Skip to main content

4-4-2

4-4-2

Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
17,366
Location
The desert
After today's performance it's apparent Hume isn't an attacking midfielder, Byrom and Keane don't create enough and unless we attack the 2nd ball after Davies has won his header teams will find us predictable.

Laird and Humphrey didn't attack enough and in the end we didn't deserve to lose today but didn't create enough to win it. A couple of early chances and bit of pressure late on.

I feel surrendering our 'fortress Deepdale' easily on Tuesday didn't help as now clubs come here, regardless of the team we had out, and feel they can win.

I'd go back to 4-4-2

GK. Rudd
RB. Keane
CB. Wright
CB. Clarke
LB. Laird
RW. Humphrey
CM. Welsh
CM. Brownhill
LW. Holmes
ST. Davies
ST. Beavon

The lad Brownhill looks comfortable on the ball and Byrom and Wroe haven't done enough to maintain their starts. I'd like to see King in the centre mid alongside Welsh.

Don't overly rate Humphrey but like having wingers on their correct wings rather than push the middle men out there.


Onwards and upwards but we all know once you start on a run of defeats its hard to get out of it. We should have nipped the defeat at Peterborough in the bud on Tuesday.

Ref was shit and horrendous Crewe gamesmanship.
 
Last edited:
After today's performance it's apparent Hume isn't an attacking midfielder, Byrom and Keane don't create enough and unless we attack the 2nd ball after Davies has won his header teams will find us predictable.

Laird and Humphrey didn't attack enough and in the end we didn't deserve to lose today but didn't create enough to win it. A couple of early chances and bit of pressure late on.

I feel surrendering our 'fortress Deepdale' easily on Tuesday didn't help as now clubs come here, regardless of the team we had out, and feel they can win.

I'd go back to 4-4-2

GK. Rudd
RB. Keane
CB. Wright
CB. Clarke
LB. Laird
RW. Humphrey
CM. Welsh
CM. Brownhill
LW. Holmes
ST. Davies
ST. Beavon

The lad Brownhill looks comfortable on the ball and Byrom and Wroe haven't done enough to maintain their starts


Onwards and upwards but we all know once you start on a run of defeats its hard to get out of it. We should have nipped the defeat at Peterborough in the bud on Tuesday.

Swap Keane for Welsh and put Nicholson at right back. That's the eleven that I would like to see. Brownhill is unproven but we may as well give him a go from the start of a game he's been no worse than any of our other options, in his brief appearances so far.
 
After today's performance it's apparent Hume isn't an attacking midfielder, Byrom and Keane don't create enough and unless we attack the 2nd ball after Davies has won his header teams will find us predictable.

Laird and Humphrey didn't attack enough and in the end we didn't deserve to lose today but didn't create enough to win it. A couple of early chances and bit of pressure late on.

I feel surrendering our 'fortress Deepdale' easily on Tuesday didn't help as now clubs come here, regardless of the team we had out, and feel they can win.

I'd go back to 4-4-2

GK. Rudd
RB. Keane
CB. Wright
CB. Clarke
LB. Laird
RW. Humphrey
CM. Welsh
CM. Brownhill
LW. Holmes
ST. Davies
ST. Beavon

The lad Brownhill looks comfortable on the ball and Byrom and Wroe haven't done enough to maintain their starts


Onwards and upwards but we all know once you start on a run of defeats its hard to get out of it. We should have nipped the defeat at Peterborough in the bud on Tuesday.

I suspect 3-5-2 may have run its course for now. It would appear teams have sussed us out. One of those days today but if we going to doing anything some of the 'names' in the team need to pull their fingers out. Hume at the moment is doing nothing to justify us keeping him on and I've been disappointed with him all season. Holmes is wasting his ability, whatever's up with him he needs to sort his head out. There are others but these two are the main ones for me and funnily enough they should be our most creative players and we are creating nowt.

No real damage done, Crewe have become an official bogey team. Well done to them as well for bringing a massive 300 the short journey up the motorway.
 
4-4-2

Swap Keane for Welsh and put Nicholson at right back. That's the eleven that I would like to see. Brownhill is unproven but we may as well give him a go from the start of a game he's been no worse than any of our other options, in his brief appearances so far.

It would be a bold move playing Brownhill but we need some new lads in there. Hope King can fill that role. Nicholson didn't look great Tuesday and Keane is a headless chicken and is good in the tackle but all we did today was go sideways. He was taken off and I think Welsh is better.
 
Last edited:
After today's performance it's apparent Hume isn't an attacking midfielder, QUOTE]

It's been apparent for a while. Whether young Brownhill is upto starting I don't know. But with two attacking fullbacks in Nicholson and Laird and two proper wide players with a bit of creativity in Holmes and Hayhurst I think we could in the short term revert to the Keane-Welsh partnership in central midfield. Yes it does lack creativity but Holmes can provide some of that if he moves in from the flank. King with either Welsh or Keane might also provide a bit of composure, but that core central midfield area of the team is where we need to strengthen. The right signing there could make or break the season.
 
