Skip to main content

Bizarre ....

Bizarre ....

Status
Not open for further replies.
Very interesting Tugg.

Prior to yesterday's loss, during the previous 15 league games, in this division, only Brighton had lost fewer matches than PNE.

So to sum up, the manager of a club that had one of the very best records over a 15 game span "fucks up big time fairly often".

Like I say, very interesting.

Thanks for the flattery, but it's not THAT interesting.

Like I said, when Grayson gets his tactics wrong from the kickoff (as he does fairly often IMO) he usually gets away with it because he makes changes to 'contain' the opposition BEFORE they can get into an unassailable lead. But when he makes the wrong decisions and can't act fast enough, or just decides not to change tactics, you end up with performances and results like the other day, Brentford away, Huddersfield away last season etc. And quite why he felt Beckford deserved to play ahead of Doyle is anyone's guess.

At home we should always play 2 strikers upfront and certainly never 1 upfront with a back 5 (or back 6 as it was at times, since we were so deep). Should have been Makienok or Hugill with Robinson up front for me, with Pringle on the left. Would also have Pearson further forward.

But these are just my opinions Bert, so please don't get too upset.
 
Thanks for the flattery, but it's not THAT interesting.

Like I said, when Grayson gets his tactics wrong from the kickoff (as he does fairly often IMO) he usually gets away with it because he makes changes to 'contain' the opposition BEFORE they can get into an unassailable lead. But when he makes the wrong decisions and can't act fast enough, or just decides not to change tactics, you end up with performances and results like the other day, Brentford away, Huddersfield away last season etc. And quite why he felt Beckford deserved to play ahead of Doyle is anyone's guess.

At home we should always play 2 strikers upfront and certainly never 1 upfront with a back 5 (or back 6 as it was at times, since we were so deep). Should have been Makienok or Hugill with Robinson up front for me, with Pringle on the left. Would also have Pearson further forward.

But these are just my opinions Bert, so please don't get too upset.

Aye you end up with bad performances, but the fact that you can only name three games shows that Grayson doesn't get it wrong as often as you think. A good manager is someone who is willing to change - Grayson starts with a team/formation and sometimes it might not work so he changes. Last season grayson did try to contain the opposition, but yesterday aside over the last few weeks/months we have looked a much more attacking team and have taken the game to the opposition. The fact that we scored first in both away games as well as creating numerous chances/shots says that. Grayson gets it right more often then not, because lets look at the facts - if he didn't he wouldn't be in a job.
 
Thanks for the flattery, but it's not THAT interesting.

Like I said, when Grayson gets his tactics wrong from the kickoff (as he does fairly often IMO) he usually gets away with it because he makes changes to 'contain' the opposition BEFORE they can get into an unassailable lead. But when he makes the wrong decisions and can't act fast enough, or just decides not to change tactics, you end up with performances and results like the other day, Brentford away, Huddersfield away last season etc. And quite why he felt Beckford deserved to play ahead of Doyle is anyone's guess.

At home we should always play 2 strikers upfront and certainly never 1 upfront with a back 5 (or back 6 as it was at times, since we were so deep). Should have been Makienok or Hugill with Robinson up front for me, with Pringle on the left. Would also have Pearson further forward.

But these are just my opinions Bert, so please don't get too upset.

He won't unless I post it. But not getting hysterical like most on here your post is spot on Tugg. Is there really only us that can see it?
 
Aye you end up with bad performances, but the fact that you can only name three games shows that Grayson doesn't get it wrong as often as you think. A good manager is someone who is willing to change - Grayson starts with a team/formation and sometimes it might not work so he changes. Last season grayson did try to contain the opposition, but yesterday aside over the last few weeks/months we have looked a much more attacking team and have taken the game to the opposition. The fact that we scored first in both away games as well as creating numerous chances/shots says that. Grayson gets it right more often then not, because lets look at the facts - if he didn't he wouldn't be in a job.

Still maintain the reason we have 'only' had 2 wallopings this season (that's wallopings, not bad performances) is because we have altered a poor choice of starting tactics before it was too late. That's not something to get excited about.

