Skip to main content

A divided support

A divided support

raefil

Dolly Patron
Joined
Jan 11, 2005
Messages
111,076
Seems to me that our leaders have quite succesfully managed to divide and rule our supporters completely over the past 3 or 4 years. We spend an awful lot of time squabbling over managers etc when maybe we should all be looking a whole lot deeper at what is happening to our club.

Was just chatting with someone else and they quite correctly said, "The silence from the top is deafening." We hear nothing, havent done so for many years in truth. Just fed little snippets, like "Become Ambassadors." Perhaps its time we all united a little and started to demand some answers.

What is our owners intentions for our club? Is he genuinely a saviour? or is he, like some say, just running the club into the ground?

I think the time is coming to form some type of action group were the fans of this club can get together and start to demand some answers instead of, like we are at the moment, arguing and Bickering about theories.

Anyway those are my thoughts for tonight. bottom line is we all want the same thing, our club to look like its got some stability and is genuinely challenging to get back a) into the championship and B) having a genuine tilt at the Premiership.

No-one believes we have the right to be up there but I honestly believe we are a big enough club to be making a genuine effort.

I feel, at the moment, we are more likely, over the next few years, to be fighting basement battles rather than promotion battles. Thats not good enough.
 
To be honest it has been a lot longer than that, I could probably trace it back to the void after Brian Gray and David Moyes.

For me when it first became truly damaging was in the final days of Billy Davies and the ensuing expectations (recalling that some would say Davies lost interest and threw the semi with Leeds - for example)
 
Seems to me that our leaders have quite succesfully managed to divide and rule our supporters completely over the past 3 or 4 years. We spend an awful lot of time squabbling over managers etc when maybe we should all be looking a whole lot deeper at what is happening to our club.

Was just chatting with someone else and they quite correctly said, "The silence from the top is deafening." We hear nothing, havent done so for many years in truth. Just fed little snippets, like "Become Ambassadors." Perhaps its time we all united a little and started to demand some answers.

What is our owners intentions for our club? Is he genuinely a saviour? or is he, like some say, just running the club into the ground?

I think the time is coming to form some type of action group were the fans of this club can get together and start to demand some answers instead of, like we are at the moment, arguing and Bickering about theories.

Anyway those are my thoughts for tonight. bottom line is we all want the same thing, our club to look like its got some stability and is genuinely challenging to get back a) into the championship and B) having a genuine tilt at the Premiership.

No-one believes we have the right to be up there but I honestly believe we are a big enough club to be making a genuine effort.

I feel, at the moment, we are more likely, over the next few years, to be fighting basement battles rather than promotion battles. Thats not good enough.

I agree but how would a group of supporters do/change anything?

Hemmings is a fucking tyrant.
 
I agree but how would a group of supporters do/change anything?

Hemmings is a fucking tyrant.

Bournemouth fans got what they wanted. They put some real pressure on their chairman and he delivered. They only achieved it though by pretty much intimidating the chairman into doing so. But then again their chairman is a fan. I'm sure similar action by our fans would have the opposite effect.
 
Seems to me that our leaders have quite succesfully managed to divide and rule our supporters completely over the past 3 or 4 years. We spend an awful lot of time squabbling over managers etc when maybe we should all be looking a whole lot deeper at what is happening to our club.

Was just chatting with someone else and they quite correctly said, "The silence from the top is deafening." We hear nothing, havent done so for many years in truth. Just fed little snippets, like "Become Ambassadors." Perhaps its time we all united a little and started to demand some answers.

What is our owners intentions for our club? Is he genuinely a saviour? or is he, like some say, just running the club into the ground?

I think the time is coming to form some type of action group were the fans of this club can get together and start to demand some answers instead of, like we are at the moment, arguing and Bickering about theories.

Anyway those are my thoughts for tonight. bottom line is we all want the same thing, our club to look like its got some stability and is genuinely challenging to get back a) into the championship and B) having a genuine tilt at the Premiership.

No-one believes we have the right to be up there but I honestly believe we are a big enough club to be making a genuine effort.

I feel, at the moment, we are more likely, over the next few years, to be fighting basement battles rather than promotion battles. Thats not good enough.