I think we play 3-5-2 as a result of the players we have at the club. We are unbalanced really and lack specialist players in certain positions e.g. Right Back so we adopt by playing a winger at wing back. We have a great forward line so try and include them all in the same side to make up for our lack of creativity in the middle of the park.

Grayson and his team have a little bit of work to do to find a system that will benefit us in the long run, I think the 3-5-2 took a few teams by surprise but we have been exposed in our last 3 fixtures and perhaps this week is the right time to address it.

I haven't seen Brownhill but heard he has shown some decent touches when given the chance, I agree it would be a bold move to play him but we are currently lacking something in that midfield area which is ironic when you consider the number of players we have in that area.
 
Rudd
Clarke Huntington Wright Laird
Humphrey Brownhill Keane Holmes
Beavon/Hume Davies

Byrom hasn't done anything since the first few games so I have no idea how he is still being picked. May as well give the young lad a chance in the middle of midfield and have some width on each flank. Today was dying out for 4-4-2 especially 2nd half. And when Humphrey was replaced with Holmes I couldn't believe it, should have kept Humphrey on and took Hume off for Holmes. Width on each side of the pitch and would give us more balance.
 
Rudd
Clarke Huntington Wright Laird
Humphrey Brownhill Keane Holmes
Beavon/Hume Davies

Byrom hasn't done anything since the first few games so I have no idea how he is still being picked. May as well give the young lad a chance in the middle of midfield and have some width on each flank. Today was dying out for 4-4-2 especially 2nd half. And when Humphrey was replaced with Holmes I couldn't believe it, should have kept Humphrey on and took Hume off for Holmes. Width on each side of the pitch and would give us more balance.

Agreed I'm sick of playing Holmes on the right
 
Rudd
Keane, Clarke, Wright, Buchanan
Beavon, Welsh, Wroe, Holmes
Davies, Hume​

Stuckmann, Humphrey, Huntington, Laird, Brownhill/King (when fit), Hayhurst, Garner
 
Keane has "done a job" for us in midfield and he is neat, but he is neither strong or skilful enough to be our main man.
Byrom can look neat on the ball, but he continues to disappear, a luxury.
Hume is a work horse but not a midfielder.
Brownhill is a good prospect, but it would be wrong for his career to put too much responsibility on him right now.
King is not mobile enough for the middle of a 4-4-2.
Laird is much more comfortable in 4-4-2 than in 3-5-2.
So we have some big decisions to take.
The best wing half we have is Welsh, ok his form has been poor, but he deserves a run after his last season's form, and maybe if Keane is winning the ball, Welsh can have permission to thrust forward.
I would go with;
Rudd;
Clarke, Huntington, Wright, Laird;
Humphrey, Keane, Welsh, Holmes;
Beavon, Davies
Then Brownhill, Hume and Garner have got to be ready for 30 minutes of hard labour if Beavon and Davies are failing or if Keane is needed at right back.
 
Rudd
Keane Clarke Wright Laird
Humphrey Welsh Wroe Holmes
Beavon Davies

You can debate Laird / Buchanan.
As a team it has some drive and skill going forward but importantly, in the middle of the pitch, it can keep the ball.
 
Keane has "done a job" for us in midfield and he is neat, but he is neither strong or skilful enough to be our main man.
Byrom can look neat on the ball, but he continues to disappear, a luxury.
Hume is a work horse but not a midfielder.
Brownhill is a good prospect, but it would be wrong for his career to put too much responsibility on him right now.
King is not mobile enough for the middle of a 4-4-2. Laird is much more comfortable in 4-4-2 than in 3-5-2.
So we have some big decisions to take.
The best wing half we have is Welsh, ok his form has been poor, but he deserves a run after his last season's form, and maybe if Keane is winning the ball, Welsh can have permission to thrust forward.
I would go with;
Rudd;
Clarke, Huntington, Wright, Laird;
Humphrey, Keane, Welsh, Holmes;
Beavon, Davies
Then Brownhill, Hume and Garner have got to be ready for 30 minutes of hard labour if Beavon and Davies are failing or if Keane is needed at right back.

Agree with most of that but I think King could do a job there. Lack of mobility didn't do Gregan any harm.

Personally, I don't rate Humphrey. He works hard and tracks back but his technical ability is very limited and this stands out when he's going forward. He can't dribble, he just seems to put his head down and run for the corner flag and when he does get crosses in they are often poor. In terms of skill, he is nowhere near Monakana, who, whilst inconsistent and frustrating, is one of the few players we have who always 'has a moment in him'. He should at the very least be on the bench as an option, as should Hayhurst, when available.
 
Last edited:
Totally agree that 352 is pap. Liverpool are totally riding their luck on it.

However, lets not dwell on our midfield - Grayson's style of football often bypasses it.
 
Back
Top