Why change tactics at home that have been working so well recently? The reason is obvious and Grayson admitted as much at the recent fans forum, when he explained in a round about way that he is a cautious manager who focuses on the defensive side of the game and WILL NOT CHANGE. It's a case of we start with a point, or what we have we hold. This approach will only get you so far.

It's all extremely frustrating.
 
Last edited:
Why change tactics at home that have been working so well recently? The reason is obvious and Grayson admitted as much at the recent fans forum, when he explained in a round about way that he is a cautious manager who focuses on the defensive side of the game and WILL NOT CHANGE.
Quick question: who came up with the tactics "that have been working so well recently"?
 
Quick question: who came up with the tactics "that have been working so well recently"?

Obvious answer, but you have ignored my so obvious question...why then change the tactics that have been working so well? A question which fits the title of this thread.

We keep coming back to the same niggling question, which is how far we can go with Grayson and his defensive (fearful), safety first approach to the game. Mid table in the Championship is not what I (or the club) are aspiring to, but I just can't see us getting much further.
 
Still maintain the reason we have 'only' had 2 wallopings this season (that's wallopings, not bad performances) is because we have altered a poor choice of starting tactics before it was too late. That's not something to get excited about.

Why change tactics at home that have been working so well recently? The reason is obvious and Grayson admitted as much at the recent fans forum, when he explained in a round about way that he is a cautious manager who focuses on the defensive side of the game and WILL NOT CHANGE. It's a case of what start with a point, or what we have we hold. This approach will only get you so far.

It's all extremely frustrating.

Games like brentford and leeds do not happen that often. Bare in mind across both game four goals where conceded being down to ten men. In fact against leeds that was the worst defensive display i have seen at home under grayson. In terms of the tactics yes they where questionable, but he still gets it right more then he gets it wrong otherwise he wouldn't be in a job. People said he shouldn't have played marnick saying it was too defensive minded, but what option did he have. Mcgeady and gallagher where both injured and humphrey not in the 18. He could have played an extra central midfielder but then that would mean no width. You can't blame him for going with that.

And leeds aside, which ever way you look at it we have become a more attacking team other the last few months. We have failed to score in one of the last 14 league games and that was against a side who game for the 0-0. Last season was frustrating as quite often we did play for a draw - the 6 clean sheets in a row came with 4 0-0 draws. Especially over the last few months i fail to see it. In the last two away games alone we have mustered up almost 40 shots between them. He has changed and stats/facts disagree with what you are saying.
 
Obvious answer, but you have ignored my so obvious question...why then change the tactics that have been working so well? A question which fits the title of this thread.

We keep coming back to the same niggling question, which is how far we can go with Grayson and his defensive (fearful), safety first approach to the game. Mid table in the Championship is not what I (or the club) are aspiring to, but I just can't see us getting much further.
Not every game is the same, where you can just bang out the same tactics as last week and magically get the same result as last week. No league club does that, unless they're so massively superior in terms of playing talent that it doesn't really matter what tactics they use.

Fact is, we're not that sort of team in this league. Quite the reverse, we're a bottom 3 budget team punching way above its weight.

Grayson sets the team up when it wins, so he obviously knows something about tactics that win football matches.

He obviously doesn't win every time - but I hope no one is seriously expecting that.
 
Obvious answer, but you have ignored my so obvious question...why then change the tactics that have been working so well? A question which fits the title of this thread.

We keep coming back to the same niggling question, which is how far we can go with Grayson and his defensive (fearful), safety first approach to the game. Mid table in the Championship is not what I (or the club) are aspiring to, but I just can't see us getting much further.

I'm sorry mate, but there was no defensive safety first approach vs Rovers or Bristol. You're picking on one game we lost and using it to justify your position. Your argument doesn't add up.
 
Still maintain the reason we have 'only' had 2 wallopings this season (that's wallopings, not bad performances) is because we have altered a poor choice of starting tactics before it was too late. That's not something to get excited about.

