Skip to main content

5 points

5 points

It was an excellent, clean tackle and never a penalty...........................How the hell anyone applies " balance " to that is beyond me.
 
but it works both ways...............remember Port Vale?

btw if you are referring to the Port Vale game where Kilkenny got sent off instead of Garner (which at the end of day worked to our advantage but he still sent one of our players off) then the referee that day was also a certain Andy Madley. Ironically that day I'm sure Grayson, Kilkenny etc. even told him that they got the wrong man but he seems very stubborn ala yesterday and once he's made a decision that's final despite other people telling him otherwise.

He is obviously incompetent and it's just a good job Swindon didn't turn up at Wembley, otherwise he would've probably been centre of attention that day and it could've gone a whole lot differently for us.
 
Last edited:
what got me was the linesman must of clearly called him over to say it wasn't a penalty otherwise their would of been no reason to go over?
 
It is a disgrace that premiership referees are demoted to the football league for poor performances.

If they are useless then punish the ref, not the teams and fans of football league teams
 
what got me was the linesman must of clearly called him over to say it wasn't a penalty otherwise their would of been no reason to go over?

Arrogance.

I will listen to you but I'll ignore what you all the same. That basically sums up his actions.
 
It is a disgrace that premiership referees are demoted to the football league for poor performances.

If they are useless then punish the ref, not the teams and fans of football league teams

I agree - if you're too rubbish to ref a game (or are consistently making mistakes) why not have an enforced break, rather than be inflicted on lower profile games? Mike Dean was demoted in such a way, was given the Barnsley Leeds game and proceeded to give Leeds a pen for an accidental handball outside the area. Wonder where he'll be demoted to next and what a hash he'll make then.
 
Back
Top