Over recent weeks on here there have been several posts bemoaning Grayson's preferred 4-5-1 formation with only one recognised striker. There have been references to this being a negative formation and showing a lack of ambition with a clamour to play two upfront. Last week we battered Norwich playing with a 4-5-1 formation which makes the team create opportunities. In the two games since we have played a traditional 4-4-2 and have been woeful - this formation merely makes the players hope for opportunities. It is a lazy formation where players simply resort to humping the ball forward hoping for a knockdown. Can we please revert to the more positive and effective 4-5-1 immediately and let's hear no more from the Mike Bassett fraternity.
4-4-2
Over recent weeks on here there have been several posts bemoaning Grayson's preferred 4-5-1 formation with only one recognised striker. There have been references to this being a negative formation and showing a lack of ambition with a clamour to play two upfront. Last week we battered Norwich playing with a 4-5-1 formation which makes the team create opportunities. In the two games since we have played a traditional 4-4-2 and have been woeful - this formation merely makes the players hope for opportunities. It is a lazy formation where players simply resort to humping the ball forward hoping for a knockdown. Can we please revert to the more positive and effective 4-5-1 immediately and let's hear no more from the Mike Bassett fraternity.
4-4-2 is easy for teams to set up against, when they come to Deepdale and pack the midfield like Walsall and Norwich did then we have to resort to the long ball.
4-4-2 has its uses but I wouldn't go with it from the start.
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2004
- Messages
- 13,345
Over recent weeks on here there have been several posts bemoaning Grayson's preferred 4-5-1 formation with only one recognised striker. There have been references to this being a negative formation and showing a lack of ambition with a clamour to play two upfront. Last week we battered Norwich playing with a 4-5-1 formation which makes the team create opportunities. In the two games since we have played a traditional 4-4-2 and have been woeful - this formation merely makes the players hope for opportunities. It is a lazy formation where players simply resort to humping the ball forward hoping for a knockdown. Can we please revert to the more positive and effective 4-5-1 immediately and let's hear no more from the Mike Bassett fraternity.
Agreed. Let's not see Kevin Davies in a starting eleven again please.
- Joined
- Aug 6, 2008
- Messages
- 7,051
Over recent weeks on here there have been several posts bemoaning Grayson's preferred 4-5-1 formation with only one recognised striker. There have been references to this being a negative formation and showing a lack of ambition with a clamour to play two upfront. Last week we battered Norwich playing with a 4-5-1 formation which makes the team create opportunities. In the two games since we have played a traditional 4-4-2 and have been woeful - this formation merely makes the players hope for opportunities. It is a lazy formation where players simply resort to humping the ball forward hoping for a knockdown. Can we please revert to the more positive and effective 4-5-1 immediately and let's hear no more from the Mike Bassett fraternity.
Only Davis can play the loan striker and he can't play more than one game a week with any effect. The reason why we play better with five in midfield is because we are so weak in that department. Catch 22
We don't have a striker who can play as the one up top. Ebanks Blake can hold the ball up but if he starts as one up top he'd last 20 minutes
- Joined
- Mar 25, 2006
- Messages
- 5,724
4-5-1 is what we usually play and Beckford is useless in this..... a 4-4-1-1 may work with Beckford playing off of Davies.
How would we tell the difference between a 442 and 4411? Seriously.
Over recent weeks on here there have been several posts bemoaning Grayson's preferred 4-5-1 formation with only one recognised striker. There have been references to this being a negative formation and showing a lack of ambition with a clamour to play two upfront. Last week we battered Norwich playing with a 4-5-1 formation which makes the team create opportunities. In the two games since we have played a traditional 4-4-2 and have been woeful - this formation merely makes the players hope for opportunities. It is a lazy formation where players simply resort to humping the ball forward hoping for a knockdown. Can we please revert to the more positive and effective 4-5-1 immediately and let's hear no more from the Mike Bassett fraternity.
Did we not start to "batter" Norwich when Beckford and Humphrey were introduced? Hump went wide and Gally was thrown up front with Beckford, making it 4-4-2.
Until that point, with the ineffective Little as the lone forward we never looked like scoring.
That's how I remember it anyhow. Please explain.
How would we tell the difference between a 442 and 4411? Seriously.
Some people like to think they are some sort of tactical geniuses. No difference at all. Quite right.
This is 100% correct.Did we not start to "batter" Norwich when Beckford and Humphrey were introduced? Hump went wide and Gally was thrown up front with Beckford, making it 4-4-2.
Until that point, with the ineffective Little as the lone forward we never looked like scoring.
That's how I remember it anyhow. Please explain.
I see it more as Gallagher at the head of a central 3 with Reid & Humphrey wide and Beckford leading the line. In the first half Little was ineffective but Gallagher was also less effective. To me I don't see a huge problem with Beckford leading the line as Garner did if he has support from both wings with Gallagher behind. The traditional 2 up front of KD & JB is too predictable.
- Joined
- Jul 23, 2010
- Messages
- 850
We either keep faith with the side that played on Saturday, and I would because I believe this is just a blip.
Or as the above post says: bring Reid in for Davies and have Gally behind Beckford.
Either way we will have had 6 days to recover and prepare for a very winnable tie. If we're able to send out a similar side and win then it'll give our confidence a much needed boost.
Or as the above post says: bring Reid in for Davies and have Gally behind Beckford.
Either way we will have had 6 days to recover and prepare for a very winnable tie. If we're able to send out a similar side and win then it'll give our confidence a much needed boost.
Did we not start to "batter" Norwich when Beckford and Humphrey were introduced? Hump went wide and Gally was thrown up front with Beckford, making it 4-4-2.
Until that point, with the ineffective Little as the lone forward we never looked like scoring.
That's how I remember it anyhow. Please explain.
And me too...thought with Little up front (literally) it could have been February before we scored!