Skip to main content

Birmingham Cheats!

Birmingham Cheats!

Joined
Jun 20, 2004
Messages
11,075
The ball is clearly out of the lines, pathetic refereeing.

cheatvn3.jpg
 
For all the people who said it was a dive for their pen, just seen it on tv and sledge had his arm wrapped round mcsheffrey as they fell to the floor, looked a definite pen to me.
 
Yeah, I saw the penalty on the championship and it is a penalty. Hardly a dive for the first one either by Mcsheffrey, had he gone down a second later it would have been stonewall in all fairness.
 
Yeah, I saw the penalty on the championship and it is a penalty. Hardly a dive for the first one either by Mcsheffrey, had he gone down a second later it would have been stonewall in all fairness.

Did they show the Bentner dive? It was so comical, he didn't even bother to claim for a pen.
 
The ball is clearly out of the lines, pathetic refereeing.

cheatvn3.jpg

It's not the Birmingham players I blame, but the referees lack of interest in looking, and it wasnt just riley, but surely having the ball a extra 12 inches, further the goal, makes no diffrerence.

As for that dive, why wasnt he booked?
 
The ball is clearly out of the lines, pathetic refereeing.

cheatvn3.jpg

Atky, speaking as a qualified referee, the rule is that, looking down from above, the ball is in the correct position as long as part of the line is obscured by any part of the ball. So even if the point where the ball touches the pitch is outside the markings, the ball can still be in the correct position. Same as for a goal...
 
Atky, speaking as a qualified referee, the rule is that, looking down from above, the ball is in the correct position as long as part of the line is obscured by any part of the ball. So even if the point where the ball touches the pitch is outside the markings, the ball can still be in the correct position. Same as for a goal...

Now I know I might need some new glasses, but can you please highlight the bit of the ball touching the line? And can you ever make a post without informing us your a "qualified referee"?
 
i take corners for my sunday team and take them well outside the line, easy enough to get away with in sunday league lol. it helps though i have scored 3 goals straight from corners this season.
 
Now I know I might need some new glasses, but can you please highlight the bit of the ball touching the line? And can you ever make a post without informing us your a "qualified referee"?

Yes I can. As I have many many times. But in this case I feel it's relevant.

As for the part about the ball touching the line. The ball isn't touching the line. But that's not the rule. I presume that you can see that part of the ball is overhanging the line. This means that the ball is considered to be in the correct position for taking the corner. The actual point of contact between ball and turf is irrelevant.
 
Hi you Pnesis's. Unlucky yesterday. About the best team we've seen at St Andrews this season. Grateful that your strikers don't know where the back of the net is. On another day, you shoulda taken the points.

Look forward to the return - but by that time, we'll be outa sight and you'll be trying to make the playoffs with the baggies, stoke, cardiff, sunderland and derby. We'll be top with southampton 2nd.

Keep Right On.
 
Hi you Pnesis's. Unlucky yesterday. About the best team we've seen at St Andrews this season. Grateful that your strikers don't know where the back of the net is. On another day, you shoulda taken the points.

Look forward to the return - but by that time, we'll be outa sight and you'll be trying to make the playoffs with the baggies, stoke, cardiff, sunderland and derby. We'll be top with southampton 2nd.

Keep Right On.


I did think that was a sensible post, until your drival about being "outta sight", I think you will be there or there abouts, but very much doubt you will be miles away, as if mcsheffey gets injured your screwed!
 
Thats because of qualified referee must have some sort of poor eyesight like the rest of them!

I know referees sometimes get it wrong, sometimes think the crowd are there to see them etc. But please, if you're spending a lot of time watching football, at least read the rules. As with a goal, if the ball hasn't completely crossed the line (and here, part of the ball is overhanging the line, so it hasn't completely crossed), it's not a goal or out of the corner arc respectively.
 
Although the ball isn't touching the line, some of it is hanging over. I wasn't happy yesterday though when he kept doing it.

Isn't it a bit pathetic, though, that players do this in the first place? What difference will it make to move the ball an extra nich, or even half inch just to get the ball sat nicely on the line?

They only do it to push the ref and wind the fans up, it's stupid. 🙄
 
It's not the Birmingham players I blame, but the referees lack of interest in looking, and it wasnt just riley, but surely having the ball a extra 12 inches, further the goal, makes no diffrerence.

As for that dive, why wasnt he booked?

You say that the 12" doesnt make a difference, it doesnt but then what is the point in the markings on the pitch if they are going to be ignored?
 
The ball is in correct possition, end of that. The first "dive" from Shefrey was a DIVE, went before anyone had touched him, should have ben booked as he was looking for a penalty. Then Alexander`s "foul", what a soft decision??? And at the end, the penalty!! That is one of the softest pens you`ll ever see. St Ledger shouldered him and then they BOTH got in a tangle with arms around each other. It was as much a pen as what it was a foul fo us. Riley blew his wistle before they even touched the floor, that`s how much he wanted to give it, just incase PNE equalize. He wanted to make the last few minutes easy for himself. Just my opinion!
 
You say that the 12" doesnt make a difference, it doesnt but then what is the point in the markings on the pitch if they are going to be ignored?

What is wrong with you clowns?

If you read the post from the referee here he explains the rule clearly.

If you look down from above, is any of the line obscured by the ball?

It clearly is - so why is everybody arguing with him?

We were beaten yesterday because we didn't take chances, crazy conspiracy theories like this are not going help us win the game next time Nuge misses a hatful of sitters!
 
Back
Top