Skip to main content

An Honest question

An Honest question

Poll Poll An Honest question

  • FA Cup Final

    Votes: 100 51.8%
  • Promotion

    Votes: 93 48.2%

  • Total voters
    193

raefil

Dolly Patron
Joined
Jan 11, 2005
Messages
111,063
If you had the choice would you choose a Wembley FA Cup Final or promotion to the championship?

In 1964, when we lost to West Ham in the final we lost out on promotion to to the Div1 by 5 points.

Its often been said that the knowledge of our cup final appearance rocked out league form. We only won 1 of our last 4 games drawing 1 and losing 2. The draw and the 2 losses would have been 5 points.

So, what would you honestly choose?
 
Ive gone for cup final. Ive seen several promotions, in my lifetime but only 1 cup final.
 
Easily promotion. Have to say though I want us to win EVERY game. This 'cup gets in the way' attitude is bullshit.

Remember cesspool after we beat them saying 'it's only the CC'? They still brought 5000, so it obviously mattered.

SG said on the back of the LEP (Thursday if memory serves me correct) that he doesn't see it as a problem, even for Fulham today, had they won it would have been a confidence booster for their next prem fixture.

For every argument that the cup is an obstruction, there's the flip side of the coin - an argument that it could be somewhat beneficial.
 
Cup Final everyday, once in a lifetime experience that we wouldn't repeat for a long time. Promotion is nothing when compared to the Cup Final, shocked that anyone would see it differently.
 
Consider Preferences:

1/. Promotion to Championship or the Cup - Possibly the Cup preferred.

2/. Promotion to Premiership or Cup. Big money at stake in the Premiership - so owners would probably say promotion.

So - some PNE fans may possibly say the Cup - Forrest owners would probably say promotion to Premiership - as would possibly the bonus opportunities for Davies and his cohorts.
 
I find it hard to believe that anyone would choose promotion!

It'd be an FA Cup final FFS. Promotions come and go.
 
Promotion.

Unfortunately the FA Cup is now a joke as all the top teams are allowed to play their reserve teams. (In some cases even their second reserve teams!)

The FA are now powerless over the Prem 🙁
 
FA Cup Final, no question.

Promotion is nothing compared to one of the biggest trophies in club football.
 
The Fa Cup Final; this would be a historical event that would go into the history books .. and we can say "I was there"! When we reach the final again? Among another 50 years maybe ..
FA Cup Final for me, without doubt 🙂
 
Promotion is something that we would have a realistic chance of achieving any year we are in League 1 but to get to an FA Cup final would be a once in a life time experience for a club like ours.

Obviously there are posters on here that saw the '64 cup final but from this point onwards, given the climate of football in the modern era, it'd be a pipe dream.
 
Back
Top