Alan Irvine
- Joined
- Mar 15, 2011
- Messages
- 2,171
Been Neil's number 2 at Norwich. Would you welcome him back if he was to return in the number 2 role?
Absouetly dreading this announcement if it is to come, worst manager we've had since I first remember going on.
He's a good coach, a nice chap, and I'm sure we can all agree that although his football was boring, we all thoroughly enjoyed the QPR game.
I'd welcome him back in a coaching role 100%
- Joined
- Aug 23, 2015
- Messages
- 4,632
Been Neil's number 2 at Norwich. Would you welcome him back if he was to return in the number 2 role?
Absolutely dreading this announcement if it is to come, worst manager we've had since I first remember going on.
I'd be happy to have Irvine back as a number 2, but I think we should move on. I'd much rather we retain Thompson. To say Irvine is the worst manager PNE have had in your time attending is ridiculous.
- Joined
- Aug 19, 2016
- Messages
- 144
Been Neil's number 2 at Norwich. Would you welcome him back if he was to return in the number 2 role?
Absouetly dreading this announcement if it is to come, worst manager we've had since I first remember going on.
I'm sure graham Wesley was worst than Alan Irvine I actually thought Irvine did well for us and was unlucky to be sacked at the time
He's a good coach, a nice chap, and I'm sure we can all agree that although his football was boring, we all thoroughly enjoyed the QPR game.
I'd welcome him back in a coaching role 100%
Sums it up for me ............
An old friend who was coached by AI at Blackburn spoke very highly of him as a coach so I'd have him back.
Liberation
Forum Patron
I'd be happy to have Irvine back as a number 2, but I think we should move on. I'd much rather we retain Thompson. To say Irvine is the worst manager PNE have had in your time attending is ridiculous.
Not if the criteria was wasting money ....In fairness though, I'm sure all his employees were more than happy, content and very comfortable ( and well off)........... So on reflection he was a great boss.
Yes, highly regarded throughout football. He is only condemned by the decision to buy the Mecedonian Gerrard rather then that ex-Blackpool player - IF it was his decision!!
- Joined
- Dec 20, 2004
- Messages
- 8,612
I'm sure graham Wesley was worst than Alan Irvine I actually thought Irvine did well for us and was unlucky to be sacked at the time
Unlucky to be sacked? You must be fucking joking surely.
Nutty is usually reliable so hopefully he's correct regarding Frankie Mcavoy.
- Joined
- Mar 27, 2012
- Messages
- 500
Irvine was 'the wrong man at the right time' if that makes sense.
He inherited a team that was chronically under-performing, spent millions improving it and scrambled to a top six finish on the back of Wallace's brilliance, the likes of Jones and St Ledger at the back and a flash of inspiration getting Lee Williamson on loan.
What I think he CAN do is work on 'boring' things like team shape, organisation etc.
If (a big if) he was prepared to come back as assistant, he could probably do a decent job as long as he was kept well away from the acquisition of players and stayed on the field. His ability to organise could also cancel out a few of Alex's perceived shortcomings.
That said, was he not at Norwich when they nosedived down the table? Maybe we're being presumptuous thinking they work well together and would want to do so again.
He inherited a team that was chronically under-performing, spent millions improving it and scrambled to a top six finish on the back of Wallace's brilliance, the likes of Jones and St Ledger at the back and a flash of inspiration getting Lee Williamson on loan.
What I think he CAN do is work on 'boring' things like team shape, organisation etc.
If (a big if) he was prepared to come back as assistant, he could probably do a decent job as long as he was kept well away from the acquisition of players and stayed on the field. His ability to organise could also cancel out a few of Alex's perceived shortcomings.
That said, was he not at Norwich when they nosedived down the table? Maybe we're being presumptuous thinking they work well together and would want to do so again.
preach
boid swatter
Get him back asap.
- Joined
- Aug 19, 2016
- Messages
- 144
Unlucky to be sacked? You must be fucking joking surely.
Nutty is usually reliable so hopefully he's correct regarding Frankie Mcavoy.
At the time yes I did think he was unlucky and lot of people thought the same fergie junior took over and that's when results really went downhill which in the end under brown we ended up relegated Irvine would of kept us up every time imo
I'd be happy to have Irvine back as a number 2, but I think we should move on. I'd much rather we retain Thompson. To say Irvine is the worst manager PNE have had in your time attending is ridiculous.
Thompson is the first team coach and is being retained, there is still room for a number 2 to replace Snodin. However I doubt it will be Irvine because a) not sure Hemmings would want him back at the club and b) I read earlier that he quit Norwich at the end of the season because he had got the bug for management again following his spell as caretaker.
There is no current place for him.
There is no current place for him.
Are you talking about just Irvine here or about Neil appointing a No2 & maybe a chief Scout whoever that is?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Irvine's record as a manager is carp but he is highly regarded as a great coach. Did well at all of his club's ad a coach. Think we need a recognised 2nd in command. Not sure that we need Irvine to do 1st team coach role while we have Steve Thompson
Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk
Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk
- Joined
- Jun 10, 2004
- Messages
- 16,890
Not for me, for me it has to be Steve Thompson as 1st team coach. I remember listening to Radio Norfolk 2 days before we played Norwich at Carrow Road last season and beat them 1-0, AN said he had sent AI to watch us 3 or 4 times so they would know what to expect and how to handle us. AI didn't do too good a job did he!
There is no current place for him.
We already have an electrician.