Skip to main content

Bizarre ....

Bizarre ....

Status
Not open for further replies.
Wondering if SG has fallen out with Humphrey. He looks to be going out on loan, but for me he'd go in at RM ahead of Marnick.
It's well documented that Humph isn't the most popular but he does have pace and can get to the byline very well. Just more of a natural winger than Vermijl.

Just my opinion, of course.

The midfield does need some work doing to it in the medium term. We've got quite a few bodies, but the balance isn't always there and we find ourselves putting square pegs in round holes quite often. When Vermijl's played in midfield, he's even been asked to play on the left, which is daft considering that he's signed to be a right full back.

Hopefully Humphrey will be away in the summer, he was poor in the division below and fares little better in this division.

That said, consistency is a big problem for the midfield. The likes of Johnson and Browne need to start performing week in week out rather than going missing.

A lot of it does come down to Grayson and his tactics, and it'll be interesting to see how we line up against Burton, to see whether the new signings will change the way that we play. We certainly could have set ourselves up better against Leeds, and were far too respectful of a side that seemed riddled with a surprising amount of errors themselves. That ones on Grayson, and we need a reaction from him and the players against Sheffield Weds certainly.
 
The midfield does need some work doing to it in the medium term. We've got quite a few bodies, but the balance isn't always there and we find ourselves putting square pegs in round holes quite often. When Vermijl's played in midfield, he's even been asked to play on the left, which is daft considering that he's signed to be a right full back.

Hopefully Humphrey will be away in the summer, he was poor in the division below and fares little better in this division.

That said, consistency is a big problem for the midfield. The likes of Johnson and Browne need to start performing week in week out rather than going missing.

A lot of it does come down to Grayson and his tactics, and it'll be interesting to see how we line up against Burton, to see whether the new signings will change the way that we play. We certainly could have set ourselves up better against Leeds, and were far too respectful of a side that seemed riddled with a surprising amount of errors themselves. That ones on Grayson, and we need a reaction from him and the players against Sheffield Weds certainly.

Some good point's PNEFC_2004, why do we not play Vermijl as a right back, the positioned we signed him for, Baptiste could then play Centre Back, his main position, horses for courses or square pegs in round holes ?
 
Last edited:
It's clearly that Baptiste, like Woods, is the type of solid, out and out defender who Grayson trusts to play 40+ games at right back.

I'm not sure that's the case with Vermijl. I think SG sees him as more of a wing-back type than someone who can play regularly at RB in a back 4.
 
It's clearly that Baptiste, like Woods, is the type of solid, out and out defender who Grayson trusts to play 40+ games at right back.

I'm not sure that's the case with Vermijl. I think SG sees him as more of a wing-back type than someone who can play regularly at RB in a back 4.

But Baptiste is not a full back and it shows, was out of position for the 3rd Leeds goal, Clarke got dragged out wide and turned in side out. Baptiste is a Centre back,play him with Clarke and let Vermijl play at right full back , allowing him to bomb forward when we are attacking ?
 
In my view it's as simple as this...Grayson sets out not to lose the game, instead of setting out to win the game. That approach will not bring long term success.
 
In my view it's as simple as this...Grayson sets out not to lose the game, instead of setting out to win the game. That approach will not bring long term success.

You are correct about Grayson but to play an expansive, attacking approach you need to have the players with the quality to carry it off and if you do not you have to cut your cloth to suit I suppose.

Suppose we need to ask the question 'If SG had a squad with the quality of say Man City/Utd or Chelsea would his philosophy then change' ?
 
Good sensible, measured responses. Boggles my mind that people see things so wildly different to this. Fantasists.

So anyone who doesn't see what you see is a fantasist? How ignorant and arrogant.

And before anyone else comes at me and mentions free flowing attacking football, I've never once mentioned that.

I'm merely pointing out the obvious flaws in setting up to avoid defeat, rather than going out to win the game. But some folks don't want to see that, or simply can't see it.
 
I'm sorry mate, but there was no defensive safety first approach vs Rovers or Bristol. You're picking on one game we lost and using it to justify your position. Your argument doesn't add up.

It's not an argument it's an opinion. I'm not a lemming and won't blindly follow the popular majority without thinking for myself. But I will form my own opinion, based on what I can see with my own eyes and based on the words from our managers mouth itself at the recent fans forum I attended (when he was questioned about his tactics).

Thanks.
 
So anyone who doesn't see what you see is a fantasist? How ignorant and arrogant.

And before anyone else comes at me and mentions free flowing attacking football, I've never once mentioned that.

I'm merely pointing out the obvious flaws in setting up to avoid defeat, rather than going out to win the game. But some folks don't want to see that, or simply can't see it.

Haven't seen enough to comment on what I see but how do you explain the fact that we've scored 19 goals to 12 in the first half and the exact opposite in the second half?
 
Haven't seen enough to comment on what I see but how do you explain the fact that we've scored 19 goals to 12 in the first half and the exact opposite in the second half?

More goals and more points compared to the atrocious first half of the season isn't a yardstick I'd want to be using to measure success.

I guess you've forgotten the wonderful home performances against Burton and Wolves.
 
Last edited:
More goals and more points compared to the atrocious first half of the season isn't a yardstick I'd want to be using to measure success.

I guess you've forgotten the wonderful home performances against Burton and Wolves.

