Skip to main content

Adavntage rule?

Adavntage rule?

Tark

The Gentry (RIP)
Joined
Jun 23, 2004
Messages
6,253
Location
Avenham
In the totally forgettable Oldham game, we saw a ref call back an advantage from about 8 seconds before. Today, about 5 seconds went by before the Ref called it back. In Rugby Union, this makes sense where the Ref keeps shouting 'advantage', till he shouts 'advantage over'.
Can anyone more familiar with the current rules inform me of what's going on, or is it just a Sepp Blatter moment that I'll carry on for as long as things are going my way, and when they're not, I'll blow my whistle to ensure they do?
 
In the totally forgettable Oldham game, we saw a ref call back an advantage from about 8 seconds before. Today, about 5 seconds went by before the Ref called it back. In Rugby Union, this makes sense where the Ref keeps shouting 'advantage', till he shouts 'advantage over'.
Can anyone more familiar with the current rules inform me of what's going on, or is it just a Sepp Blatter moment that I'll carry on for as long as things are going my way, and when they're not, I'll blow my whistle to ensure they do?

The ref can wait "a few seconds" to decide if an advantage develops for the side against whom the foul/infringement was committed. If no advantage occurs the ref can call it back and award the free kick. If an advantage does occur but the team fails to make the most of it, then tough!
 
In the totally forgettable Oldham game, we saw a ref call back an advantage from about 8 seconds before. Today, about 5 seconds went by before the Ref called it back. In Rugby Union, this makes sense where the Ref keeps shouting 'advantage', till he shouts 'advantage over'.
Can anyone more familiar with the current rules inform me of what's going on, or is it just a Sepp Blatter moment that I'll carry on for as long as things are going my way, and when they're not, I'll blow my whistle to ensure they do?

No set time as far as I am aware, just a refs decision to see where the current play takes the team in possession.
 
The ref can wait "a few seconds" to decide if an advantage develops for the side against whom the foul/infringement was committed. If no advantage occurs the ref can call it back and award the free kick. If an advantage does occur but the team fails to make the most of it, then tough!

Unless they are Wigan

I will never forgive the referee in the game we lost 4-2 at Deepdale when just before half time they got in round Lucas (who fouled his man) but the ball came to Barlow with an open goal at the Town End (that must be the biggest advantage ever) but he missed (which is surely his fault). What was worse is that not only was it pulled back for the penalty Lucas got sent off for denying an obvious goalscoring opportunity - which he clearly did not as the open goal was still there.

Generally though I like the rule and apparently it was implemented well when Browne tugged Baxter and then later got the challenge in but play got brought back for the original incident.
 
It needs to be implemented more. The number of referees who blow straight away for a foul, when the momentum is still with the attacking team despite the foul.......so I'm pleased to see that the refs are using it.
 
The one with Hugill was a joke. He eventually give them a free kick once Hugill made a good tackle, but instead of the free kick being where the original offence was he give it where Hugill made the good tackle a further 15 yards towards our goal!!

And on the ref he gave a lot of free kicks around the half way line but in and around the box only seemed to give them to the defending team. Basically taking the easy option.
 
A great rule that, as jcFartpants rightly points out,needs to be used more !
How many times are we screaming for play to continue only for the Ref to whistle and bring it back for a inconspicuous challenge ! Likewise, how often do we the fans complain about one of our lads fouling, only for the Ref to 'play-on' and give the advantage to the opposition ? Not very often I'd wager, we all know good officiating when we see it !
 
Back
Top