Skip to main content

Better Without a Target Man?

Better Without a Target Man?

Joined
Jan 4, 2008
Messages
5,067
Location
Newcastle/Preston
Thought we played class for most of the first 70 mins today. Didn't quite happen for us in the first half, but came out all guns blazing in the second. Shit ourselves at the end a bit, but most importantly came away with the 3 points.

Personally, I'd like to see Davies dropped for the foreseeable future, at least in home games anyway. He was dire at Shrewsbury, and the team performance was uninspiring to say the least, although solid.

Today we showed that we are in fact a very good footballing side and I don't think it's a coincidence that Davies was not on the pitch. I think a Hume & Garner strike partnership is the way forward for us at Deepdale. I honestly think we looked like a side that is worthy of challenging the top 2, and that may well have been through NOT having a target man in the side. We were more inclined to pass the ball around rather than just hoof it up. Thought Kilkenny had a great game today; very good passer of the ball.

Grayson proved those people wrong today that complained about him having to play a target man, and fair play to him for that! Thought his team selection was spot on.

UTW
 
I think it's been shown that 352 with KD as a target man up front works away from home and so we should keep it there but I definitely agree that I'd rather see us play a 442 with Hume and Garner at home when we can.
 
Very good post.....and at 3-0 we all said the same, Davies should be used for away games etc. But the last 20 mins showed us why SG plays KD. Someone up front who could hold up the ball. Its a difficult balancing act but it seems if we play fast flowing attacking football,with this current squad, we will concede goals.Squeaky bum time I think. I think we need a vastly experianced C/H playing todays exciting system. I thought BW and JK struggled today.
 
Last edited:
Very good post.....and at 3-0 we all said the same, Davies should be used for away games etc. But the last 20 mins showed us why SG plays KD. Someone up front who could hold up the ball. Its a difficult balancing act but it seems if we play fast flowing attacking football,with this current squad, we will concede goals.Squeaky bum time I think. I think we need a vastly experianced C/H playing todays exciting system. I thought BW and JK struggled today.

Agreed. What I would like to see is super Tommy Clarke & Bailey Wright as our CB pairing and then a pacey, attacking RB (new signing). That would improve our team massively IMO, because Clarke isn't the best at going forward but is an absolute rock at the back; I feel his best position is CB.
 
Last edited:
I think Garner is pretty handy in the air, the plus side being that he isn't a target man and nothing else (a la Davies).

Aye, he does win his fair share of headers. Hume, although only 5'7, has got a cracking leap on him as well.

I think Garner could prosper playing alongside Hume and could well be our 20 goal a season man; I guess we will have to wait and see!
 
If Garner, Beavon & Hume are all match fit, Davies shouldn't be on the pitch. He's probably a fantastic guy to have around the changing room but on the pitch he literally adds bare minimum to our team. We play so much better when he isn't on.
 
If Garner, Beavon & Hume are all match fit, Davies shouldn't be on the pitch. He's probably a fantastic guy to have around the changing room but on the pitch he literally adds bare minimum to our team. We play so much better when he isn't on.

This, even when he came on yesterday he was utter shite. Think hes best when the game is scrappy from the start, he doesnt really fit in when we are playing good football.
 
It's best that we have both options and let Grayson decide what formation to play.

He's doing quite well if you hadn't noticed.
 
I think it's been shown that 352 with KD as a target man up front works away from home and so we should keep it there but I definitely agree that I'd rather see us play a 442 with Hume and Garner at home when we can.

Are we a good enough team to cope with constantly changing formation and line up though? Some players can't cope with being in then out of the team and be able to 'pick up where they left off'
 
It was a poor decision to take a striker off and absorb pressure and Davies coming on held the ball up well. I thought first half we didn't look good but when in full flow yes we look better without Davies.

Would like to see Davies in away games but at Shrewsbury he was the man doing all the tracking back and left Garner up top, no wonder at 36, he was knackered
 
Despite not being the tallest player, Garner is a Target Man.

Thought the combination of him and Hume worked well today.

Think he has moved himself up Grayson's rankings to being our first choice striker at the moment.
 
I disagree , I think overall Davies has been a class act this season , in the air he is our best option and he can trap the ball well and bring people into the game .

HOWEVER he can't hit a sodding barn door !