Don't you recall the Hemmings 'interview' in the LEP, last season was it? That was in response to calls from fans that we didn't know what his intentions were. In truth, I think it was little more than a hurried phone conversation with the LEP and only trotted out his previous assurance that he is 'committed to the club', or words to that effect.

Personally, I don't think we are going anywhere under TH's stewardship. If he pulled the plug then at least we'd hopefully do a Chester/Wimbledon and start to build again. No guarantee of that of course but maybe even that would be better than the current stagnation?
 
I think since the Simpson era the fans have had a distinct divide.

Everytime we appoint a manager there is instantly those who write him off whilst others will unconditionally back him to the hilt. The former will bicker with the latter and vice versa.

However, I have never seen a manager divide sets of fans quite like Westley.
 
Complete nonsense Raefy. Let's ignore that selecting Simonsen and taking off Beavon cost us the win last night and instead blame Hemmings!
 
Complete nonsense Raefy. Let's ignore that selecting Simonsen and taking off Beavon cost us the win last night and instead blame Hemmings!

Don't often agree with you but bang on, taking Beavon off when he was causing all kinds of trouble was crazy and Simonsen was at fault for their winner.
 
Complete nonsense Raefy. Let's ignore that selecting Simonsen and taking off Beavon cost us the win last night and instead blame Hemmings!
Could you expand on what, in your opinion, is nonsense? You want to look at the now, wheras some of us can see that its not JUST now where the problem is. I still look back at those incidents against Leeds. The "Job done" comment, the sitting out in the dugout by Davies. Its like seismic change in the fortunes of our club began at that stage. We went from being a club that brought players in to improve and push for the prem to a club that reacted only to a threat of relegation. From Simpson right down to Westley we seem, as a club, to react when things are looking grim as opposed to a club that is preparing for a bright future. Even the acquistion of our latest striker seems to be a response to a bad situation as opposed to a positive push for a realistic promotion push.

Yeh yeh we know you, and youre not alone, want Westley out but thats for other discussions, lets foronce try and see the bigger picture and realise that this isnt a new situation but one thats been present, for whatever reason, for a long time in our club.
 
I get the impression that the reason for the silence is because Hemmings and Ridsdale have total confidence that Westley will turn things around, as whenever Ridsdale does speak he always refers to Westley's previous achievements, however, that doesn't give him a divine right to achieve here. We are a higher profile club that Stevenage and the pressures are far higher here - at Stevenage the demand from the supporters would have much lower and the players would have had time to settle and develop before putting together their success. Here, at PNE, the frustrations are at the highest they've ever been and as a result that is expressed in a clear way and whether these players have the character to deal with that, whilst also trying to form a strong bond, is questionable?

The purists of the game, will never fully accept Westley, whether that be in the media or within our own fan base and Westley may be tapping into that, through forging a siege mentality, although, we've all experienced how demanding our support can be and whether Ridsdale can ride through that, time will tell?

I honestly don't think that we are far off. I'm as tired as anyone of seeing these results and performances, however, I do see positive results around the corner and patience may be the real winner here. Of course, Ridsdale could respond to a section of our support and take ultimate action and sack Westley, however, would an incoming manager be able to drive the club on? We had hope when Ferguson and Brown came in, as both had achieved at their previous clubs, and what happened?
 
Could you expand on what, in your opinion, is nonsense? You want to look at the now, wheras some of us can see that its not JUST now where the problem is. I still look back at those incidents against Leeds. The "Job done" comment, the sitting out in the dugout by Davies. Its like seismic change in the fortunes of our club began at that stage. We went from being a club that brought players in to improve and push for the prem to a club that reacted only to a threat of relegation. From Simpson right down to Westley we seem, as a club, to react when things are looking grim as opposed to a club that is preparing for a bright future. Even the acquistion of our latest striker seems to be a response to a bad situation as opposed to a positive push for a realistic promotion push.

Yeh yeh we know you, and youre not alone, want Westley out but thats for other discussions, lets foronce try and see the bigger picture and realise that this isnt a new situation but one thats been present, for whatever reason, for a long time in our club.

