Skip to main content

A benchmark game

A benchmark game

The "top 6 mini-league" that so many people seem to care about when we're doing well in the real league, is as follows (by my reckoning at least):

Swindon ..P5 W3 D0 L2 F10A7 Pts 9
Rochdale .P5 W2 D2 L1 F9 A6 Pts 8
MK Dons ..P5 W2 D2 L1 F8 A7 Pts 8
Bristol C P5 W2 D1 L2 F6 A6 Pts 7
PNE ......P5 W1 D2 L2 F3 A6 Pts 5
Sheff Utd P5 W1 D1 L3 F5 A9 Pts 4


PS: Swindon have played 4 of these at home, 1 away.

Sheff Utd have played 3 at home, 2 away.

Everyone else has played 2 at home, 3 away.


Fair enough, but to include Rochdale in the stats can be a bit misleading, given that 6th, 7th 8th and 9th are all on 30 points. And 5th place Sheff U are 6pts behind us.At the moment, it's probably more instructive to look just at the top 4. Then it all looks very tight. Not one game with more than a goal in it. Bristol City look the weakest. Swindon top the minileague by a fine margin, but have had 2 home games, unlike MKD and PNE.

By this measure, it's too close to call, at this stage.

BRISTOL
Bristol 0-1 Preston
Swindon 1-0 Bristol
Bristol 3-2 MK


SWINDON
MK 2-1 Swindon
Swindon 1-0 Bristol
Swindon 1-0 Preston


MK DONS
Preston 1-1 MK
MK 2-1 Swind
Bristol 3-2 MK


PRESTON
Swindon 1-0 Preston
Bristol 0-1 Preston
Preston 1-1 MK

MINILEAGUE
Swindon W2 D0 L1 6pts
MK Dons W1 D1 L1 4pts
Preston NE W1 D1 L1 4pts
Bristol C W1 D0 L2 3pts
 
Fair enough, but to include Rochdale in the stats can be a bit misleading, given that 6th, 7th 8th and 9th are all on 30 points. And 5th place Sheff U are 6pts behind us.At the moment, it's probably more instructive to look just at the top 4. Then it all looks very tight. Not one game with more than a goal in it. Bristol City look the weakest. Swindon top the minileague by a fine margin, but have had 2 home games, unlike MKD and PNE.

By this measure, it's too close to call, at this stage.

BRISTOL
Bristol 0-1 Preston
Swindon 1-0 Bristol
Bristol 3-2 MK


SWINDON
MK 2-1 Swindon
Swindon 1-0 Bristol
Swindon 1-0 Preston


MK DONS
Preston 1-1 MK
MK 2-1 Swind
Bristol 3-2 MK


PRESTON
Swindon 1-0 Preston
Bristol 0-1 Preston
Preston 1-1 MK

MINILEAGUE
Swindon W2 D0 L1 6pts
MK Dons W1 D1 L1 4pts
Preston NE W1 D1 L1 4pts
Bristol C W1 D0 L2 3pts

The mini league stat shows that we are not as bad as some people think against our promotion rivals.
 
The mini league stat is utterly irrelevant, and you can't get more irrelevant than that.

Utterly irrelevant? You'll need to explain that one Jonny.

The football league is obviously the most important one... but how you're doing against other cream of the division definitely has importance.
 
Utterly irrelevant? You'll need to explain that one Jonny.

The football league is obviously the most important one... but how you're doing against other cream of the division definitely has importance.

Explanation is simple. It's the points garnered (get it?) at the end of the season against all teams in the division that determine promotion. Finishing bottom of in a mini-league means nothing if you get enough points elsewhere.
 
Explanation is simple. It's the points garnered (get it?) at the end of the season against all teams in the division that determine promotion. Finishing bottom of in a mini-league means nothing if you get enough points elsewhere.

Your point is obviously correct in terms of the end of the season total but, part way through, it can help us interpret whether we "deserve" to be where we are and what our prospects might be later in the season.

What it shows is that we're holding our own in a competitive promotion race and there's no reason why we shouldn't be going forward with optimism. As it happens, this is what the actual league table shows. If we hadn't played any of the top 4 yet, there'd be a question mark.
 
Your point is obviously correct in terms of the end of the season total but, part way through, it can help us interpret whether we "deserve" to be where we are and what our prospects might be later in the season.

What it shows is that we're holding our own in a competitive promotion race and there's no reason why we shouldn't be going forward with optimism. As it happens, this is what the actual league table shows. If we hadn't played any of the top 4 yet, there'd be a question mark.

Agreed, one thing that I took away from Saturday is that we are more than matching/outplaying/competing against our main promotion rivals.

Last season we were not up to the standard of Wolves and Brentford, Wolves were the big fish who ran away with it and the most we got against them was a solid home draw. Brentford outplayed us twice and we couldn't beat Rotherham over 4 fixtures, these teams were very hard to beat and in some cases we created very little, this seasons seems to be different.

If MK Dons are being put on the pedestal as one of our greatest promotion rivals I am confident we can more than match them or anybody else in the division.
 
Explanation is simple. It's the points garnered (get it?) at the end of the season against all teams in the division that determine promotion. Finishing bottom of in a mini-league means nothing if you get enough points elsewhere.

Listen mate... I spent at least 10 minutes of my valuable time working out that minileague... so I'm going to defend it to the hilt!
 
Back
Top