I would like to see him played behind the strikers in maybe a 4-3-1-2 ! Give him licence to stay forward find space and bring the forwards into the game !
 
Looks like Garner has scored in streaks throughout his career.

Even gets his booking in streaks too - 5 in 6 games at Forest!

On the face of it, there's no reason why those scoring streaks can't be extended. He should be coming to his peak in the next few years.

However, I'm sure that KD still has a big part to play this season.
 
This, even when he came on yesterday he was utter shite. Think hes best when the game is scrappy from the start, he doesnt really fit in when we are playing good football.

Totally disagree.

The stuff we saw under Westley was total shite.

Ok, it's not like watching Brazil, but we are a sound unit now and Davies has been and still is a key part if the success we have enjoyed.

I don't think any of our players have been utter shite this season and I object to your total over criticism of KD.

Get real.
 
Thought we played class for most of the first 70 mins today. Didn't quite happen for us in the first half, but came out all guns blazing in the second. Shit ourselves at the end a bit, but most importantly came away with the 3 points.

Personally, I'd like to see Davies dropped for the foreseeable future, at least in home games anyway. He was dire at Shrewsbury, and the team performance was uninspiring to say the least, although solid.

Today we showed that we are in fact a very good footballing side and I don't think it's a coincidence that Davies was not on the pitch. I think a Hume & Garner strike partnership is the way forward for us at Deepdale. I honestly think we looked like a side that is worthy of challenging the top 2, and that may well have been through NOT having a target man in the side. We were more inclined to pass the ball around rather than just hoof it up. Thought Kilkenny had a great game today; very good passer of the ball.

Grayson proved those people wrong today that complained about him having to play a target man, and fair play to him for that! Thought his team selection was spot on.

UTW

I think you are getting carried away, we certainly didn't play 'class' for 70 mins, first half wasn't that good really. Kevin Davies has a big part to play over the rest of the season not only up front but helping out in defence.
 
Kevin Davies has been a excellent signing and has played a big part in how our season has panned out so far. Is and still is a very important player for us imo!
 
I disagree , I think overall Davies has been a class act this season , in the air he is our best option and he can trap the ball well and bring people into the game .

HOWEVER he can't hit a sodding barn door !

I would like to see him played behind the strikers in maybe a 4-3-1-2 ! Give him licence to stay forward find space and bring the forwards into the game !

Thing is Hume missed some sitters also and has on several occasions this season
 
Very good post.....and at 3-0 we all said the same, Davies should be used for away games etc. But the last 20 mins showed us why SG plays KD. Someone up front who could hold up the ball. Its a difficult balancing act but it seems if we play fast flowing attacking football,with this current squad, we will concede goals.Squeaky bum time I think. I think we need a vastly experianced C/H playing todays exciting system. I thought BW and JK struggled today.

King was terrible yesterday I thought. He dived in at the half way line when it was 2 on 2 and left Wright having to deal with 2 of theirs, his headed clearances were only going 10-15 yards and in the 2nd half he hardly won one and mis hit quite a few clearances. It was about this time it was crying out for a dominant CB to step forward and clear everything and push us up the pitch. At times Kilkenny and Welsh were also most forming a back 6.

His passing out of the back decent though, so as part of a 352 he's fine but I'd prefer to see a 'proper' CB there, for now at least (King may become this in the future) so Huntington or Clarke in there for me.

This, even when he came on yesterday he was utter shite. Think hes best when the game is scrappy from the start, he doesnt really fit in when we are playing good football.

He wasn't though was he? He mis hit his first pass but after that did nothing wrong. Held it up well which is what was needed and linked up well with Garner a couple of times.

It's best that we have both options and let Grayson decide what formation to play.

He's doing quite well if you hadn't noticed.

I agree, it's amazing how much more the fans know than Grayson. Coming off yesterday I heard someone say that Garner and Gallagher are our only 2 footballers and the rest are cloggers.

Are we a good enough team to cope with constantly changing formation and line up though? Some players can't cope with being in then out of the team and be able to 'pick up where they left off'

This is also a good point. I often read a "play 352 away and 442 at home" but the consistency of our formations and team selection is playing a big part in us being at the top. We could all name 7 or 8 of the starting line up with some confidence, something you couldn't do under Westley.
 
Back
Top