And I'm guessing you've forgotten the wonderful home performances against Villa and Huddersfield?
 
I'm merely pointing out the obvious flaws in setting up to avoid defeat, rather than going out to win the game. But some folks don't want to see that, or simply can't see it.

I think that strategy just reflects where we are at the moment with the quality of our squad. Our budget is one that should probably place us in the relegation zone in this division.

What would change if we switched managers ? I would guess that if a new manager arrived tomorrow, he would head into the game vs Sheffield Wednesday, who spent over 10 million pounds in the summer and pay strikers over 30 thousand pounds a week, with the intention of staying solid and not getting beat to begin with.

The new manager would then go to Burton, who are very good at home, with the intention of not getting beat and perhaps nicking something on the break, just like Grayson would.

Until the owner, or a new one in time, opens the purse strings a bit more on higher calibre players for the division, we will always be up against it in this league.

As Mark Lawrenson said in a podcast recently, we're 10 over par, so to speak, before kick off pretty much every single game at the moment. Being hard to beat is half the job, the other half would require us to invest is a top quality striker but that isn't possible given the state of football's economy/the transfer market right now and the policies of our owner regarding that market (and who can blame him).

So without wanting to sound 'defeatist', I think with the quality of player with have at the club right now, perhaps staying solid and hard to beat is the wisest way to operate for the manager ?
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the flattery, but it's not THAT interesting.

Like I said, when Grayson gets his tactics wrong from the kickoff (as he does fairly often IMO) he usually gets away with it because he makes changes to 'contain' the opposition BEFORE they can get into an unassailable lead. But when he makes the wrong decisions and can't act fast enough, or just decides not to change tactics, you end up with performances and results like the other day, Brentford away, Huddersfield away last season etc. And quite why he felt Beckford deserved to play ahead of Doyle is anyone's guess.

At home we should always play 2 strikers upfront and certainly never 1 upfront with a back 5 (or back 6 as it was at times, since we were so deep). Should have been Makienok or Hugill with Robinson up front for me, with Pringle on the left. Would also have Pearson further forward.

But these are just my opinions Bert, so please don't get too upset.

Not getting upset at all, but you post your opinion (which is fine) I post facts, which can't be argued with, yet you still sort of wish so to do?

Did you read and understand what I wrote? Last 15 games prior to Leeds only Brighton in the entire division has lost fewer.

What would our record be I wonder if we could only find a manager who did not get his tactics wrong fairly often?

My facts suggest Grayson does know what he is doing, your opinion is, well, just your opinion.

Think about it.
 
Last edited:
£Pound for £pound spent on players when comparing each and every club in the Championship I guess that Norwich City would be in a relegation place whilst we would be in a top 4 if not top 2 place. However, we do not have parachute money to rely on or 20,000 average home attendances so those who think that we should be up there with the likes of Newcastle, Leeds, Sheff Wednesday, etc are a little bit deluded.

As for the argument that Blackpool and Burnley achieve promotion to the promised land, it was a bit easier in that parachute payments were not as great and the number of teams in this division receiving these parachute payments were not as many plus there are far more clubs the size of both Burnley and Blackpool who haven't made it!

We are progressing season upon season with SG and his backroom staff at the helm however, this continued progression is obviously not quick enough for some. I guess that is down to the state of society nowadays with the 'I want it now' mentality giving no bit of notice how much it might put the club in to debt and how many steps it might put us backwards!!
 
£Pound for £pound spent on players when comparing each and every club in the Championship I guess that Norwich City would be in a relegation place whilst we would be in a top 4 if not top 2 place. However, we do not have parachute money to rely on or 20,000 average home attendances so those who think that we should be up there with the likes of Newcastle, Leeds, Sheff Wednesday, etc are a little bit deluded.

As for the argument that Blackpool and Burnley achieve promotion to the promised land, it was a bit easier in that parachute payments were not as great and the number of teams in this division receiving these parachute payments were not as many plus there are far more clubs the size of both Burnley and Blackpool who haven't made it!

We are progressing season upon season with SG and his backroom staff at the helm however, this continued progression is obviously not quick enough for some. I guess that is down to the state of society nowadays with the 'I want it now' mentality giving no bit of notice how much it might put the club in to debt and how many steps it might put us backwards!!

The progression stops once in this league as history shows us. At one point it looked like he had changed his approach but he's shown he's not capable of sustaining that. Try not to get beat and stay safe. Mid table for ever. Sorry but I want more.
 
Not getting upset at all, but you post your opinion (which is fine) I post facts, which can't be argued with, yet you still sort of wish so to do?

Did you read and understand what I wrote? Last 15 games prior to Leeds only Brighton in the entire division has lost fewer.

What would our record be I wonder if we could only find a manager who did not get his tactics wrong fairly often?

My facts suggest Grayson does know what he is doing, your opinion is well, just your opinion.

Think about it.

You do post selective stats to try win an argument though, you don't tell a full story. Why choose 15 games prior to Leeds, but not include Leeds itself? Is it because we lost to Leeds? And is it because we lost a lot of games prior to them 15 games?

Now if you said 10 teams have lost more then us this season, that's not being selective. It tells more of a full story, one that is we are probably a mid table team. That then leaves it open to interpretation whether Grayson knows what he is doing or not. Mid table for me is a good job in my opinion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top