What I mean by complete nonsense Raefy is the team selection, tactics, and decisions made during the game cost us last night. No deeper agenda at work at a higher level within the club. Coventry were poor last night and we couldn't take advantage, yet I think a better manager could have done so.

The way I see it, we are where we are because of a series of poor decisions.

- Sacking Irvine after a poor run of results despite the progress made up to that point. After taking us from relegation battle to play-off finish in 18 months he deserved more time;
- Appointing Darren Ferguson;
- Sacking Darren Ferguson too late when we were 13 points from safety;
- Appointing Ridsdale as chairman;
- Allowing Ridsdale to sack Brown after two league matches (a win and a draw) during Ridsdale's time at Deepdale;
- Appointing Graham Westley.

Lots of mistakes but sticking with Westley now would be another to add to the list. We need Ridsdale and Westley out and the chance to start afresh.

With a new, forward-thinking chairman, able to communicate with supporters and not banned from being a company director, and then a great managerial appointment we can still go forward under Hemmings. There are decent candidates out there - O'Driscoll for starters.

Ultimately what should decide Westley's fate is the answer to the question is he getting the best out of what he's got? I can't believe the supporters are really divided on that one because it would be defending the indefensible to argue that so many changes are necessary and that the team selections make sense.
 
Was such a weird night last night, from celebration in the 90th min to conceding 2 goals in the space of a min, I cant quite remember a game like it. Its hard to say it but I think we've just got to look to next season now (hopefully with a new manager) and start the rebuilding process again, I just can't take Westley seriously anymore.
Well done to all those who travelled instead of sitting in. I gave myself a pat on the back after paying to watch that shower of shit, We will be back!
 
Was such a weird night last night, from celebration in the 90th min to conceding 2 goals in the space of a min, I cant quite remember a game like it. Its hard to say it but I think we've just got to look to next season now (hopefully with a new manager) and start the rebuilding process again, I just can't take Westley seriously anymore.
Well done to all those who travelled instead of sitting in. I gave myself a pat on the back after paying to watch that shower of shit, We will be back!

Burnley away
 
I get the impression that the reason for the silence is because Hemmings and Ridsdale have total confidence that Westley will turn things around, as whenever Ridsdale does speak he always refers to Westley's previous achievements...

I think I am right in saying, Ridsdale hasn't said a dicky-bird about North End in public since he was disqualified from acting as a director.

So the current "silence" is not because of any "total confidence" in Westley's abilities - it's because for him to speak would be a breach of his disqualification.
 
What I mean by complete nonsense Raefy is the team selection, tactics, and decisions made during the game cost us last night. No deeper agenda at work at a higher level within the club. Coventry were poor last night and we couldn't take advantage, yet I think a better manager could have done so.

The way I see it, we are where we are because of a series of poor decisions.

- Sacking Irvine after a poor run of results despite the progress made up to that point. After taking us from relegation battle to play-off finish in 18 months he deserved more time;
- Appointing Darren Ferguson;
- Sacking Darren Ferguson too late when we were 13 points from safety;
- Appointing Ridsdale as chairman;
- Allowing Ridsdale to sack Brown after two league matches (a win and a draw) during Ridsdale's time at Deepdale;
- Appointing Graham Westley.

Lots of mistakes but sticking with Westley now would be another to add to the list. We need Ridsdale and Westley out and the chance to start afresh.

With a new, forward-thinking chairman, able to communicate with supporters and not banned from being a company director, and then a great managerial appointment we can still go forward under Hemmings. There are decent candidates out there - O'Driscoll for starters.

Ultimately what should decide Westley's fate is the answer to the question is he getting the best out of what he's got? I can't believe the supporters are really divided on that one because it would be defending the indefensible to argue that so many changes are necessary and that the team selections make sense.
Let me try and make this clear. There are numerous threads about Graham Westley, this is not onme of them. Take your blind hatred of him and move it on to one of those. This is to talk about our club as a whole.
 
I think I am right in saying, Ridsdale hasn't said a dicky-bird about North End in public since he was disqualified from acting as a director.

So the current "silence" is not because of any "total confidence" in Westley's abilities - it's because for him to speak would be a breach of his disqualification.