Why change tactics at home that have been working so well recently? The reason is obvious and Grayson admitted as much at the recent fans forum, when he explained in a round about way that he is a cautious manager who focuses on the defensive side of the game and WILL NOT CHANGE. It's a case of we start with a point, or what we have we hold. This approach will only get you so far.

It's all extremely frustrating.

Absolutely spot on Tugg. Well put. This is exactly how I see it and we have got to the 'so far'. I'd like us to keep going rather than tread water.
 
We keep coming back to the same niggling question, which is how far we can go with Grayson and his defensive (fearful), safety first approach to the game. Mid table in the Championship is not what I (or the club) are aspiring to, but I just can't see us getting much further.
do you even watch any other teams in this division? Who are the free flowing attack minded teams you seem to be comparing us to? Other than the multi million assembled squads of brighton and newcastle (and perhaps derby) every team seems to adopt a safety first approach.

Gary Rowett a perfect example at Birmingham. I see the zola revolution is working miracles there. Most teams play a possession style of football (slow build up from back) or a counter attacking style (giving up the majority of the posession to the opposition) Neither is built on attacking. But built on a defensive approach. Not conceding is the number one priority.

Graysons record of losing only 1 game when north end score first proves his tactics can and do work. We just need a striker who can stay fit, stay on the pitch or can stay in form.

We have lost 3 league games since mid-september. All three were when we had one less player (10 men vs shefield, 11 vs newcastle (plus ref), 10 men vs leeds). If you think losing three games in over three months is not acceptable (or isnt enough to challenge) then i think you need to stop watching north end. You'll never be happy no matter who is manager or where we are in the table.
 
Not every game is the same, where you can just bang out the same tactics as last week and magically get the same result as last week. No league club does that, unless they're so massively superior in terms of playing talent that it doesn't really matter what tactics they use.

Fact is, we're not that sort of team in this league. Quite the reverse, we're a bottom 3 budget team punching way above its weight.

Grayson sets the team up when it wins, so he obviously knows something about tactics that win football matches.

He obviously doesn't win every time - but I hope no one is seriously expecting that.

do you even watch any other teams in this division? Who are the free flowing attack minded teams you seem to be comparing us to? Other than the multi million assembled squads of brighton and newcastle (and perhaps derby) every team seems to adopt a safety first approach.

Gary Rowett a perfect example at Birmingham. I see the zola revolution is working miracles there. Most teams play a possession style of football (slow build up from back) or a counter attacking style (giving up the majority of the posession to the opposition) Neither is built on attacking. But built on a defensive approach. Not conceding is the number one priority.

Graysons record of losing only 1 game when north end score first proves his tactics can and do work. We just need a striker who can stay fit, stay on the pitch or can stay in form.

We have lost 3 league games since mid-september. All three were when we had one less player (10 men vs shefield, 11 vs newcastle (plus ref), 10 men vs leeds). If you think losing three games in over three months is not acceptable (or isnt enough to challenge) then i think you need to stop watching north end. You'll never be happy no matter who is manager or where we are in the table.


Good sensible, measured responses. Boggles my mind that people see things so wildly different to this. Fantasists.
 
Absolutely spot on Tugg. Well put. This is exactly how I see it and we have got to the 'so far'. I'd like us to keep going rather than tread water.

But on the other thread you suggest that "we follow the exact same path as Leeds" and sack SG and then go in decline for at least 5 seasons!
 
Wondering if SG has fallen out with Humphrey. He looks to be going out on loan, but for me he'd go in at RM ahead of Marnick.
It's well documented that Humph isn't the most popular but he does have pace and can get to the byline very well. Just more of a natural winger than Vermijl.

Just my opinion, of course.
 
Wondering if SG has fallen out with Humphrey. He looks to be going out on loan, but for me he'd go in at RM ahead of Marnick.
It's well documented that Humph isn't the most popular but he does have pace and can get to the byline very well. Just more of a natural winger than Vermijl.

Just my opinion, of course.
trouble is, when humphrey does get to the bye line there is hardly ever any end product and he usually gets a nosebleed and turns it back. At least Vermijl is capable of a step over or two and a shot, and he's no slouch eaither. So Vermijl over humps for me any day of the week.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top