as ernest very well pointed out.

Instead, compared to last season, we now have both more quality and quantity on the wings (Humphrey, Reid, also Robinson, Gallagher to certain degree, Hayhurst, Holmes, Little), i.e. either proper wingers for 4-4-2 or its variations, and strikers who can play on the wing in 4-3-3.
 
I'd go with this. I'd play Laird and Humphrey out wide, with Huntington the central defender with Wiseman and Clarke alongside him. Browne and Kilkenny in the centre with Gallagher given license to play a free role behind Garner and Beckford.

Brownhill can cover for Gallagher in that role, with Reid and Buchanan cover for the wing backs (not sure if Reid can play that role?)

Robinson cover for the front 2.
 
It's a reasonable shout but losing 3 games in a row shouldn't be a reason to go all defensive IMO; we still need to be looking to win games. I'd rather we played a standard 4-4-2. I'd like to see Garner & Robinson upfront. Beckford could be a useful sub to bring on but I'm not sure he deserves to walk straight into the side.
 
It's a reasonable shout but losing 3 games in a row shouldn't be a reason to go all defensive IMO; we still need to be looking to win games. I'd rather we played a standard 4-4-2. I'd like to see Garner & Robinson upfront. Beckford could be a useful sub to bring on but I'm not sure he deserves to walk straight into the side.

I agree. Robinson upfront with Garner and Beckford on the bench.
 
Reid and Buchanan cover for the wing backs (not sure if Reid can play that role?)QUOTE]

I doubt if he can on either flank - frankly I suspect he would be a disaster in that role. Both Humphrey and Laird are compromises as wing-backs in any case but the best deputies for them might well be Browne and Hayhurst.
 
Reid and Buchanan cover for the wing backs (not sure if Reid can play that role?)QUOTE]

I doubt if he can on either flank - frankly I suspect he would be a disaster in that role. Both Humphrey and Laird are compromises as wing-backs in any case but the best deputies for them might well be Browne and Hayhurst.

Ernest you seem to keep banging on about Hayhurst and everyone has their favourites but in my opinion he has done nothing to warrant even making the bench. I feel another loan move might do him a power of good.
 
Ernest you seem to keep banging on about Hayhurst and everyone has their favourites but in my opinion he has done nothing to warrant even making the bench. I feel another loan move might do him a power of good.

Hi Pilchard - I did say 'might'. But more to the point, as I have also said, a reversion to the 'wing-back' system at least for away games might be a good ploy despite the fact that we don't actually have any real wing-backs. Where are you Chris Sedgwick now that we really need you....
 
Last edited:
Back
Top