Skip to main content

Andy Butler

Andy Butler

Personally though if we signed another centre half (probably the one area we don't need to strengthen) then I'd rather we went for a promising youngster from League One or Two who's already played +100 games and could have some sell-on value in 2-3 years.

Like Bailey Wright, e.g.?
 
We are a league one club in case you haven't noticed. Nugent hadn't played a single game above League Two level until we signed him and look at what happened then. He may be 30 but that means he would still have at least four or five years at this level in him for sure. I'm sure we wouldn't offer him that long anyway.

I like players/signings with Championship potential - the target for next season is promotion in case you hadn't noticed.
 
I like players/signings with Championship potential - the target for next season is promotion in case you hadn't noticed.

Who is to say he isn't? I was merely offering a suggestion which I think would be a good signing for the budget we have to work with. He would be an improvement on what we have currently which is a defence with the third best record this season just ended which signals our intentions for promotion.
 
You don't seem to have heard of many of the players mentioned as possible targets. I don't know why you think we might be interested in your ignorance.

I agree with the others that he might be worth considering despite the fact that he is 30.

You only have to look at my posts in the General Football section of this forum to see that I know what I am on about when it comes to identifying future stars, so I can assure I'm usually spot on when it comes to giving an opinion on a player.

This Butler fella isn't good enough.

Next.
 
You only have to look at my posts in the General Football section of this forum to see that I know what I am on about when it comes to identifying future stars, so I can assure I'm usually spot on when it comes to giving an opinion on a player.

This Butler fella isn't good enough.

Next.

Well how can he not be good enough if you have never heard of him? i'm pretty sure you had never heard of Ryan Giggs when he was first put in United's team and look at what happened. I'm not claiming Butler to be our saviour but I think, along with the majority of posters on this thread, that he would be a useful signing.
 
Well how can he not be good enough if you have never heard of him? i'm pretty sure you had never heard of Ryan Giggs when he was first put in United's team and look at what happened. I'm not claiming Butler to be our saviour but I think, along with the majority of posters on this thread, that he would be a useful signing.

Out of interest, how many times have you seen this 30 year old, lower league journeyman play?
 
I like players/signings with Championship potential - the target for next season is promotion in case you hadn't noticed.

Potential being the main word John, as opposed to someone who has played in the Championship and is now on a downward curve in their career. I would rather take someone like Jack O'Connell (20 year old 6'3" centre back from Blackburn) on loan than this Butler bloke.
 
Whilst it's great to get quality young players, sometimes you need an old head, a leader that an lead by example and organise. Particularly at centre half. I think we lacked that last season at the back and that the likes of Wright, Clarke and King would all benefit from playing alongside someone like Butler.
 
Butler is strong, steady, not afraid to go in on the tackle, has experience, scores a few goals and would be a good leader the only downside is he does tend to pick up 2 or 3 red cards a season.

I used to work with his mother, at Doncaster MBC (she was my secretary), when Andy was on school boy terms with Scunthorpe Utd and broke in to the youth team and therefore I have very closely followed his progress over the years.

IMHO we could do a lot worse.
 
Good player. Would be very pleased if we were to sign him. He's hardly a journeyman as some have said and at 30 we'd a few hood years out of him too
 
Out of interest, how many times have you seen this 30 year old, lower league journeyman play?

Good shout.

I've never heard of him to be honest but you get plenty on here saying what a good player he is and how we should sign him.

What is this based on?
 
Butler is strong, steady, not afraid to go in on the tackle, has experience, scores a few goals and would be a good leader the only downside is he does tend to pick up 2 or 3 red cards a season.

I used to work with his mother, at Doncaster MBC (she was my secretary), when Andy was on school boy terms with Scunthorpe Utd and broke in to the youth team and therefore I have very closely followed his progress over the years.

IMHO we could do a lot worse.
sheff utd bound
 
The very same Butler who was shocking when we beat them 3-0 at Walsall, Garner easily put him on his arse for our second, and again the very same player who was again crap at Deepdale when we beat them 2-1.

Our team down at Walsall included, Huntington, Byrom, Keane, Davies and Beavon with Wroe on as a sub, he is just a lump and no better than Clrake, Wright or Huntington.
 
Back
Top