Skip to main content

Ben Davies

Ben Davies

Joined
Jun 15, 2005
Messages
4,402
Location
Castle in the sky
Ben Davies scored the final and decisive penalty last night for Tranmere to dump Carlisle out of the cup 5-4 on penalties. Tranmere fans are beginning to warm to him, two of whom work in the same office as me. Tranmere wanted BD as a replacement for ex-PNE defender Matty Hill who is out injured (probably out for the whole season). So it is good that BD has been able to step into the place vacated by a player so much liked, not an easy task as there will be those who unfairly compare the youngster with Matty Hill. Also as Tranmere are a struggling League 2 side it is a fair bet that confidence is not as high as it could be in their dressing room. All these things the youngster has to contend with on top of working hard on improving his skills.
For the time being I think BD is playing at the right level, somewhere where he can shine and be stretched just enough to improve him as a player.
I'm pleased for him.
 
Yes Ben Davies is a real talent but it will probably be next season before he is challenging for a first team place here - though whether that will be as a fullback or a central defender is another matter. For now let him tough up a bit where he is.
 
I'm not convinced he will be challenging for a place in a Championship side next season (where PNE hope to be). His next step up would be a League 1 side.
 
I'll be honest here, from the little I've seen of Davies, I don't think he looks good enough.

He certainly doesn't look like a LB that's for sure.
 
He is a good young talent with potential but we did the whole it will be next season last season , what he needs is time and maybe he might be ready next season but maybe he never will be only time will tell . If we get promoted he may never be ready to step up to that level , at the moment he's playing for a very poor side in the bottom division he may have been better in a half decent side in division 2 . Not sure what finishing in the bottom 8 will do for his confidence or his progress .
 
He is a good young talent with potential but we did the whole it will be next season last season , what he needs is time and maybe he might be ready next season but maybe he never will be only time will tell . If we get promoted he may never be ready to step up to that level , at the moment he's playing for a very poor side in the bottom division he may have been better in a half decent side in division 2 . Not sure what finishing in the bottom 8 will do for his confidence or his progress .
When he went to York last season they were down near the bottom
 
He's 19, when Scott Laird was 19 he was on loan to Tiverton in God knows what league and David Buchanan had just been let go by Bolton, then was picked up by Bury at that age.

Way too early to start questioning if he's good enough for various levels.
 
He's 19, when Scott Laird was 19 he was on loan to Tiverton in God knows what league and David Buchanan had just been let go by Bolton, then was picked up by Bury at that age.

Way too early to start questioning if he's good enough for various levels.


Exactly , only time will tell
 
He's 19, when Scott Laird was 19 he was on loan to Tiverton in God knows what league and David Buchanan had just been let go by Bolton, then was picked up by Bury at that age.

Way too early to start questioning if he's good enough for various levels.
Agreed - seems to be a feature of some areas of this forum where young players are concerned.

Usually goes like this: young player comes into 1st team reckoning, instant verdict "not ready, send him out on loan for a year". Out of sight, out of mind. Young player does well on loan, but doesn't instantly set the 1st team on fire the next season, instant verdict "he hasn't 'kicked on' [a favourite phrase], so get shut".

Others from the recent past that were instantly dismissed by various experts include Jamie Proctor (22 years old, 4 goals in 9 starts this season in League 1) and Danny Mayor (23 years old, ever-present as Bury top League 2 ahead of Saint Beavon's current team).

Davies is 3-4 years younger than those two, and seems to have promise.

And if this club is ever going to "break even", it needs to start developing its own good, young players, not binning them off at the first sign they haven't 'kicked on'.
 
Yes Ben Davies is a real talent but it will probably be next season before he is challenging for a first team place here - though whether that will be as a fullback or a central defender is another matter. For now let him tough up a bit where he is.

have you watched Ben Davies play, he came back from his stint at York with a glowing report, however having watched him pre season and also this season I have seen nothing to suggest he can compete at the level we are playing at.
 
I'm not convinced he will be challenging for a place in a Championship side next season (where PNE hope to be). His next step up would be a League 1 side.
EXACTLY NOT GOOD ENOUGH AT THE MOMENT TO PLAY LEAGUE 1 AND TO BE HONEST i`M NOT SURE HE WILL BUT TIME WILL TELL AND AS YOU HAVE STATED IF WE ARE EXPECTING TO POSSIBLY BE PROMOTED HE WOULD HAVE NO CHANCE AT THAT LEVEL
 
have you watched Ben Davies play, he came back from his stint at York with a glowing report, however having watched him pre season and also this season I have seen nothing to suggest he can compete at the level we are playing at.

SG saw enough of him pre-season to choose him ahead of both Laird and Buchanan initially and comments on here said he looked better than either at times then as well. From what I have seen of him Davies looks composed on the ball and may eventually become a central defender like Sean St Ledger. But that is for the future - for the rest of this season learning how tough the game can be at Traqnmere might be just what he needs.
 
SG saw enough of him pre-season to choose him ahead of both Laird and Buchanan initially and comments on here said he looked better than either at times then as well. From what I have seen of him Davies looks composed on the ball and may eventually become a central defender like Sean St Ledger. But that is for the future - for the rest of this season learning how tough the game can be at Traqnmere might be just what he needs.


Any particular reason why Sean St Ledger ?
 
A lot of younger players seem to not develop, or meet higher performance levels expected from them in their 2nd season. Not sure why, but it happens a lot. Josh Brownhill is going through the same at the moment.
 
A lot of younger players seem to not develop, or meet higher performance levels expected from them in their 2nd season. Not sure why, but it happens a lot. Josh Brownhill is going through the same at the moment.


Josh was outstanding pre season before the whole how much is he worth and who might be in for him started , maybe we gave him a big head in some way .
 
A lot of younger players seem to not develop, or meet higher performance levels expected from them in their 2nd season. Not sure why, but it happens a lot. Josh Brownhill is going through the same at the moment.

Just watched the video of the Port Vale game - after coming on a substitute Brownhill has one of his 30-yard cracks at goal. Maybe being benched made him a bit more aggressive once he got on the field. A bit like Gallagher I think he needs a goal right now. That and maybe being used a bit more selectively in alternation with Welsh - who is perhaps also a bit sharper now than of late - may get him back on track.
 
Back
Top