He isn't a director at PNE. The Board of Directors are Kevin Abbott, Anthony Hughes, Paul Newsham, David Robinson and David Taylor.

He is/was the Chairman of Football. Although his details have now been removed from the Who's Who section of PNEFC website.

He is perfectly able to speak to the press if he wants to do so as long as he clarifies that he is now basically a Football Consultant to Trevor Hemmings. I wonder how involved he is with transfers etc? I'd imagine that he filters all the calls and arranges deals.... just don't tell the FA about it! ;-)

You have to laugh at what a joke we are.

As has been said before, "We have an Owner that won't talk, a 'Chairman' that can't talk and a Manager that does nothing BUT talk!"
 
Last edited:
Don't often agree with you but bang on, taking Beavon off when he was causing all kinds of trouble was crazy and Simonsen was at fault for their winner.

What a pair of Simpletons BSK4EVER & PNE4EVER are. It was obvious to anyone that actually watched the game & has an ounce of football knowledge that Beavon was substituted due to being injured. But, hey you two just carry on with your anti Westley agenda & jeopardise yet another thread. Anyway, I have just extended the diversion, caused by your good selves, away from the original point of the OP & I will now cease. I agree with Raefil & his concerns regarding the management of our proud club from the top downwards. We have an owner who in my opinion has no passion or ambition for the club whatsoever & views the club as a burden that he cant wait to get off his hands. We have a Non Chairman who's sole contribution to me seems to be the introduction of measures to drive floating support away from the club ( Ticket cost increases, no cash turnstiles, no Half Season tickets {but who in their right mind would have been interested in buying one of those this season?} ) , the appointment of Westley & bringing shame on the club for basically being found guilty of being a thief. Not good is it? Sorry, but the refusal by Trevor Hemmings to communicate with his paying public is disrespectful to say the least & the lack of a mission statement & information regarding his intentions is contributing to the reduction in crowds. We are a rudderless ship & it is going to get worse. I have resigned myself to the fact that under the stewardship of TH we are just going to witness an ongoing decline with the annual sacking of managers who have gamely tried to reverse the trend. Unfortunately, there is no Fairy Billionaire Godmother out there that will save us from the inevitable.
 
He isn't a director at PNE. The Board of Directors are Kevin Abbott, Anthony Hughes, Paul Newsham, David Robinson and David Taylor.

He is/was the Chairman of Football. Although his details have now been removed from the Who's Who section of PNEFC website.
I know. But his disqualification is not about taking job titles off a website. He is not allowed to act as a director (or a chairman, obviously), and this is not just a ban on calling himself one, it's a ban on functioning like one.

He is perfectly able to speak to the press if he wants to do so as long as he clarifies that he is now basically a Football Consultant to Trevor Hemmings. I wonder how involved he is with transfers etc? I'd imagine that he filters all the calls and arranges deals.... just don't tell the FA about it! ;-)

Well, quite. I suspect Ridsdale wisely doesn't talk about Westley in public, because he cannot realistically do so without risking the appearance of flouting his ban, which is not something to be treated lightly.

What he does in his role as "Football Consultant" I have no idea, and I wouldn't want to speculate about it either.
 
I know. But his disqualification is not about taking job titles off a website. He is not allowed to act as a director (or a chairman, obviously), and this is not just a ban on calling himself one, it's a ban on functioning like one.



Well, quite. I suspect Ridsdale wisely doesn't talk about Westley in public, because he cannot realistically do so without risking the appearance of flouting his ban, which is not something to be treated lightly.

What he does in his role as "Football Consultant" I have no idea, and I wouldn't want to speculate about it either.

Quite.

It's an utter shambles really isn't it.
 
Let me try and make this clear. There are numerous threads about Graham Westley, this is not onme of them. Take your blind hatred of him and move it on to one of those. This is to talk about our club as a whole.

Sorry Raefy but my comments are highly relevant here because you seem to be suggesting Hemmings is to blame for us losing last night and I'm pointing out that this isn't the case at all. Sorry if I've proven you wrong but you should be used to that by now.
 
Back
Top