Skip to main content

Alex Neil

Alex Neil

Joined
Feb 12, 2005
Messages
6,007
Read a few postings that he should be sacked or living close to it.

Want to point out a few things:

McGuire and Burke injuries just before the season start. If that would have happened a month earlier we could have got reinforcements but difficult when it's that close to the season start. Additional strikers when those 2 were fit would have been way too many strikers.

Pearson/Ledson suspensions: yes self inflicted but created more key absences.

Lots of new signings: not experienced Championship players who will need the best part of a season to acclimatise. There's no patience amongst fans these days for this but it's a reality.

I wish Trevor and Alex would refrain from talking about Premiership ambitions, creates a false expectation for many fans.
 
Guessing you're talking about Bodin and not Burke (and Maguire).

I agree that it's a very tough job to do with the tools at his disposal, 7th was a big overachievement given that. Our 7 summer signings had 4 Championship appearances between them (Barker's handful of loan appearances at Rotherham).

There's nothing wrong with signing these types of players, but it amounts to building as the season goes on as they gain experience, rather than truly being able to challenge from the word go, which makes it very hard to challenge for promotion.

Another problem is that when these players do come good and become experienced, some of them are then sold and then replaced by inexperienced players who will take time to improve, so the starting 11 is weakened and you cannot challenge.

Average age of the starting 11 today was 23.4. The oldest outfield players were Johnson and Hughes (26) before Gallagher came on.

Not an easy task when a lot of the players aren't very experienced, and some of the more experienced ones have unperformed or been unavailable. I'd love us to challenge for promotion from the league but it will require a change in policy from the top, and with our current policy I really doubt we'd find anyone who could do much better than Alex Neil.
 
I don’t think the pace at which we recruit helps the manager either. He wanted a CB and CM when he joined and only got them 12 months later. By January, when presumably we will look for a target man, will have been 12 months to replace Hugill with a physical striker.

Holds us back in terms of the different qualities we have on the pitch every week, not filling positions we are short in.

AN has his faults but as others have said, the hand dealt to him isn’t the best, and like the players he is also learning all the time against more experienced managers.
 
I’d sack Alex Neil if and only if there was someone available who, on our budget, can provide a better alternative in both the long and short term.

mick McCarthy, Sam Allardyce et al aren’t long term guys. And really would anyone be happy with managers who would set us up to finish 17th every year

thought the line up and subs were all good today, he was let down by Ledson and Hughes being inept, and Maguire not being 100%

add to that Robbo’s illness and Barky’s Knock, his hands were tied
 
Home win, away draw , we move up and look forward . Just for California pne 4 to go
 
Just read the LEP reports on yesterday. Like AN’s comments throughout. Calls things exactly as he sees them, doesn’t whinge about the issues with injury/illness and gave credit to the travelling faithful.
Have never had an issue with AN but have with the owner.
Continue to fully support our team and manager, next two games massive. KTF!
 
Keeper1;n3396002 said:
Just read the LEP reports on yesterday. Like AN’s comments throughout. Calls things exactly as he sees them, doesn’t whinge about the issues with injury/illness and gave credit to the travelling faithful.
Have never had an issue with AN but have with the owner.
Continue to fully support our team and manager, next two games massive. KTF!

This.

AN is bound to make mistakes along the way, but when he gets it right, we will be a real force to be reckoned with.
 
Lee Trundle;n3395952 said:
I’d sack Alex Neil if and only if there was someone available who, on our budget, can provide a better alternative in both the long and short term.

mick McCarthy, Sam Allardyce et al aren’t long term guys. And really would anyone be happy with managers who would set us up to finish 17th every year

thought the line up and subs were all good today, he was let down by Ledson and Hughes being inept, and Maguire not being 100%

add to that Robbo’s illness and Barky’s Knock, his hands were tied
what exactly would you call 'long term' though in football management, Lee? Is there such a thing any more? I don't think there is. It's all about the here and now. A lot of clubs bang on about three or five year plans etc but in reality, apart from maybe Bournemouth, how many clubs ever allow their managers the time to see these plans through? Personally I'm not a great fan of Neil at the moment and I don't share the views of those who were pretty adamant last week that we had turned the corner.
 
Dirty Harry;n3396031 said:
what exactly would you call 'long term' though in football management, Lee? Is there such a thing any more? I don't think there is. It's all about the here and now. A lot of clubs bang on about three or five year plans etc but in reality, apart from maybe Bournemouth, how many clubs ever allow their managers the time to see these plans through? Personally I'm not a great fan of Neil at the moment and I don't share the views of those who were pretty adamant last week that we had turned the corner.

I agree with you regarding the ‘turning of a corner’, what i saw yesterday was another poor display barring 20 minutes of the match. The fact it ended 1-1 is rose tinting the reality. Hull should have won by 3 goals and it was all too easy for them at times. I understand that we have conceded less with a more youthful back line but Hunts wouldn’t have been dominated in the air yesterday like davies and storey were by martin.
AN still hasn’t got us very well organised defensively despite the 1 goal shipped in 2 games. We did however play well versus Wigan but that performance has been too rare thus far. Im afraid im on the side of we are underperforming with the resources available and that is down to AN right now.
i don’t expect a top 6 push or anything but for me our squad i mid table comfort but its going to be anything but comfortable
 
Dirty Harry;n3396031 said:
A lot of clubs bang on about three or five year plans etc but in reality, apart from maybe Bournemouth, how many clubs ever allow their managers the time to see these plans through?

Burnley?
 
kbd_pne;n3395906 said:
I don’t think the pace at which we recruit helps the manager either. He wanted a CB and CM when he joined and only got them 12 months later. By January, when presumably we will look for a target man, will have been 12 months to replace Hugill with a physical striker.

Holds us back in terms of the different qualities we have on the pitch every week, not filling positions we are short in.

AN has his faults but as others have said, the hand dealt to him isn’t the best, and like the players he is also learning all the time against more experienced managers.

All excellent points. Right back cover is another one, too.
 
Minimum of severn points from our next four games or it might be time to let Neil go. This is realistically achievable given the opposition.
 
Back
Top